Aaron Rogers in the Playoffs

[Mark Vader]

4 hours ago, atlbillsfan1975 said:

Wait, would Belichick want a player with Rogers skill set? 
Honestly, with your assessment that Belichick wouldn’t want Josh as his QB, I’m not sure you should be debating anyone about QB rankings. 

[Stank_Nasty]

13 minutes ago, DabillsDaBillsDaBills said:

 

Rodgers

Overall playoffs 11-9

Conference Championship 1-4

Superbowl 1-0 with 1 SB MVP

 

Elway

Overall playoff record 14-7

Conference Championship 5-1

Superbowl 2-3 with 1 SB MVP 

 

Elway (prior to his final 2 seasons with a stacked team)

Overall playoffs 7-7

Conference Championship 3-1

Superbowl 0-3 (1 bad and 2 dreadful games)

 

Honestly I don't know if either guy should be considered clutch in the playoffs. Elway's 5-1 conference title record is impressive, but he followed those up with 4 pretty bad SB performances. Rodgers only made the SB once, but in that one appearance he had a fantastic game. Elway may have the slightly better playoff career than Rodgers, but the better regular season career is Rodgers by far (and Rodgers isn't over yet). 

 

Elway had The Drive. Rodgers had the divisional game vs Cowboys that I linked earlier. 

 

Saying that Elway is far and away the more clutch player is a combination of viewing Elway through rose colored glasses, and discounting Rodgers based on recency bias. 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

These are all fair points. the only one i see thats sorta grasping is you keep trying to discount elways last 2 seasons. That doesnt make a lot of sense to me. it was part of his career... Are you saying that a packers team thats gone 13-3 for 3 straight seasons is bereft of talent?

 

... rodgers still has a couple years to write his story. he very well might end up winning a title or 2 on a talented team(may or may not be GB) and solidify himself as a top 3-ish. i suppose we'll discount that as well, just to be fair?

Edited February 11, 2022 by Stank_Nasty

[Olliemets]

Rogers Playoff failures knock him out of the top 5 in my book. As others have pointed out, he's a great thrower of the Football. But it seems that if things get difficult, he doesn't adapt and had no plan B

 

Brady

Unitis

Graham

Montana

Staubach

[Allen2Moulds]

This is a really fun topic and almost certainly needs to be divided.

 

Rodgers is no doubt a top 5 talent, and a top 3 performer in the regular season. 

 

The year he won the Superbowl, he played some of the best football I've ever seen in the playoffs. 

 

However, that was before he was a known diva. Over the last however many years, je just hasn't been as special. I also tend to put more stock into playoff football. Tony Romo was a great reg season QB, Eli was just the opposite. I would've taken Eli, and would trust him over Rodgers in the playoffs. I almost think that Rodgers is very aware of his placement, and likely cares about his stats/rating. Maybe one of the reasons his pick totals are so low, is that he sometimes plays it safe, instead of pushing the envelope like a Josh, or Mahomes will do.

 

I also have only been watching football for about 30 years, and I would have to say.

 

Brady

Montana

Manning

Young

Kurt Warner 

 

[Thurman#1]

5 hours ago, Mr. WEO said:

 

Defender was tied up with a receiver.  He jogs in easily.  Instead tosses a pass into the turf.  game over.

 

I bet Rodgers would rather have 2 SB wins/SB MVPs....say, like Eli Manning.

 

 

Defender was not tied up with a receiver. I mean deep in the end zone, that guy might have been, but shallow and just slightly outside Rodgers a receiver was doubled and the one guy was outside him and not tied up. He could easily have fired off outside. And it was Delaney, a CB. He'd have had an excellent chance of catching up to him. He was actually about two steps outside of Rodgers as Rodgers threw.

 

Just went and looked on Game pass. Delaney would have had an excellent shot at making the play. He runs a 4.46 40.

 

I don't like Rodgers. He's a jackass. But he was presented with two very very tough options.

 

 

Edited February 11, 2022 by Thurman#1

[Big Turk]

5 hours ago, gonzo1105 said:

I mean if your going to dog on Rodgers you have to dog on Marino for his playoff failures 

 

Marino only got to one Superbowl and was blown out.

24 minutes ago, Allen2Moulds said:

This is a really fun topic and almost certainly needs to be divided.

 

Rodgers is no doubt a top 5 talent, and a top 3 performer in the regular season. 

 

The year he won the Superbowl, he played some of the best football I've ever seen in the playoffs. 

