EmotionallyUnstable Posted November 14, 2020 Posted November 14, 2020 11 minutes ago, njbuff said: You think Neal can play outside, or no shot? In a pinch. I just don’t think he’s any good, anywhere on defense. 2 minutes ago, Hapless Bills Fan said: Possible they may be without some DB as well And maybe their best RB 1
Hapless Bills Fan Posted November 14, 2020 Posted November 14, 2020 I hope the coaches and team are successful in not being gobsmacked by this and in keeping up their spirits or even getting a bit of an "edge" to their play because of it 4
97bills Posted November 14, 2020 Posted November 14, 2020 2 hours ago, Hapless Bills Fan said: Why do you think Tre is out? It's Norman and Wallace, with Hyde questionable and his backup (Marlow) also out. See Sal C's very useful list upthread. Even so we’ve got to get better at corner whites going to have he’s hands full and our 2-3 corners are going to be toast. I hope we can get pressure and score at a hi level. Go bills
Hapless Bills Fan Posted November 14, 2020 Posted November 14, 2020 1 hour ago, Penfield45 said: Norman has played like 1 game for us this season it’s really not a big loss Three so far - 2 of them losses, including one loss where he got p'wned badly. Did make a key play in the Raiders game, though.
RochesterLifer Posted November 14, 2020 Posted November 14, 2020 (edited) 56 minutes ago, Hapless Bills Fan said: I hope the coaches and team are successful in not being gobsmacked by this and in keeping up their spirits or even getting a bit of an "edge" to their play because of it This touches on one of the reasons I have such high optimism and confidence in Beane, McDermott and the staff. They seem to face challenges with strength, always viewing the “opportunity” aspect of what is in front of them. This strikes me as a very smart and serious minded leadership team. Edited November 15, 2020 by RochesterLifer 3 1
CSBill Posted November 15, 2020 Posted November 15, 2020 4 hours ago, njbuff said: Josh Norman??? The gift that keeps on giving. Indeed, he has brought nothing to this team. Cut him!
SlimShady'sSpaceForce Posted November 15, 2020 Posted November 15, 2020 18 minutes ago, CSBill said: Indeed, he has brought nothing to this team. Cut him! that has me wondering the % of former Panthers players brought in worked and flopped in Buffalo
whatdrought Posted November 15, 2020 Posted November 15, 2020 Would be great if they were missing Buddah Baker to offset our covid losses. 1
Hapless Bills Fan Posted November 15, 2020 Posted November 15, 2020 27 minutes ago, SlimShady'sSpaceForce said: that has me wondering the % of former Panthers players brought in worked and flopped in Buffalo I'm not sure that's asking quite the right question. Every team brings in camp fodder guys, guys who fill the roster during training camp. No big deal, why not bring in guys you know something about, especially when you're trying to change a team's culture? Then there are the guys we sign who are significant expenditures of cap $$ and roster spots. What I'm saying is to figure out how successful or unsuccessful our "Carolina North" player personnel strategy has been, you probably don't want to examine the percentage of Captain Munnerlyns or the Kaelyn Clays or the Dean Marlowes who have been successful. You probably want to look at the guys we either traded for or signed for more than vet minimum dollars - Kelvin Benjamin, Star Lotulelei, Derek Anderson, Josh Norman, Vernon Butler, AJ Klein, Mario Addison. Or maybe not. Anyway here's a list, though I think there are a few more on there now
CEN-CAL17 Posted November 15, 2020 Posted November 15, 2020 That CB and LB list needs a lot of work this offseason.... I feel next years 53 is gonna have like 15 new guys on the defensive side of the ball...
CEN-CAL17 Posted November 15, 2020 Posted November 15, 2020 Bills need to put up 40+ Pts to have a chance....
