Bills “trying to run the clock out” on Tre’Davious White PUP list decision

[The Wiz]

2 minutes ago, nucci said:

we actually need our best players for every game. Why wouldn't we need him until 2nd half?

Well the first 4 games we have Rams (matters but not as much with non- conference).

 

Then titans, Miami, Baltimore. 

 

Titans and Baltimore don't have great receivers anymore and Miami has great receivers but Tua at qb.

 

I think we can live without him for a few weeks even though I'd rather have him. 

[HappyDays]

I would almost rather he not play in week 1. Even though it's the exciting NFL season opener, the Rams game is the least important game on our schedule. If we had to choose one game that the Bills were guaranteed to lose it would be this one. Give White a little extra time to rehab and make sure he's good to go for more important games.

[Cash]

1 hour ago, HamSandwhich said:

The fact that they are waiting so long seems to suggest he’s close and they think he could potentially be ready for the start of the season. That’s positive news for sure! 

My only nitpick with this idea is that PUP means he’s out 4 weeks. So even if they know he’ll miss weeks 1 and 2, they still might think it’s worth keeping him on the 53 if there’s any reasonable chance he plays in week 3 or even 4. He’s a captain and arguably their best defensive player when healthy. One week of Tre is probably worth more to the Bills than 4 weeks of Cam Lewis or whomever. 
 

But I agree with the broader point: if they knew Tre was probably going to miss 4 weeks or more no matter what, he’s already be on PUP. And Beane has generally been a straight shooter when he actually says something. They clearly don’t know for sure when he’ll be back, but they think September is realistic. 

[Freddie's Dead]

Please don't use "running out the clock" in a Bills forum.  Too soon.  Scars.

[BillsBytheBay]

I'm not in a rush to see him. I'd rather him be healthy later in the season.

[Saint Doug]

21 minutes ago, nucci said:

we actually need our best players for every game. Why wouldn't we need him until 2nd half?

2nd half of the season is arguably more important than the 1st half, especially leading into the post-season. If you rush a player coming off a major injury, you may set yourself for another one. Plus, it’s going to take awhile before he gets back into game shape considering the number of games he’s already missed.

[FLFan]

42 minutes ago, Cash said:

My only nitpick with this idea is that PUP means he’s out 4 weeks. So even if they know he’ll miss weeks 1 and 2, they still might think it’s worth keeping him on the 53 if there’s any reasonable chance he plays in week 3 or even 4. He’s a captain and arguably their best defensive player when healthy. One week of Tre is probably worth more to the Bills than 4 weeks of Cam Lewis or whomever. 
 

But I agree with the broader point: if they knew Tre was probably going to miss 4 weeks or more no matter what, he’s already be on PUP. And Beane has generally been a straight shooter when he actually says something. They clearly don’t know for sure when he’ll be back, but they think September is realistic. 

Players on PUP cannot practice with the team.  So, if they put him on the list, he would be eligible to come back after week 4, and he can be activated and play, or remain inactive and begin practicing with the team.   They have 21 days at that point to activate him.  It is highly unlikely, like 0% probability, that the Bills would play White without practice time. 2 or 3 weeks of practice is likely.  The Bye is week 7.

 

i am sure they are hoping that Tre will be ready to work out with the team and begin practicing in the next few weeks.  In that case it would make sense to keep him off PUP and carry him on the active roster.  If that is not the case, and they resort to a PUP designation, you are probably looking at week 8. 

[Beast]

2 hours ago, Airseven said:

Nothing new here. I'd be shocked if he didn't miss the first 4 games at least.

 

They would ***** around if that was the case.

 

What it should tell everyone is he is very close to taking part in football activities.

Edited August 23, 2022 by Beast

[Over 29 years of fanhood]

It seems they are only waiting to see if he’s still month to month or closer to week to week.

[Saxum]

2 hours ago, Saint Doug said:

I would rather they didn’t rush him. We likely won’t really need to until the 2nd half of the season. 

 

Considering the first half of season is a lot tougher I disagree.  If he can play let him play with a limited snap count and examination by doctor after every game.

1 hour ago, Donuts and Doritos said:

Have a feeling he's back after the week 7 buy, just in time to play the Packers.

 

Only Pat(riot)s get a week 7 buy paid for out of Krafty's pocket.

[TBBills]

He will be activated on the final day of cuts.

