NewEra Posted March 10, 2021 Posted March 10, 2021 14 minutes ago, Reed83HOF said: A LorAx type role might work really for us, especially this season due to the cap. Pay a little bit more to get a guy who can play both positions and lessen the Milano blow while picking up a pass rusher. Gives us some flexibility in the draft and UfA in the coming seasons well. Klein was playing the lorax role. If we sign reddick, does klein start in milanos spot? Playing 3 LB sets is rare for a McD D. Maybe we switch it up this year? Taron Johnson would than get less snap. I’m a big believer that there are several ways to skin a cat. If McD is willing to get creative with his personnel, I’d be all for it as long as it doesn’t break the bank. I love his athleticism. 2 minutes ago, dave mcbride said: Yeah, I get that, but I certainly don't think it's physical decline given how young he is. Point is, he's capable of playing at a high level in pass coverage and has proved it. He just needs to fix his game. Either that or the opponents have figured out what made him successful in year 1+2 and schemed away from his strengths. He was pretty bad in coverage the majority of the year. Can’t believe they voted him to the pro bowl (not that it’s a big deal, but he definitely didn’t deserve the nod.) I hope he gets his **** figured out. I really hope we don’t have the same type of play at MLB again this year.
Doc Posted March 10, 2021 Posted March 10, 2021 1 hour ago, dave mcbride said: The way to adjust is to reduce the extreme number to a garden-variety very good game number -- 2/2.5. That leaves him with 9.5-10 sacks, which is very good. He also had 15 tackles for loss, 6 forced fumbles, and 4 passes defensed. That's a very good season, Plus you can't coach speed, and he's a 4.52 guy. Sign me up for more fast guys. This is all academic because some other team is going to pay him more than the Bills will. Good pass rushers are simply too hard to find. 1 hour ago, BADOLBILZ said: He is a playmaker.......which is so undervalued on this board, IMO. I am down on Edmunds because he makes NONE. If they start calling offensive holding again Reddick might see a bump too. Perhaps not as much as the big targets who are easier to grab without it look like an absolute mugging.......but nonetheless that kind of sack production in a season where the OL was allowed to tackle DL was impressive. I think the Bills were in on him in that draft too if I recall those rumors. I doubt he falls in their price range but intriguing weapon. Reddick has talent. But that talent did little for his first 3 years (7.5 sacks during that time) and as such the Cards didn't even give him a 5th year option. What I'm saying is that it's caveat emptor.
dave mcbride Posted March 10, 2021 Author Posted March 10, 2021 15 minutes ago, Doc said: Reddick has talent. But that talent did little for his first 3 years (7.5 sacks during that time) and as such the Cards didn't even give him a 5th year option. What I'm saying is that it's caveat emptor. Agreed, but he essentially played a different position in his first three seasons (OLB). He was almost entirely an edge player this past season. 3
transplantbillsfan Posted March 10, 2021 Posted March 10, 2021 14 hours ago, White Linen said: Another issue is 5 of his 12.5 sacks came in one game against the Giants. 2 hours ago, White Linen said: Point taken, however I think when 40% of a players sack production comes in 1 game against a weak opponent, you have to factor that in. How many sacks does Matt Milano have? If Reddick were to come into Buffalo, he might be viewed as more of a cross between Edge Rusher/Big Nickel.... which I'm curious about. Reddick is bigger and faster than Milano and from what I've read in some of his scouting reports he does have experience in coverage. I don't know that he's the guy we want or target because I do think he'll get paid. But sometimes players just need a change of scenery to really thrive.... just ask Jerry Hughes.
Ridgewaycynic2013 Posted March 10, 2021 Posted March 10, 2021 I thought this was a Sherlock Holmes generated thread, until I squinted to read the author's name. 🤔
White Linen Posted March 10, 2021 Posted March 10, 2021 1 hour ago, transplantbillsfan said: How many sacks does Matt Milano have? If Reddick were to come into Buffalo, he might be viewed as more of a cross between Edge Rusher/Big Nickel.... which I'm curious about. Reddick is bigger and faster than Milano and from what I've read in some of his scouting reports he does have experience in coverage. I don't know that he's the guy we want or target because I do think he'll get paid. But sometimes players just need a change of scenery to really thrive.... just ask Jerry Hughes. I'm not arguing that possibility. I'm just saying his 12.5 sacks are a bit of a mirage.