JGMcD2 Posted November 15, 2020 Posted November 15, 2020 (edited) 19 minutes ago, Hapless Bills Fan said: I'm not sure that's asking quite the right question. Every team brings in camp fodder guys, guys who fill the roster during training camp. No big deal, why not bring in guys you know something about, especially when you're trying to change a team's culture? Then there are the guys we sign who are significant expenditures of cap $$ and roster spots. What I'm saying is to figure out how successful or unsuccessful our "Carolina North" player personnel strategy has been, you probably don't want to examine the percentage of Captain Munnerlyns or the Kaelyn Clays or the Dean Marlowes who have been successful. You probably want to look at the guys we either traded for or signed for more than vet minimum dollars - Kelvin Benjamin, Star Lotulelei, Derek Anderson, Josh Norman, Vernon Butler, AJ Klein, Mario Addison. Or maybe not. Anyway here's a list, though I think there are a few more on there now Preach Hap! Very well put. I’d even exclude 1-year deals as well... it’s just depth. Anderson, Daryl Williams, Josh Norman. Low-risk and high-reward. Williams panned out, Norman didn’t. But the point is they’re not going to kill you if they don’t pan out. I’m pretty sure Anderson was in response to Allen’s partially torn UCL from the Texans game? I may be wrong... he was a signing so far off the beaten path I never really considered him a substantial investment. I think I said it before... in years 1-3 of McDermott they brought in 17 former Panthers... two of which remain in the organization... Star and Dean Marlowe. They also let Marlowe go for a bit and brought him back this season. It’s really been a ton of depth type guys until this year and even now there’s still only like 8 former Panthers in the organization. 3 of them are depth guys (Smith, Marlowe, Worley), 1 of them opted out of the season (Star), 1 has barely played (Norman) and the other three are Klein, Addison and Williams. Addison has been consistent which is his MO, Klein has been everyone’s whipping boy and rightfully so and people on this board are campaigning for Williams to get $10-$12M a year. EDIT: Oops forgot Vernon Butler. Edited November 15, 2020 by JGMcD2
Scott7975 Posted November 15, 2020 Posted November 15, 2020 6 minutes ago, CEN-CAL17 said: Bills need to put up 40+ Pts to have a chance.... I don't think that will be the case but at least they are capable of it if it is. 2
TroutDog Posted November 15, 2020 Posted November 15, 2020 The pictures in the Bills app shows Christian Wade going with them: do PS players normally travel?
ShakAttack Posted November 15, 2020 Posted November 15, 2020 The hardest part is, when the day started it seemed like we were going to be healthier than we had been in weeks against the Cards, and that they would have more issues with injuries than we did. One step forward, two steps back. Always seems to be the case for the bills with injuries (and now covid)... except for 2019.
Hapless Bills Fan Posted November 15, 2020 Posted November 15, 2020 1 hour ago, JGMcD2 said: Preach Hap! Very well put. I’d even exclude 1-year deals as well... it’s just depth. Anderson, Daryl Williams, Josh Norman. Low-risk and high-reward. Williams panned out, Norman didn’t. But the point is they’re not going to kill you if they don’t pan out. I’m pretty sure Anderson was in response to Allen’s partially torn UCL from the Texans game? I may be wrong... he was a signing so far off the beaten path I never really considered him a substantial investment. I think I said it before... in years 1-3 of McDermott they brought in 17 former Panthers... two of which remain in the organization... Star and Dean Marlowe. They also let Marlowe go for a bit and brought him back this season. It’s really been a ton of depth type guys until this year and even now there’s still only like 8 former Panthers in the organization. 3 of them are depth guys (Smith, Marlowe, Worley), 1 of them opted out of the season (Star), 1 has barely played (Norman) and the other three are Klein, Addison and Williams. Addison has been consistent which is his MO, Klein has been everyone’s whipping boy and rightfully so and people on this board are campaigning for Williams to get $10-$12M a year. EDIT: Oops forgot Vernon Butler. Anderson was signed in early October, a couple weeks before Allen got injured, when the Clue Bird perched on Beane's earlob and chirped when you got a young rookie who barely knows how the highest level of college competition prepares and the other QB got the hook halfway through the season opener, you really need a vet to show the kid how to get it done as far as daily and weekly prep. I'm still salty that the Bills didn't do a better job filling that need before the season but my only problem with Anderson was that they didn't bring him, or someone like him, in sooner. I think you include the Josh Normans, Daryl Williams, Derek Anderson etc. They're brought in to fill a perceived need to upgrade performance and/or a veteran presence at their positions. If you didn't bring in Josh Norman for $5.7M, you trade for or bring in someone else. These are guys we need performance from. Certainly paying Norman that much is part of our current $3M cap space which perhaps kept us from making other moves to bolster the roster. On the other hand, signing ex-panther Daryl Worley to the practice squad is a low-risk deal where previous familiarity is a plus. The flip side people don't bring up is, how many similar guys did we sign from other organizations and what was their success or failure rate? See aforementioned AJ McCarron...Quinton Spain this season...it's not like ex-players are the only guys we sign (sometimes for good money) who for one or another reason, disappoint. 22 minutes ago, TroutDog said: The pictures in the Bills app shows Christian Wade going with them: do PS players normally travel? That's a really good question. I didn't think that the PS guys traveled, but I also saw Mike Love, who is a PS DE.