[Saxum]

1 hour ago, Cash said:

My only nitpick with this idea is that PUP means he’s out 4 weeks. So even if they know he’ll miss weeks 1 and 2, they still might think it’s worth keeping him on the 53 if there’s any reasonable chance he plays in week 3 or even 4. He’s a captain and arguably their best defensive player when healthy. One week of Tre is probably worth more to the Bills than 4 weeks of Cam Lewis or whomever. 
 

But I agree with the broader point: if they knew Tre was probably going to miss 4 weeks or more no matter what, he’s already be on PUP. And Beane has generally been a straight shooter when he actually says something. They clearly don’t know for sure when he’ll be back, but they think September is realistic. 

 

if they knew he would be available week 5 he would not be on 4 week PUP list since he could not practice with team.

Bills can keep him inactive each week rather than another player allowing him to practice at his own, NFLPA mandated slower pace, until he is ready for live snaps.

I do not think the #53 player is worth putting him on PUP list especially with PS callups.

[FilthyBeast]

2 hours ago, Saint Doug said:

I would rather they didn’t rush him. We likely won’t really need to until the 2nd half of the season. 

 

There's a good chance this team is sitting around .500 after the first half of the season given the schedule and how many good QB/offenses we face.

 

We don't need to rush him, but we also should have adequately addressed the DB position in FA instead of relying on rookies, including a 1st rounder that doesn't look like he's ready to make a meaningful contribution right away and whose career could be adversely impacted by forcing him into the lineup against some of the league's elite QB/WR combos we are going to see in the first half of the season.

 

As for the continued word salad from McD/Beane/etc they know he's likely not ready and won't be any time soon hence the 'run out the clock' type of comment because once he is put on PUP or IR they don't have to answer media questions anytime soon.

[Donuts and Doritos]

1 hour ago, 1ManRaid said:

 

And why do you have this "feeling"?  Do you have sort of knowledge the coaches and medical staff don't?  They're mulling over if they will even need to PUP him for 4 weeks, and you're just writing him off for 7 because...?

 

Didn't say I know. Definitely didn't say I know something the coaches or medical staff don't, or you or anyone else for that matter. Said it's a "feeling". Reading what little info we all have to go on like everyone else. It was more than just an ACL, also a miniscus, he's not been seen out doing the rehab since late July (doesn't mean it isn't happening), Bills have been known to take it slowly bringing guys back from injury according to the news reports, PUP could take him out 4 weeks, 2 more games missed gets them to the week 7 buy. That buy gives them 2 weeks to run him through practices and get ready for the next game. Packers is a huge home game. That's the thought behind the "feeling" & yes it's guess work. But as you point out none of us are the coaches or medical staff in the know, so I guess we're all guessing and opining our own "feelings" about this until they tell us. Could be back week 1 or 4 or 7. Really, really hope it's week 1, we'll see. Go Bills.

[BarleyNY]

3 hours ago, HamSandwhich said:

The fact that they are waiting so long seems to suggest he’s close and they think he could potentially be ready for the start of the season. That’s positive news for sure! 

No need to give the Rams and other teams any info about his condition until we have to.

[Billzgobowlin]

I love the idea of getting a fresh All Pro CB back after 4 games especially if both rookies step up

[Logic]

The Bills have arguably the best medical and sports science staff in the league.

Whatever the doctors and medical staff say, I trust them.

If I had to bet money on it, I'd guess he starts the season on PUP, misses the first four games, and returns in week five. In that case, I think Jackson, Elam, and Benford will be good enough to get us through until White is back on the field.

[nkreed]

If he wasn't on the positive side of the 4 weeks, as the coaches and trainers see it, why would they be wasting roster spots on him during the cutdown time? There is some serious depth here that they could have taken an extra week on. For instance they could have kept Ford for this week's game if they thought he was going to be a cut or trade.

 

I think this is actually positive news.

[Putin]

3 hours ago, Saint Doug said:

I would rather they didn’t rush him. We likely won’t really need to until the 2nd half of the season. 

The first half of the schedule is the toughest and  that is when we could really use him  , 

I don’t want to rush him but if he’s ready to go week one LETS GOOOO !!!

Edited August 23, 2022 by Putin

[nucci]

2 hours ago, Saint Doug said:

2nd half of the season is arguably more important than the 1st half, especially leading into the post-season. If you rush a player coming off a major injury, you may set yourself for another one. Plus, it’s going to take awhile before he gets back into game shape considering the number of games he’s already missed.

I'm not saying rush him. But it's wrong to say we'll be ok if he misses the 1st half of the season