DCOrange Posted March 4, 2021 Posted March 4, 2021 (edited) https://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2021/03/04/ravens-to-propose-revolutionary-spot-and-choose-overtime-procedure/ My guess is that this will not pass, but perhaps it will be like the 4th and 15 rule where it keeps coming back as more teams get frustrated with the current way things are. The rule is laid out in the article above, but basically, this is how it would work. One team chooses the spot where the ball will begin in OT (i.e. the offense's own 10 yard line). The other team then gets to choose if it wants to take the ball at the 10 or play defense from the 10 and bank on getting a quick stop and getting the ball back around midfield after the punt. The winner of the coin toss decides if they want to be the team setting the spot or be the team making the call on taking the ball (I imagine teams would always choose the latter). Edit: Forgot this part: this rule was submitted with two different variations. One being that it's sudden death, so if you take the ball from your own 10 and score, that's the ballgame. The other variation that was submitted (and has the Patriots backing in addition to the Ravens) is that OT is 7.5 minutes long and you just play it out; most points at the end of it wins or it can end in a tie there. Edited March 4, 2021 by DCOrange
Orlando Buffalo Posted March 4, 2021 Posted March 4, 2021 This is an awful idea- if two teams are tied play to sudden death. 2 1
papazoid Posted March 4, 2021 Posted March 4, 2021 #1 - overtime should be for a definite period of time. enough so that each team would likely get the ball once. say anywhere from 10 to 15 minutes. #2 - in the unlikely event it stays tied after that, then sudden death. 2
Buffalo03 Posted March 4, 2021 Posted March 4, 2021 Keep it how it is now bit go back to 15:00 OT quarters. The 10:00 quarters are crappy. It leads to more ties 4
CA OC Bills Fan Posted March 4, 2021 Posted March 4, 2021 Leave as is or move back to 15 minute quarters. I hate the college OT and see no advantage to go to this new proposal. 2
Rochesterfan Posted March 4, 2021 Posted March 4, 2021 18 minutes ago, 17islongenough said: Just go to college rules. I hate the college rules - it is just as bad as the stupid Hockey OT rules. It is fine the way it is. - adjust the clock if needed. 3
GunnerBill Posted March 4, 2021 Posted March 4, 2021 I don't know why you all hate ties so much. How many games go to overtime over the course of a season? 15? 20? Just call them ties and be done with it. In the playoffs I'd insist each team possess the ball once and if it remains tied after that then sudden death.
Royale with Cheese Posted March 4, 2021 Posted March 4, 2021 10 minutes ago, GunnerBill said: I don't know why you all hate ties so much. How many games go to overtime over the course of a season? 15? 20? Just call them ties and be done with it. In the playoffs I'd insist each team possess the ball once and if it remains tied after that then sudden death. Go back to eating your crumpets and drinking your warm beer. This is 'Merica, we don't tie unless it's a hog. 4 2
Rubes Posted March 4, 2021 Posted March 4, 2021 Honestly, I don't care what else they do with the rules, the only thing I want to see changed is no ties. Ever.
PrimeTime101 Posted March 4, 2021 Posted March 4, 2021 I like my rule better NEW OT RULES 1. Beginning of over time ball is spotted at the 50. 2. After the toss each team will have as many shots at the end zone or fg as they wish. 3. If they do or don't get a FG or TD the other team takes over at the 50. So every drive starts at the 50. No matter what. This lasts for 10 minutes. Team that is ahead after 10 wins. IF its a tie after 10 mins., they go for an extended 5 minutes. If a tie after the extended 5 minutes then the game ends in a tie.. this turns into a cat and mouse strategy game. Depending on the situation does one continue to play up tempo? Keep running the game clock with confidence in defense? This would be my new rule. Or play an extra 15 minutes of game... let them duke it out.. after 15 minutes if its a tie its a tie.