atlbillsfan1975 Posted November 15, 2020 Posted November 15, 2020 (edited) 7 hours ago, Hapless Bills Fan said: Anderson was signed in early October, a couple weeks before Allen got injured, when the Clue Bird perched on Beane's earlob and chirped when you got a young rookie who barely knows how the highest level of college competition prepares and the other QB got the hook halfway through the season opener, you really need a vet to show the kid how to get it done as far as daily and weekly prep. I'm still salty that the Bills didn't do a better job filling that need before the season but my only problem with Anderson was that they didn't bring him, or someone like him, in sooner. I think you include the Josh Normans, Daryl Williams, Derek Anderson etc. They're brought in to fill a perceived need to upgrade performance and/or a veteran presence at their positions. If you didn't bring in Josh Norman for $5.7M, you trade for or bring in someone else. These are guys we need performance from. Certainly paying Norman that much is part of our current $3M cap space which perhaps kept us from making other moves to bolster the roster. On the other hand, signing ex-panther Daryl Worley to the practice squad is a low-risk deal where previous familiarity is a plus. The flip side people don't bring up is, how many similar guys did we sign from other organizations and what was their success or failure rate? See aforementioned AJ McCarron...Quinton Spain this season...it's not like ex-players are the only guys we sign (sometimes for good money) who for one or another reason, disappoint. That's a really good question. I didn't think that the PS guys traveled, but I also saw Mike Love, who is a PS DE. Is this maybe a little extra juice for the sidelines? It is a big game. 8-2 and go into the bye on a high note. Sit back, heal up, hope for a couple key losses by other teams. Come back for the stretch to try and compete for home field advantage in the playoffs. Edited November 15, 2020 by atlbillsfan1975 1
JGMcD2 Posted November 15, 2020 Posted November 15, 2020 26 minutes ago, Hapless Bills Fan said: Anderson was signed in early October, a couple weeks before Allen got injured, when the Clue Bird perched on Beane's earlob and chirped when you got a young rookie who barely knows how the highest level of college competition prepares and the other QB got the hook halfway through the season opener, you really need a vet to show the kid how to get it done as far as daily and weekly prep. I'm still salty that the Bills didn't do a better job filling that need before the season but my only problem with Anderson was that they didn't bring him, or someone like him, in sooner. I think you include the Josh Normans, Daryl Williams, Derek Anderson etc. They're brought in to fill a perceived need to upgrade performance and/or a veteran presence at their positions. If you didn't bring in Josh Norman for $5.7M, you trade for or bring in someone else. These are guys we need performance from. Certainly paying Norman that much is part of our current $3M cap space which perhaps kept us from making other moves to bolster the roster. On the other hand, signing ex-panther Daryl Worley to the practice squad is a low-risk deal where previous familiarity is a plus. The flip side people don't bring up is, how many similar guys did we sign from other organizations and what was their success or failure rate? See aforementioned AJ McCarron...Quinton Spain this season...it's not like ex-players are the only guys we sign (sometimes for good money) who for one or another reason, disappoint. That's a really good question. I didn't think that the PS guys traveled, but I also saw Mike Love, who is a PS DE. I agree they mishandled the QB room with Josh early... I know they wanted to sign Fitz/McCown and it didn’t work out. They traded McCarron which defeated the purpose of bringing him in. Although, the whole mentoring thing is a little overblown IMO. You definitely need leaders in the locker room but it’s not always position to position. See Mario Addison comforting Josh after his grandmother passing. Josh seems to have developed just fine without a real veteran QB around the mentor him. Josh is Josh because he’s Josh. Point being, guys can learn how to do things the right way from guys who play different positions, ultimately it falls on the person who’s making the adjustments to actually make them. That Larry Fitz interview with Kim Pegula went into how Kurt Warner mentored him and in return he’s mentoring Kyler Murray in his own way. Josh was never going to fail because he didn’t have another older QB showing him the ropes. That’s what the coaching staff is for... if they’re not teaching a guy how to prepare that’s on them... it helps to have a player... but what we know about Josh... he was going to take care of it himself and absorb information from whomever gave it to him. He’s not the uncoachable type. Norman was brought in like Kevin Johnson to create completion for the CB2 role. Levi had his ups and downs last year but bringing in Norman was an attempt to elevate competition. I guess I’m more laissez faire when it comes to 1 year deals... I see them all as flier type deals. The market is limited each year, in terms of talent and talent at each position. You’re bringing in a guy to compete and if it doesn’t pan out there are no long term ramifications. If they do pan out, it helps you until you can find a long term solution. The whole current cap situation is WAY overblown... I mean seriously. Nobody coming in mid-season is going to be such a massive upgrade over the current personnel on any roster unless you’re trading for a real difference maker. It’s just way overblown. You spend money on guys and they get hurt or don’t perform... that’s the nature of professional sports. Looking at it from the lens of hindsight just doesn’t work. Otherwise, I agree wholeheartedly with you on the Panthers stuff. Really great point on the impact of signings from other teams... much better comparison for success.
Recommended Posts