 

However, that was before he was a known diva. Over the last however many years, je just hasn't been as special. I also tend to put more stock into playoff football. Tony Romo was a great reg season QB, Eli was just the opposite. I would've taken Eli, and would trust him over Rodgers in the playoffs. I almost think that Rodgers is very aware of his placement, and likely cares about his stats/rating. Maybe one of the reasons his pick totals are so low, is that he sometimes plays it safe, instead of pushing the envelope like a Josh, or Mahomes will do.

 

I also have only been watching football for about 30 years, and I would have to say.

 

Brady

Montana

Manning

Young

Kurt Warner 

 

 

Until Allen came along this playoff. Best two game stretch of QB play in the playoffs you'll ever see...149 QB rating is crazy

[Thurman#1]

1 hour ago, DabillsDaBillsDaBills said:

 

Rodgers

Overall playoffs 11-9

Conference Championship 1-4

Superbowl 1-0 with 1 SB MVP

 

Elway

Overall playoff record 14-7

Conference Championship 5-1

Superbowl 2-3 with 1 SB MVP 

 

Elway (prior to his final 2 seasons with a stacked team)

Overall playoffs 7-7

Conference Championship 3-1

Superbowl 0-3 (1 bad and 2 dreadful games)

 

Honestly I don't know if either guy should be considered clutch in the playoffs. Elway's 5-1 conference title record is impressive, but he followed those up with 4 pretty bad SB performances. Rodgers only made the SB once, but in that one appearance he had a fantastic game. Elway may have the slightly better playoff career than Rodgers, but the better regular season career is Rodgers by far (and Rodgers isn't over yet). 

 

Elway had The Drive. Rodgers had the divisional game vs Cowboys that I linked earlier. 

 

Saying that Elway is far and away the more clutch player is a combination of viewing Elway through rose colored glasses, and discounting Rodgers based on recency bias. 

 

 

 

 

Agreed. 

 

Wins is a team stat.

 

How the QB plays, QB stats basically, that's how you judge the QB. Or how you do it with stats anyway. 

 

Rodgers has played three out of 22 playoff games with a QB rating below 90. He's been very good in the playoffs.

[Mr. WEO]

15 minutes ago, Thurman#1 said:

 

 

Defender was not tied up with a receiver. I mean deep in the end zone, that guy might have been, but shallow and just slightly outside Rodgers a receiver was doubled and the one guy was outside him and not tied up. He could easily have fired off outside. And it was Delaney, a CB. He'd have had an excellent chance of catching up to him. He was actually about two steps outside of Rodgers as Rodgers threw.

 

Just went and looked on Game pass. Delaney would have had an excellent shot at making the play. He runs a 4.46 40.

 

I don't like Rodgers. He's a jackass. But he was presented with two very very tough options.

 

 

 

His pass had zero chance of being caught in the End Zone.  Run was best chance.  Never looked.

[Bookie Man]

If I were to start an all time team, Rodgers would be in strong consideration for QB. 

[PatsFanNH]

9 hours ago, BuffaloBillyG said:

I see that logic and agree. However, the other side of the argument..this is who he's been by and large his career in the postseason. Odd timing to finally drop him down after the last 2 seasons he's had is all.

 

 

For me this season he had a top D that showed up big time limiting the 49ers O all game and he failed to elevate his game for that one critical drive to win the game. 
 

Last year he had the win in his hands or rather feet and instead decided make a bad throw. Even if he doesn’t score it be 4th and goal from like the. They probably go for it.. 

 

For me a true MVP shows up in both those games to win them.  Mind you I thought Brady deserved it over him this year.  I mean if the team is down 27-3 NO one thinks Rogers will lead them back for a win. Hell he probably phones in the rest of the game.

[FireChans]

12 hours ago, PatsFanNH said:

Ok a friend of mine (a huge Rogers fan) and I are debating on how great Rogers is. He states he is top 5 all time.  I say he is maybe top 10 and that his choking in playoff games isn’t helping him. 
 

he points to his playoff stats 5894 yards 22 TD and 13 INT in 21 games.

 

I say that’s nice but just look at the last two years. In 2020 he had 3rd and Goal from the 5 and could have easily run it in and he throws it into double coverage. This year he barely gets 10 points on the 49ers, and worse fails to get even one first down deep in his own end which lead to a punt block.

 

I say the lack of being clutch keeps him out of the top 5. 

You need to post your top 5 if you're going to claim he's not top 5.

[PatsFanNH]

5 hours ago, ßookie_tech said:

If I were to start an all time team, Rodgers would be in strong consideration for QB. 

