Inigo Montoya Posted October 4, 2022 Posted October 4, 2022 What we know This is the first week that Tre is eligible to come off of short term PUP list and start to practice with the team. From the time Tre comes off PUP and starts to practice, the Bills will have 21 days to activate him to the regular roster or he will have to be placed on season ending IR. McDermott was asked yesterday about Tre's status and he essentially gave no answer except that Tre continues to work to get back. What we suspect Even if Tre is 100% right now I would be shocked for him to lace it up against the Steelers this week due to the matchup. The Bills secondary should be able to hold up against the Steeler's offense without Tre in there this week. The big question is, will they play him the following week vs the Chiefs in Arrowhead. It would obviously be a big boost to have him back on the field for that pivotal matchup with plenty of playoff seeding consequences for the Bills. If the Bills don't play him in Week 6 versus the Chiefs, Tre will then have an additional week to rehab with the bye week in Week 7 and will have to be activated before the Week 8 tilt on Sunday night against the Packers at home. This might have been the plan all along. When he comes back he will likely be on a snap count and alternating time with Elam and Jackson as he plays back into form. 1 2
jletha Posted October 4, 2022 Posted October 4, 2022 My ideal situation is him coming off PUP today, and then getting two weeks to practice before playing on a limited basis for the Chiefs ahead of the bye. 3 4
SCBills Posted October 4, 2022 Posted October 4, 2022 May or may not be popular, but I'm not playing Tre until after the bye, against Green Bay. From what I understand, once you reach a certain time period, the chance of re-injury stays stagnant... doesn't really improve with more time off. I'm not sure where he is in relation to that, but he's too important to rush back and call me crazy, but I have a lot of confidence in a secondary of Poyer-Hamlin-Johnson-Jackson-Elam. More important, imo, is to get Davis, Oliver and Phillips right for the Chiefs game - if possible. 13 12
No_Matter_What Posted October 4, 2022 Posted October 4, 2022 My wild uneducated guess is that we will be happy if he plays against GB. 1
Freddie's Dead Posted October 4, 2022 Posted October 4, 2022 No need to rush Tre' back. Let that ACL fully heal and save him for the stretch run and the playoffs. GB is fine if you want to bring him on after the bye. 2 3
Brandon Posted October 4, 2022 Posted October 4, 2022 With the way the secondary is playing, they may as well give him some extra time. I'd just wait until after the bye week. 2
Billsflyer12 Posted October 4, 2022 Posted October 4, 2022 1 minute ago, No_Matter_What said: My wild uneducated guess is that we will be happy if he plays against GB. I to am starting to feel like it will be later then most think. Not ruling out he doesn’t play at all or very little this season. 1 2
clayboy54 Posted October 4, 2022 Posted October 4, 2022 Just now, SCBills said: May or may not be popular, but I'm not playing Tre until after the bye, against Green Bay. From what I understand, once you reach a certain time period, the chance of re-injury stays stagnant... doesn't really improve with more time off. I'm not sure where he is in relation to that, but he's too important to rush back and call me crazy, but I have a lot of confidence in a secondary of Poyer-Hamlin-Johnson-Jackson-Elam. I agree that our existing secondary as it is can be more than adequate for the season. Tre is icing on the cake if and when he comes back 100%. It's not the re-injury risk for me, but rather the <100% performance-related drop off. Right now, Tre at say 80% may be worse than what we currently have on the field. 2
Ramza86 Posted October 4, 2022 Posted October 4, 2022 I think if we NEEDED to win maybe he comes back after this week. If you ask me. Hell be back after the bye week. Get back to 100% by the playoffs.