mushypeaches Posted March 4, 2021 Posted March 4, 2021 Ties are the best. They force coaches into interesting logic/strategy in OT that they actually have to think about sometimes. Seeing them fail can be fun (or excruciating, like McDermott's 2017 Snow Game brain cramp) Impact on standings is fun They happen so rarely that they're interesting and unique Frankly, I miss ties in hockey too, and the changes to OT and adding shootouts didn't really move the needle in that sport either More gimmicks in football would be unnecessary 1
Logic Posted March 4, 2021 Posted March 4, 2021 Let each team pick their best fighter. The two men then square off at the 50-yard-line in three two minute rounds. May the best man (and team) win. I know who the Bills are picking in this scenario... 1 4
BADOLBILZ Posted March 4, 2021 Posted March 4, 2021 2 hours ago, GunnerBill said: I don't know why you all hate ties so much. How many games go to overtime over the course of a season? 15? 20? Just call them ties and be done with it. In the playoffs I'd insist each team possess the ball once and if it remains tied after that then sudden death. Ties really are anti-American. We want decisive results and instant analysis and ties are counterproductive to those endeavors. You are just used to it because soccer is a sport where you eventually just reach a point where both teams are too exhausted to score. That's not sport, it's aerobics. Always hated that about the game. Hockey has a similar problem. 4 OT playoff games are bullish*t. 5
Brianmoorman4jesus Posted March 4, 2021 Posted March 4, 2021 Everyone always tries to reinvent the wheel with overtime. I say play an 8 min quarter. Whatever the score is after is the score.
Motorin' Posted March 4, 2021 Posted March 4, 2021 Madden has a really fun feature that would make NFL OT must watch. Each team gets one drive from their 20. Punting is not allowed. Extra points are not allowed. Highest score wins. If the score is tied after 2 drives, the ball is placed at the 50. Each team alternates on O for one play. The next play starts where the ball was downed. If one team scores a TD, game over. If it comes down to the last play of 8 plays, the winner is determined by the spot of the ball. Imagine the ball is at the Bills 35 and it's the very last play. They have to get the ball past the 50, into their opponents territory to win. High drama.
GunnerBill Posted March 4, 2021 Posted March 4, 2021 1 hour ago, BADOLBILZ said: Ties really are anti-American. We want decisive results and instant analysis and ties are counterproductive to those endeavors. You are just used to it because soccer is a sport where you eventually just reach a point where both teams are too exhausted to score. That's not sport, it's aerobics. Always hated that about the game. Hockey has a similar problem. 4 OT playoff games are bullish*t. I just don't get it. It is bizarre.
HappyDays Posted March 4, 2021 Posted March 4, 2021 My weird idea for overtime is you're not allowed to punt. First team to score wins. But you can't kick a field goal until your 3rd possession. So now the playing field is a bit more even because even if you get the ball first there's a risk you'll give the ball to the other team on a short field. 1
Cash Posted March 4, 2021 Posted March 4, 2021 4 hours ago, 17islongenough said: Just go to college rules. 3 hours ago, PrimeTime101 said: I like my rule better NEW OT RULES 1. Beginning of over time ball is spotted at the 50. 2. After the toss each team will have as many shots at the end zone or fg as they wish. 3. If they do or don't get a FG or TD the other team takes over at the 50. So every drive starts at the 50. No matter what. This lasts for 10 minutes. Team that is ahead after 10 wins. IF its a tie after 10 mins., they go for an extended 5 minutes. If a tie after the extended 5 minutes then the game ends in a tie.. this turns into a cat and mouse strategy game. Depending on the situation does one continue to play up tempo? Keep running the game clock with confidence in defense? This would be my new rule. Or play an extra 15 minutes of game... let them duke it out.. after 15 minutes if its a tie its a tie. 57 minutes ago, Motorin' said: Madden has a really fun feature that would make NFL OT must watch. Each team gets one drive from their 20. Punting is not allowed. Extra points are not allowed. Highest score wins. If the score is tied after 2 drives, the ball is placed at the 50. Each team alternates on O for one play. The next play starts where the ball was downed. If one team scores a TD, game over. If it comes down to the last play of 8 plays, the winner is determined by the spot of the ball. Imagine the ball is at the Bills 35 and it's the very last play. They have to get the ball past the 50, into their opponents territory to win. High drama. 13 minutes ago, HappyDays said: My weird idea for overtime is you're not allowed to punt. First team to score wins. But you can't kick a field goal until your 3rd possession. So now the playing field is a bit more even because even if you get the ball first there's a risk you'll give the ball to the other team on a short field. I hate any OT proposal that removes special teams and the field position battle from the game. There should be a difference between going 3-and-out versus moving the ball a decent ways down the field and still having to punt. Likewise, there should be a difference between the QB fumbling when he gets sacked vs. throwing a pick on a 40-yard bomb (arm punt). Turning football into a binary succeed/fail option (or tri-nary if it's TD/FG/fail) is much less interesting to me than traditional football, where every yard matters. 1 1
Recommended Posts