That be a fun one to do… QB be the toughest to decide…I see a lot of biased based on the uniform the person cheers for.. for me

QB — Brady, Montana, Kelly… 

RB — Barry Sanders, Sweetness, Curtis Martin

 

WR — Moss, Rice, Fitzgerald

 

TE — Gronk, Gates, Tony G.

 

those mine and for QB I’d take Mahomes, and Big Ben over Rogers 

 

1 minute ago, FireChans said:

You need to post your top 5 if you're going to claim he's not top 5.

I did:

 

Brady, Manning, Montana, Graham, Marino. 
 

I also have Elway, starbauck, and Unitas ahead of him.

[Old Coot]

Otto Graham was a very good QB.  He played for the Belichick of his era, Paul Brown (after whom the Browns are named)).  The Cleveland Browns were so good that they won all 4 championships of the All-American Football Conference (the Bills were one of the AAFC teams).  When the AAFC folded in 1949 the Browns joined the NFL and won the 1950 NFL championship plus the 1954 & 55 championships with Otto at the helm.

 

 

Edited February 12, 2022 by Old Coot

[coloradobillsfan]

In a must-win game, if I get them in their prime I'd take Favre over Rodgers.  Just my gut reaction after watching a lot of both of them.  

[Old Coot]

Unitas did it all.  He called his own plays and played in an era when the D was allowed to beat up the QB.  Halas' Bears were notorious for being dirty players.

 

It's really impossible to say who the GOAT or rank QBs.  As others have stated the game has changed so much.

[FireChans]

17 minutes ago, PatsFanNH said:

That be a fun one to do… QB be the toughest to decide…I see a lot of biased based on the uniform the person cheers for.. for me

QB — Brady, Montana, Kelly… 

RB — Barry Sanders, Sweetness, Curtis Martin

 

WR — Moss, Rice, Fitzgerald

 

TE — Gronk, Gates, Tony G.

 

those mine and for QB I’d take Mahomes, and Big Ben over Rogers 

 

I did:

 

Brady, Manning, Montana, Graham, Marino. 
 

I also have Elway, starbauck, and Unitas ahead of him.

 

12 hours ago, PatsFanNH said:

Ok a friend of mine (a huge Rogers fan) and I are debating on how great Rogers is. He states he is top 5 all time.  I say he is maybe top 10 and that his choking in playoff games isn’t helping him. 
 

he points to his playoff stats 5894 yards 22 TD and 13 INT in 21 games.

 

I say that’s nice but just look at the last two years. In 2020 he had 3rd and Goal from the 5 and could have easily run it in and he throws it into double coverage. This year he barely gets 10 points on the 49ers, and worse fails to get even one first down deep in his own end which lead to a punt block.

 

I say the lack of being clutch keeps him out of the top 5. 

Lol talk about lack of clutch. Aaron Rodgers is Marino if Marino won a Superbowl. 

[RaoulDuke79]

Statistically he's top 5. Sometimes it's just bad matchups and sometime there's something intangible that can't be captured in stats. I don't know what it is, but I don't necessarily think it's all a Rodgers problem. Of course all the attention is on the QB, but I don't think He's ever completely ***** the bed in a playoff game. He's Marinoesque

[PatsFanNH]

20 minutes ago, FireChans said:

 

Lol talk about lack of clutch. Aaron Rodgers is Marino if Marino won a Superbowl. 

Maybe it’s the way I remember watching those games… Marino was like a surgeon and dang did it hurt when he operated. 

[78thealltimegreat]

Top 5 all time? No way 

1 TB12 7 trophies 

2 Joe Montana 4 rings

 

3 Johnny Unitas 3 nfl titles and a super bowl 

 

4 Roger Staubach So unbelievably good that do to his military commitment he couldn’t even join the league till he was 27 and he was still voted one of the best players of all time

 

5 John Elway this is Josh Allen 1.0 for those of us who remember him he was as close to a one man team as anyone ever

 

Aarons good maybe 10ish but he’s nowhere near these guys 

[FireChans]

46 minutes ago, PatsFanNH said:

Maybe it’s the way I remember watching those games… Marino was like a surgeon and dang did it hurt when he operated. 

Time has been kind to Marino for that exact reason. You also played him twice a year.

 

Time will be kind to Aaron. He will be regarded as a champion, a multiple MVP/AllPro etc etc. Bears and Vikings fans will always remember how much he owned them over 15 season, how unstoppable he was. 
 

Honestly, the room in the top 5 grows smaller with every year. I’m someone who WOULD have Manning and Brady obviously. Montana because I know him. Unitas, Staubach are just names of guys I didn’t watch play.  
 

Rodgers has it all. You just have to win one. Very few win one let alone multiple.