Unpopular Bills takes, Past and present.

[spartacus]

5 hours ago, Brennan Huff said:

Marv Levy is one of the most overrated coaches in NFL history. I still love the man though

Marv was great with the players

He sucked with his coordiators

He vehemently opposed Marchibroda using the no-huddle

Other than Marchibroda, he hired and kept horrible co-ordiators

 

Walt Corey wasted Bruce Smith in a passive 3-4 defense

The players did not respect Walt's "expertise"

[Jauronimo]

10 hours ago, Mango said:

Lynch was easily the better back. 
 

Hot take I don’t take back: Buffalo, the same city that put Kaeps face in cross hairs, ran Lynch out of town. Dude was parked on the side of the road in a rich neighborhood in a Mercedes. Cops came to the car for no reason. Claimed to smell pot. Searched the car, found no burning or burnt weed, but did find a registered gun in a backpack in the trunk along with a couple of joints in the bag.

 

It was a giant nothing burger. It wasn’t some thugged out incident threatening his career. Oh yeah, he clipped a drunk girl dancing in the street in the rain. Not condoning that, but this isn’t any wild uncontrollable behavior. 
 

That was a stupid trade. 

That happened in Los Angeles County.

 

https://www.nfl.com/news/lynch-charged-with-three-gun-related-misdemeanors-in-california-09000d5d80ecf90c

[Mango]

Just now, Jauronimo said:

That happened in Los Angeles County.

 

https://www.nfl.com/news/lynch-charged-with-three-gun-related-misdemeanors-in-california-09000d5d80ecf90c

I am fully aware of where it was. The reason he was searched was trash. It wasn’t the police that ran Marshawn out of town, it was fans. 
 

Point was that the same FANS that put Kaeps face in cross hairs are the same fans that were clamoring to move him because he was “one step away from being kicked out of the league” it was a BS dog whistle/narrative at the time, and it’s a BS narrative now.  He was never close to being booted from the league or a year long suspension. 

[Midwest1981]

11 hours ago, Mango said:

Nobody wants to admit it because it’s more fun to crack jokes, but Buddy Nix and Chan Gailey were integral first steps to righting the nearly 20 years of wrong with this franchise. It took longer than we wanted, but the team had come off of a run at GM that included the corpse of Marv Levy,  Russ Brandon, and Tom Donohoe running our drafts. George Wilson was our starting SS and the dude was a WR like 12 weeks before the season. Think about that. That’s the depth chart Gailey and Nix inherited. Your best Safety could also be your slot receiver. There is literally nobody else on the roster...on a franchise in the NFL. Let’s not forget before that Tom D. Traded a first for Rob Johnson. Then had 20% of the cap tied up in Flutie and Johnson in 2000. Later cut RJ and took a larger dead cap hit on top of that. Our top 5 players are like 50% of the cap at that point. Then he traded ANOTHER First round pick for Drew Bledsoe. But wait, we aren’t done yet, in 2004 we traded a 1st and 2nd round pick to trade back into the first for JP Losman. What a total disaster. 
 

Gailey and Fitz are remembered better than Jauron because we had real football players, real football coaches, and a real football exec in the FO (granted with flaws). What those guys inherited in hindsight was not a professional football franchise. It reads almost like “Major League”. 

Just as a point of clarification/correction- and sorry if somebody else pointed this out and I just failed to see it- but it was actually John Butler who traded a 1st (9th overall pick in 1998; Jags took Fred Taylor) for Johnson.

[Bill from NYC]

1 hour ago, Straight Hucklebuck said:

Unpopular Takes:

 

1. The Bills screwed up the Jason Peters situation. I don't care that they renegotiated his deal once before. The fact that Derrick Dockery was making $7 million a year, and Langston Walker was making $5 million a year, when Jason Peters was making $3.25M was absurd. Funny how the Philadelphia Eagles were able to get a contract done immediately. Russ Brandon standing up in front of the media in 2009 saying he had no idea where Peters was, and that he hadn't heard from him since the 2008 season ended. And then seeing PFT quote sources saying the Bills got fleeced. 

 

Fans largely sided with the organization, saying Peters was a fat, out of shape slob and that the Bills made him into what he was. Rinky Dink organization. Peters is a HOF LT. 

 

Every word of the above is 100% true.

Jason Peters is one of the best players in the history of the team and we traded him for a bag of doughnuts.

[BullBuchanan]

10 minutes ago, Bill from NYC said:

Every word of the above is 100% true.

Jason Peters is one of the best players in the history of the team and we traded him for a bag of doughnuts.

We got Eric Wood. I really don't think letting Peters go ended up being a significant negative impact to us. We weren't going to the playoffs during the drought if we had Walter Pace, so I'm not sure how much it matters.We had 3 years of middling LT play after we traded Peters, but since 2012 when we got Cordy Glenn, it hasn't been a weakness.

Edited August 21, 2020 by BullBuchanan

[Bill from NYC]

You certainly mean Orlando Pace or Walter Jones but I get it.

 

My thing is you don't trade away a great LT for a chance at a decent to good Center. Smart organizations just don't make mistakes like that. Also, did you see the salaries of Dockery and Walker compared to that of Peters? Walker and Dockery both were second rate players. Wait, let me go a step further and say that they both sucked. Peters was great and having him would have afforded us the opportunity to be set at LT for many years. Trading JP was inexcusable.

