Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted
46 minutes ago, Mr. WEO said:

 

Far more people in this country have far more physically demanding jobs that are more dangerous and detrimental to their long and short term health than pro athletes.  Most take these jobs because they don't have the opportunities/choices afforded elite athletes.  For their efforts, these people get a modest paycheck and no post retirement healthcare.  

 

 

They do---for 5 years after retirement. 

 

The "average NFL career" is frequently cited as 3 years---but that includes anyone who got a single check from an NFL team at any time....so that includes a lot of "camp fodder"--guys who never make a roster (and rarely take a big hit in a game).  But we are talking about guys who at least are on an active roster for several years--these are the guys who are being exposed to the big hits--not the PS guys. 

 

Talley made at least 5 million from the Bills/Falcons/Vikings (plus the Bills payed him in the range of 50-100K for years to be one of their "legends").  That was pretty good money in the 80's-90's.  Easily could have stashed away a chunk for his later years.  Now apparently the money is gone.  Some years ago, there was a online fund drive (disclaimer:  I donated) when the story of his recent health struggles was published.

 

The point is that every players knows exactly what they are getting into from college ball to the NFL, as far as risks to their health.   They negotiate how much they are going to be payed to subject themselves to this risk.  They also know that, like nearly all nonmunicipal unemployed/retired adults under 65, that at some point their employer will no longer be paying for their healthcare.  They can't then, after leaving the game, complain that years later the NFL isn't paying for their health care needs, or that they "earned" something they were never due.  That's not how it works.

 

Those people are retiring for the most part after they already have Medicare for their insurance. NFL players are not retiring anywhere near Medicare age(well, except maybe for Brady and a few kickers/punters) and as such have much longer to go without health insurance.

  • Like (+1) 1
  • Eyeroll 2
Posted (edited)

Update from the gofundme page:

 

Today by Damar Hamlin's Team, Team Member

We're simply awestruck by the level of support and generosity we've seen over the past two days. With over $6 million raised, this fundraiser has become an overnight reminder of the incredible nature of humankind. Your actions directly reflect the type of human Damar is himself.

As representatives of Damar, the team at Jaster Athletes posted the fundraiser updates and will work with the Hamlin family, The Chasing M's Foundation, and the GoFundMe team to ensure the safe delivery of funds.

Because the situation is evolving, we'll continue to communicate any updates on the fundraiser. We will also work with GoFundMe to email all donors with more specifics regarding the use of funds as those details are available. As you can imagine, this has been a challenging time for the family. We appreciate your understanding as we give them the time and space they need to focus on Damar's health first.

We're hopeful about Damar's future involvement in disbursing the incredibly generous contributions. We thank you again for your support and look forward to updating you along the way.

Edited by Big Turk
  • Like (+1) 6
  • Awesome! (+1) 1
  • Thank you (+1) 3
Posted
5 minutes ago, YoloinOhio said:

I don’t think they will get any updates from anyone at UCMC.

I'm sure that we'll get updates when they have something to report. Right now, they have very little to report.

  • Agree 1
Posted
3 minutes ago, YoloinOhio said:

I don’t think they will get any updates from anyone at UCMC.

Agreed and I’m always leery of family members giving medical updates. Required a 2nd resuscitation at the hospital? A 24 year old super fit athlete with no prior condition died twice that night?? Seems unrealistic -especially so if the medical opinion that the hit caused the heart to be knocked off timing and stop..

  • Agree 2
Posted
1 minute ago, Chandler#81 said:

Agreed and I’m always leery of family members giving medical updates. Required a 2nd resuscitation at the hospital? A 24 year old super fit athlete with no prior condition died twice that night?? Seems unrealistic -especially so if the medical opinion that the hit caused the heart to be knocked off timing and stop..

Wasn't that report from hamlins uncle? 

Posted
3 minutes ago, Chandler#81 said:

Agreed and I’m always leery of family members giving medical updates. Required a 2nd resuscitation at the hospital? A 24 year old super fit athlete with no prior condition died twice that night?? Seems unrealistic -especially so if the medical opinion that the hit caused the heart to be knocked off timing and stop..

 

It was clarified after by Jordan that there was only 1 resuscitation and that was on the field and they wanted to clear up any miscommunication by his uncle.

  • Agree 1
  • Thank you (+1) 1
Posted
2 minutes ago, Chandler#81 said:

Agreed and I’m always leery of family members giving medical updates. Required a 2nd resuscitation at the hospital? A 24 year old super fit athlete with no prior condition died twice that night?? Seems unrealistic -especially so if the medical opinion that the hit caused the heart to be knocked off timing and stop..

The big issue is that doctors aren’t generally great at communications. A lot of good communicators don’t really understand science. So things definitely get lost in translation between the medical personnel to the family and the family to each other etc. 

 

That’s why I think they need a single spokesperson. But obviously they have more pressing concerns. I don’t think anyone is being intentionally misleading or seeking something by speaking to the media, they just aren’t the right people to do it.

  • Agree 1
Posted
4 minutes ago, Chandler#81 said:

Agreed and I’m always leery of family members giving medical updates. Required a 2nd resuscitation at the hospital? A 24 year old super fit athlete with no prior condition died twice that night?? Seems unrealistic -especially so if the medical opinion that the hit caused the heart to be knocked off timing and stop..

UCMC just clarified that what the uncle said is incorrect and he “only” needed to be  resuscitated once on the field. 

  • Thank you (+1) 2
Posted
1 hour ago, Beck Water said:

 

Fantastic post, Thanks!  So basically, any cardiac arrest/ROSC leaves the patient susceptible to re-arrest? 