BADOLBILZ Posted March 10, 2021 Posted March 10, 2021 3 hours ago, dave mcbride said: The thing about Edmunds is that he was a playmaker in one category before 2020 - passes defensed. He had 12 in his rookie season, which was second in the league among non-secondary players. He was pretty good the next season too with 9, but this year he only had 3. I'm not saying he's in decline, and this is a stat that's pretty spiky anyway. But the fact of the matter is that until this season he has been a better-than-average pass defender for a linebacker. In a passing league, that's important. And there's really no difference between a pass defensed and either a stuff on a running play or a sack at the LOS. Defending passes alone doesn't really discourage QB's though. I think the information is out there that Edmunds simply isn't going to intercept or force a fumble if you throw at him..........so QB's attacked him more fearlessly this year. We saw QB's throwing at him when he was actually in good coverage.......with excellent results.........his passer rating against was ghastly. Call it a latter day case of "Thomas Smith syndrome". I also wonder if experience hasn't taken aggressiveness out of his game. He's a shadow of the playmaker that he was as a rookie......... in GAME ONE of his career he showed his potential with a TFL/strip fumble play. That's somehow still probably the highlight play of his career. It's criminal the way they waste his potential in the middle. People who doubt that.........look at the astonishing difference that putting Reddick on the LOS made to his productivity. Edmunds should be an absolute stud pass rusher. I thought he was the best PR prospect in that draft and I wasn't alone in that thought, even on this board. Speaking of that.........anyone know whatever happed to @thebandit27? 1
C.Biscuit97 Posted March 11, 2021 Posted March 11, 2021 4 hours ago, Doc said: Reddick has talent. But that talent did little for his first 3 years (7.5 sacks during that time) and as such the Cards didn't even give him a 5th year option. What I'm saying is that it's caveat emptor. Hughes had 5 sacks his first 3 years. I don’t think HR has any character or work ethic concerns. Sometimes it takes a bit. 2 hours ago, White Linen said: I'm not arguing that possibility. I'm just saying his 12.5 sacks are a bit of a mirage. So trending up when you’re 26 is a bad thing? Would it have been better if he had 12.5 sacks as a rookie and went backwards? This team badly needs a legit number 1 pass rusher. Dude is probably going to be too expensive but I don’t why so many are quick to dismiss a guy trending in the right direction. Double digit sack guys entering their prime rarely hit the open market.
NewEra Posted March 11, 2021 Posted March 11, 2021 4 hours ago, dave mcbride said: Agreed, but he essentially played a different position in his first three seasons (OLB). He was almost entirely an edge player this past season. What position do you think he would play for us? He’s 230lbs
NewEra Posted March 11, 2021 Posted March 11, 2021 2 hours ago, BADOLBILZ said: Defending passes alone doesn't really discourage QB's though. I think the information is out there that Edmunds simply isn't going to intercept or force a fumble if you throw at him..........so QB's attacked him more fearlessly this year. We saw QB's throwing at him when he was actually in good coverage.......with excellent results.........his passer rating against was ghastly. Call it a latter day case of "Thomas Smith syndrome". I also wonder if experience hasn't taken aggressiveness out of his game. He's a shadow of the playmaker that he was as a rookie......... in GAME ONE of his career he showed his potential with a TFL/strip fumble play. That's somehow still probably the highlight play of his career. It's criminal the way they waste his potential in the middle. People who doubt that.........look at the astonishing difference that putting Reddick on the LOS made to his productivity. Edmunds should be an absolute stud pass rusher. I thought he was the best PR prospect in that draft and I wasn't alone in that thought, even on this board. Speaking of that.........anyone know whatever happed to @thebandit27? Perfectly stated. I noticed that @thebandit27 wasn’t around in December and sent him a PM to see if everything was alright. Was surprised that he wasn’t more active here during such an exciting time. He’s yet to reply. 😞. I hope everything is alright 1
pennstate10 Posted March 11, 2021 Posted March 11, 2021 On 1/28/2021 at 2:15 PM, dave mcbride said: He is a FA, and he's a lot more appealing to me than Milano (who I also like). I don't think we'll get him, but man, did he blow up this season after a mediocre first three years (young talented players do get better!). He'd 12.5 sacks and finished 3rd in the league in tackles for a loss with 15. That's 27.5 negative yardage plays. He also had SIX forced fumbles and four passes defensed. He also runs a 4.52 40. My guess is that he gets north of $15 million per. One can dream. 1). Don't think he's a good match for Bills 4-3 D. I think Milano is far better for what this D. Wants to do. 2). I think your math iis off. A sack is,by definition,a tackle for loss.