nucci Posted October 4, 2022 Posted October 4, 2022 26 minutes ago, Inigo Montoya said: What we know This is the first week that Tre is eligible to come off of short term PUP list and start to practice with the team. From the time Tre comes off PUP and starts to practice, the Bills will have 21 days to activate him to the regular roster or he will have to be placed on season ending IR. McDermott was asked yesterday about Tre's status and he essentially gave no answer except that Tre continues to work to get back. What we suspect Even if Tre is 100% right now I would be shocked for him to lace it up against the Steelers this week due to the matchup. The Bills secondary should be able to hold up against the Steeler's offense without Tre in there this week. The big question is, will they play him the following week vs the Chiefs in Arrowhead. It would obviously be a big boost to have him back on the field for that pivotal matchup with plenty of playoff seeding consequences for the Bills. If the Bills don't play him in Week 6 versus the Chiefs, Tre will then have an additional week to rehab with the bye week in Week 7 and will have to be activated before the Week 8 tilt on Sunday night against the Packers at home. This might have been the plan all along. When he comes back he will likely be on a snap count and alternating time with Elam and Jackson as he plays back into form. Good points but if a player is 100% and has practiced, he should play 2
DapperCam Posted October 4, 2022 Posted October 4, 2022 I hope he plays this week on a snap count and is ready to go for KC. Obviously the most conservative approach is best though. 1
krf139 Posted October 4, 2022 Posted October 4, 2022 McDermott has been silent with updates on this situation and the media have done a very poor job (as they did with 13 seconds) getting answers. Leaves me to believe there might be more going on with this situation (and a potentially longer timeline) than we’d like to think 3 2
LABILLBACKER Posted October 4, 2022 Posted October 4, 2022 The prudent plan is to active him right before the Packers game and slowly ease him in to playing time. Any other strategy would probably carry more risk.
ArtVandalay Posted October 4, 2022 Posted October 4, 2022 You play him when he's ready. You don't hold him out longer or rush him back. If he's ready he's ready and you play him. KC game is a playoff game and may very well determine #1 seed. 2 1 1 1
yall Posted October 4, 2022 Posted October 4, 2022 37 minutes ago, Billsflyer12 said: I to am starting to feel like it will be later then most think. Not ruling out he doesn’t play at all or very little this season. I said this a week or so ago. An unpopular opinion to be sure, but I continue to hear rumblings around OP that his rehab is not going well. 1 1
gordong Posted October 4, 2022 Posted October 4, 2022 I'd like to see him come off the pup list sooner than later but I don't care if he plays until later... give him as much time as he needs plus more. getting him back for the playoffs would be a huge add.
nucci Posted October 4, 2022 Posted October 4, 2022 5 minutes ago, ArtVandalay said: You play him when he's ready. You don't hold him out longer or rush him back. If he's ready he's ready and you play him. KC game is a playoff game and may very well determine #1 seed. This should be the default post on every injury
Billsflyer12 Posted October 4, 2022 Posted October 4, 2022 1 minute ago, yall said: I said this a week or so ago. An unpopular opinion to be sure, but I continue to hear rumblings around OP that his rehab is not going well. I’ve sensed since about week 2 of training camp that maybe he had a set back. He was at Fischer at first, some comments from team were initially somewhat positive. Then it all just went quiet and he was largely out of sight then. Just a hunch of mine since early August. 1
Big Turk Posted October 4, 2022 Posted October 4, 2022 If the Bills exercise caution when dealing with things like hamstring injuries to prevent reoccurrence or worsening that are far less serious than an ACL, you can bet they will be exercising an abundance of caution to make sure he is 100% ready to go and not putting him at any extra risk. 1
quinnearlysghost88 Posted October 4, 2022 Posted October 4, 2022 1 hour ago, Inigo Montoya said: What we know This is the first week that Tre is eligible to come off of short term PUP list and start to practice with the team. From the time Tre comes off PUP and starts to practice, the Bills will have 21 days to activate him to the regular roster or he will have to be placed on season ending IR. McDermott was asked yesterday about Tre's status and he essentially gave no answer except that Tre continues to work to get back. What we suspect Even if Tre is 100% right now I would be shocked for him to lace it up against the Steelers this week due to the matchup. The Bills secondary should be able to hold up against the Steeler's offense without Tre in there this week. The big question is, will they play him the following week vs the Chiefs in Arrowhead. It would obviously be a big boost to have him back on the field for that pivotal matchup with plenty of playoff seeding consequences for the Bills. If the Bills don't play him in Week 6 versus the Chiefs, Tre will then have an additional week to rehab with the bye week in Week 7 and will have to be activated before the Week 8 tilt on Sunday night against the Packers at home. This might have been the plan all along. When he comes back he will likely be on a snap count and alternating time with Elam and Jackson as he plays back into form. Honestly he has to come back for KC if he’s ready. We’re in a race for home field and can’t afford to go into KC short handed. That’s almost a must win if we want to not be playing KC in January.
Recommended Posts