 

But now we have reports that he did not re-arrest so that's great if true.

 

On the ambulance, I'll give my perspective as a former EMT which could be full of wind, but whatever.  I think the ambulance most likely waited because the emergency physician or one of the paramedics was performing a procedure, in consult with the trauma center, that was quicker and easier to perform while the ambulance was not in motion.  You know how using your cell phone is hella easier when you're sitting still vs. jouncing around a city street?  Yeah, That.  It's kind of an unusual situation BECAUSE there is an emergency physician and airway specialist and a broader range of equipment and drugs available to them at the stadium.  So the physician/paramedics could well have been in contact with the trauma center and they mutually decided to do whatever they paused to do vs. waiting 10-15 minutes to arrive at the Trauma Center.

 

It's my understanding that since Kevin Everett and Ryan Shazier's injury, the NFL is "all in" on hypothermia treatment.  They reportedly started an IV - I'm told that chilled IV fluids are now maintained at Pittsburgh stadium, so quite likely elsewhere as well - and they could well have packed him in cooling packs or ice to start hypothermia, stadia most certainly are supplied with ice and blue ice packs.  They might even have paused to do this before heading for the ER.

 

Sal C reported that Damar's mom was on her way down while he was still on the field, standing behind the Bills bench saying "I want to be with my son" and he summoned Dane Jackson who got the attention of the Bills Chaplain, and they then worked with security to get her on the field ASAP.  I think she just got down to the while the ambulance was still there so they put her in, and if the ambulance had been ready to leave before she got there it would have left and security would have put her in a car and followed.

 

 

Thanks for all your input and feedback!  I definitely appreciate your ambulance perspective, but as a former EMT would you want the mom in there if things go south?

 

To answer your question, yes, but so, so much goes into it.   Things like myocarditis/pericarditis temporarily changes ERPs and sensitivity of the heart to arrhythmia.  

In Hamlin's case, young and in top shape, with no significant risk factors you would anticipate restoring sinus rhythm quickly and minimal chance of rearrest.  But we don't know what underlying genetic and environmental factors there were.  Immediate CPR is a big help also, but the longer it takes to restore sinus rhythm the odds you can't bring the person back rise precipitously.  My understanding from the docs is humans fall off the cliff of being able to resuscitate very quickly.  Just happy they got him back, 8 minutes is a fairly long time but they were doing CPR for most of it.

 

Posted
58 minutes ago, Mr. WEO said:

 

Unfortunately oxygenation isn't an indicator of much.  Assuming normal lung function and adequate cardiac output, he should have little difficulty oxygenating on the vent. The key moment isn't taking him off the vent.

 

There aren't necessarily going to be "good/improving numbers" in this scenario, unfortunately.  All that matters is what will be his mental status as the hypothermic therapy and sedation are stopped.  His heart can, right now, be fully back to baseline (no doubt he's had at least one echocardiogram since he went down)--the issue is did he suffer an anoxic brain injury before spontaneous circulation was restored in the filed.

Not if he has ARDS.  Then improving oxygenation is very important.  Many other measurables could be important.  But it's true that without brain function, it doesn't matter.  Pray that his brain is ok.

  • Thank you (+1) 3
Posted
4 minutes ago, CoffeeDrip said:

Absolutely the best man to be leading this team right now.

Given everything this team has been through, it's hard to believe he isn't given more consideration for Coach of the Year honors.  I don't think the national audience quite understands how trying this season has been for the Bills.

  • Like (+1) 2
  • Agree 3
  • Thank you (+1) 1
Posted
22 minutes ago, YoloinOhio said:

I don’t think they will get any updates from anyone at UCMC.

 

I saw a few journalists on Twitter say that the hospital was supposed to give an official update, but then the hospital came out and said there was no update to give yet. So there will hopefully be one at some point.

Posted
1 hour ago, Mr. WEO said:

 

Far more people in this country have far more physically demanding jobs that are more dangerous and detrimental to their long and short term health than pro athletes.  Most take these jobs because they don't have the opportunities/choices afforded elite athletes.  For their efforts, these people get a modest paycheck and no post retirement healthcare.  

 

 

They do---for 5 years after retirement. 

 

The "average NFL career" is frequently cited as 3 years---but that includes anyone who got a single check from an NFL team at any time....so that includes a lot of "camp fodder"--guys who never make a roster (and rarely take a big hit in a game).  But we are talking about guys who at least are on an active roster for several years--these are the guys who are being exposed to the big hits--not the PS guys. 

 

Talley made at least 5 million from the Bills/Falcons/Vikings (plus the Bills payed him in the range of 50-100K for years to be one of their "legends").  That was pretty good money in the 80's-90's.  Easily could have stashed away a chunk for his later years.  Now apparently the money is gone.  Some years ago, there was a online fund drive (disclaimer:  I donated) when the story of his recent health struggles was published.

 

The point is that every players knows exactly what they are getting into from college ball to the NFL, as far as risks to their health.   They negotiate how much they are going to be payed to subject themselves to this risk.  They also know that, like nearly all nonmunicipal unemployed/retired adults under 65, that at some point their employer will no longer be paying for their healthcare.  They can't then, after leaving the game, complain that years later the NFL isn't paying for their health care needs, or that they "earned" something they were never due.  That's not how it works.

So then why do you care when someone on the players’ side complains about the health insurance provided by the league? I strongly suspect it’s going to be an issue in the next CBA.  It’s the right of the players to negotiate it.  I think they’ve earned it, and have for a long time.  

  • Like (+1) 1
This topic is OLD. A NEW topic should be started unless there is a very specific reason to revive this one.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...