Doc Posted March 11, 2021 Posted March 11, 2021 58 minutes ago, C.Biscuit97 said: Hughes had 5 sacks his first 3 years. I don’t think HR has any character or work ethic concerns. Sometimes it takes a bit. The Bills certainly got lucky with Hughes. But they basically traded nothing (Kelvin Sheppard) for him and didn't have to pay him much initially so it was a worthwhile gamble. Reddick is going to be looking for big bucks.
Weatherman Posted March 11, 2021 Posted March 11, 2021 (edited) 6 minutes ago, Doc said: The Bills certainly got lucky with Hughes. But they basically traded nothing (Kelvin Sheppard) for him and didn't have to pay him much initially so it was a worthwhile gamble. Reddick is going to be looking for big bucks. Which isn’t available until next year so I’m guessing he will sign a 1 year deal. If he has another 10 plus sack year he will break the bank. Edited March 11, 2021 by Weatherman
Doc Posted March 11, 2021 Posted March 11, 2021 3 minutes ago, Weatherman said: Which isn’t available until next year so I’m guessing he will sign a 1 year deal. If he has another 10 plus sack year he will break the bank. There are some teams will a good amount of cap space. All it takes is one to offer him a multi-year deal.
Weatherman Posted March 11, 2021 Posted March 11, 2021 5 minutes ago, Doc said: There are some teams will a good amount of cap space. All it takes is one to offer him a multi-year deal. We shall see. Most of those teams with a lot of cap have rosters that are gutted and need a QB.
Doc Posted March 11, 2021 Posted March 11, 2021 Just now, Weatherman said: We shall see. Most of those teams with a lot of cap have rosters that are gutted and need a QB. Yeah but there aren't QBs available. They have to use the money on something.
Weatherman Posted March 11, 2021 Posted March 11, 2021 (edited) 8 minutes ago, Doc said: Yeah but there aren't QBs available. They have to use the money on something. Nearly all QBs signed via FA to be the starter will command a min salary of $15M. That’s a huge chunk. Dalton, Fitz, Smith should get $10M min and Trubisky / Crab Legs should get $15M+ Edited March 11, 2021 by Weatherman
Doc Posted March 11, 2021 Posted March 11, 2021 1 minute ago, Weatherman said: Nearly all QBs signed via FA to be the starter will command a min salary of $15M. That’s a huge chunk. Dalton, Fitz, Smith should get $10M min and Bridgewater / Crab Legs should get $15M+ Bridgewater is signed through 2022. The rest of those guys will be lucky to break $5M this year.
Weatherman Posted March 11, 2021 Posted March 11, 2021 Just now, Doc said: Bridgewater is signed through 2022. The rest of those guys will be lucky to break $5M this year. My mistake I thought he was released...still might be.
Doc Posted March 11, 2021 Posted March 11, 2021 13 minutes ago, Weatherman said: My mistake I thought he was released...still might be. I would if I were them. He's not worth what he's getting. At least approach about a pay cut.
Recommended Posts