Thoughts on McDermott’s timeouts?

[JGMcD2]

Just now, Shortchaz said:

I’m sorry I’m not a stat nerd, and I don’t know a good website to dive into this.
 

I intentionally used the word FEEL. 
 

The bills are winning but haven’t taken the next step, I believe they are starting to regress. Perhaps we can revisit this after next weekend. I’d be happy to be wrong 

Well you can’t use the word regress and not have data? 
 

Winning or losing next weekend isn’t really a good barometer to determine regression or not. 

[Over 29 years of fanhood]

He wins a lot. He’s got that going for him 

[Shortchaz]

Just now, JGMcD2 said:

Well you can’t use the word regress and not have data? 
 

Winning or losing next weekend isn’t really a good barometer to determine regression or not. 

You’re a nerd

[JGMcD2]

2 minutes ago, Shortchaz said:

You’re a nerd

Thanks!

 

Words have definitions for a reason. I apologize for properly using them. 

[RyanC883]

I think an important question here is WHY was the D out of position in two critical spots necessitating McD calling a timeout. And why didn’t a player notice this?  

[Shortchaz]

6 minutes ago, JGMcD2 said:

Thanks!

 

Words have definitions for a reason. I apologize for properly using them. 

You certainly have high standards for a football fan message board. Some might say too high; I say…high enough?.? 
 

(that’s not even how you spell pedantic)

Edited January 16, 2023 by Shortchaz

[1stgm1993]

Better question how did the pentacle flag never come out against Miami until they had no more time outs to give

plenty of times that ball was snapped after 0 and another 1-2 secs they give plus they are warned not to keep getting that close  

[Bermuda Triangle]

3 hours ago, NUT said:

If I was Pegula I'd hire whatever retired coach had a good challenge record and knew clock management. Take those gameday responsibilities away from McDermott.

Bring back Rex's chaplain.  He can manage replays and times out.

[Mango]

4 hours ago, Xwnyer said:

Both turned out to be terrible based on result of the play.  Not sure why he called timeout as time was expiring on the 4th and 1

I think he was trying to get Miami to show their hand with what concepts they were thinking. Maybe ice a rookie QB? 
 

When you go for it on 4th you bring your best play. You have to rethink it or run your second best play the next time. 
 

I thought it was odd for McD. But that’s all I could come up with. 

[QCity]

4 hours ago, GunnerBill said:

 

That play you HAVE to call timeout. They weren't just misaligned. They were not in any alignment. 

 

And that speaks to a bigger problem -- that can't happen in the most crucial moment of the game.

[ganesh]

3 hours ago, RyanC883 said:

I think an important question here is WHY was the D out of position in two critical spots necessitating McD calling a timeout. And why didn’t a player notice this?  

Remember the Dolphins were slow to getting plays in on the field.  May be the call game in late and the Bills saw that they were not in a position to defend it.

[Sierra Foothills]

Whatever you do, don't call him "McClappy" or post a link to this video:

 

 

If you do a total stranger will question your character.

 

 

[GunnerBill]

3 hours ago, QCity said:

 

And that speaks to a bigger problem -- that can't happen in the most crucial moment of the game.

 

Yea not sure what happened. I don't know if the Bills thought they were punting and had the punt team half on and then had to switch out? Not sure. 

[Saxum]

8 hours ago, aceman_16 said:

1 good and 1 bad. Needed a thread for this?

 

Of course. Every inane thought needs its own post.  Keeps clutter away from other posts hopefully.

[JGMcD2]

7 hours ago, Shortchaz said:

You certainly have high standards for a football fan message board. Some might say too high; I say…high enough?.? 
 

(that’s not even how you spell pedantic)

You’re right. 
 

Expecting you to have points to support your statement was ridiculous of me. 

[GunnerBill]

8 hours ago, Chaos said:

There seems to be no thoughts to McDermott's timeouts. Only coach in the league who calls a timeout to prevent the other team from getting a delay penalty. 

 

The thought on the 4th down one was the defense was not lined up. If the Dolphins ran that play better it was a touchdown. I'd need to go back and look again at the earlier one (on their one long touchdown drive where Edmunds made a tackle for a gain of 1 only for a TO to have already been taken on defense). 

 

His worst timeout of the day was the one on offense to try and get them to review the Diggs non-touchdown. That cost them a potential shot to the endzone and forced them to take a FG. That is bad time out usage. The 4th down one he honestly had to call. Okay Skylar made a crap throw but when your defense isn't lined up and there are guys still breaking the huddle on a critical down you don't say "oh well let it play out, maybe their QB will throw a crap pass."

[Shortchaz]

5 hours ago, JGMcD2 said:

You’re right. 
 

Expecting you to have points to support your statement was ridiculous of me. 

Dude…

 

I made my point in my first post when I said I FEEL. By saying that I’m letting the audience know that the statement is based on emotion rather than empirical evidence.

 

you asked me to expand so I gave one area (red zone efficiency) where the team has regressed (a word that seems to trigger you). You showed a 9% drop from last year then dismissed it as statistically insignificant. Fine.

 

I get that you love McDermott and I don’t hate the guy. I just FEEL like the team has gone as far as it can with this staff. I WANT to be wrong. 

[dakrider]

A defensive timeout should be egregious, not just some guy lined up in wrong spot.  And against Cinci where you might need those timeouts at end of a half, don't waste them.  I really wish there was a 3 second rule on timeouts, can't wait til the damn ball is being snapped to call a timeout! 

[Doc]

5 hours ago, GunnerBill said:

The thought on the 4th down one was the defense was not lined up. If the Dolphins ran that play better it was a touchdown. I'd need to go back and look again at the earlier one (on their one long touchdown drive where Edmunds made a tackle for a gain of 1 only for a TO to have already been taken on defense). 

 

His worst timeout of the day was the one on offense to try and get them to review the Diggs non-touchdown. That cost them a potential shot to the endzone and forced them to take a FG. That is bad time out usage. The 4th down one he honestly had to call. Okay Skylar made a crap throw but when your defense isn't lined up and there are guys still breaking the huddle on a critical down you don't say "oh well let it play out, maybe their QB will throw a crap pass."

 

I didn't have a problem with the TO to get them to review Diggs' almost TD catch, if that was the reason he took it.  And they still could have run a play because it's either a shot to the endzone or nothing at all since a run play would eat up too much time and possibly just net you a FG anyway.

[BernieBill]

Like most of Sean "Glory to God" McDermott's in-game decisions in big spots, he acted like a complete Spaz and screwed his team out of two great plays.  When Cincinnati comes into Buffalo next week and wins (a game the Bills are lucky to have at home as the Monday night game in Cincy was shaping up to be a Bengals rout), I sincerely hope more Bills fans will get on the "fire McDermott" train so that Bills Nation actually has a reasonable chance at cashing in Super Bowls with their generational-talent Quarterback.  McDermott is a coordinator at-best in the NFL, not a head coach, and certainly not the head coach of a team with super Bowl aspirations.