 

jmo

 

 

[May Day 10]

My one that gets me yelled at is that I believe Lee Evans was vastly overrated

[Bill from NYC]

3 minutes ago, May Day 10 said:

My one that gets me yelled at is that I believe Lee Evans was vastly overrated

I thought so too for a while but then started to view him as a one trick pony.

[Jerry Jabber]

1 hour ago, Steve O said:

There's a fictional B movie  about the bills called Second String. Mularkey actually tried two of the plays from the movie in games. In one of them, Bledsoe starts walking off the field, starts to call a time out but his hands don't touch and there is a direct snap to the running back. Play worked in the movie, not so much in the game. As we're still in the midst of a pandemic, if you haven't seen the movie watch it.

Thanks, I'll have to check it out sometime. My favorite trick play Mularkey called, was when he had Bledsoe start off the play on a QB sneak, then Bledsoe stopped, turned around and threw the ball back to the RB (I believe it was McGahee) who ran it in for a 33 yard TD. It's the only time I've ever seen that play used by the Bills.

19 minutes ago, May Day 10 said:

My one that gets me yelled at is that I believe Lee Evans was vastly overrated

Evans would have been a good #2 WR behind someone like Eric Moulds. Too bad they only had a season together.

[Mango]

12 minutes ago, Bill from NYC said:

You certainly mean Orlando Pace or Walter Jones but I get it.

 

My thing is you don't trade away a great LT for a chance at a decent to good Center. Smart organizations just don't make mistakes like that. Also, did you see the salaries of Dockery and Walker compared to that of Peters? Walker and Dockery both were second rate players. Wait, let me go a step further and say that they both sucked. Peters was great and having him would have afforded us the opportunity to be set at LT for many years. Trading JP was inexcusable.

 

jmo

 

 

 

Also the narrative that the team wasn't going anywhere, so it didn't make a difference. The Bills had one of the highest paid OL in the entire league at that point, but didn't pay Peters. This was during a really dark time for Buffalo, probably the worst in franchise history when it came to managing and acquiring personnel. Our GM's were TD, Marv, and Russ. We got a back of footballs for Peters, overpaid Walker and Dockery by a mile. Another bag of footballs for Lynch. Of course the team was bad, but you don't keep making it bad. The need to draft Glenn was because of the mismanagement of Peters. Same thing for Levitre during that time. We could run through 100 roster decisions that all stacked on top of eachother that made the team terrible. Then tried to fix it by trading away all of our draft picks. The Bills in the early 2010's-ish were basically an expansion team without an expansion draft, and they did it to themselves. 

[eball]

i just have to say this thread is really bumming me out so I'll go now.

[Brennan Huff]

1 hour ago, spartacus said:

Marv was great with the players

He sucked with his coordiators

He vehemently opposed Marchibroda using the no-huddle

Other than Marchibroda, he hired and kept horrible co-ordiators

 

Walt Corey wasted Bruce Smith in a passive 3-4 defense

The players did not respect Walt's "expertise"

He was definitely a “players coach”. Which is why he had no control over their partying. Especially before the Super Bowls

[Jerry Jabber]

2 minutes ago, Mango said:

 

Also the narrative that the team wasn't going anywhere, so it didn't make a difference. The Bills had one of the highest paid OL in the entire league at that point, but didn't pay Peters. This was during a really dark time for Buffalo, probably the worst in franchise history when it came to managing and acquiring personnel. Our GM's were TD, Marv, and Russ. We got a back of footballs for Peters, overpaid Walker and Dockery by a mile. Another bag of footballs for Lynch. Of course the team was bad, but you don't keep making it bad. The need to draft Glenn was because of the mismanagement of Peters. Same thing for Levitre during that time. We could run through 100 roster decisions that all stacked on top of eachother that made the team terrible. Then tried to fix it by trading away all of our draft picks. The Bills in the early 2010's-ish were basically an expansion team without an expansion draft, and they did it to themselves. 

Drafting RB's and DB's in the first round almost every year during that period was another reason why the Bills were terrible. McGahee (a first round pick) was traded for two #rd round picks and a 7th rounder, Lynch was traded for a 4th rounder. I forget about Whitner (don't remember if his contract expired or was traded), when we could of had Ngata instead. A lot of dumb decisions back then.

 

IMO, the Bills should of tanked for a couple of years after Bledsoe was released and built the team up the right way, instead of the path they went, which they ended up going 6-10/7-9 almost every year.

[Rico]

Once again,

Tom Donahoe was a great football mind whose career was ruined by a POS of an owner.

Edited August 21, 2020 by Rico

[Bills fan since 87]

1 hour ago, eball said:

 

I know I'm not changing anyone's mind.  Just a personal observation.  I think it looks silly.  Do you put on your pads too so the jersey doesn't look ridiculously oversized?  And don't get me started on the guys who tuck their jerseys into their jeans.

 

 

No problem with grownups wearing jerseys but yeah, the tucked in Jersey is the worst look in the world.  Once saw a dude with a tucked in hockey jersey, ugh.

 

On Another note that kinda ties into this subject, I hate it when someone wears clothing from two different sports simultaneously.  IE: Bills jersey, Mets hat at the same time.

[Mango]

3 minutes ago, Jerry Jabber said:

Drafting RB's and DB's in the first round almost every year during that period was another reason why the Bills were terrible. McGahee (a first round pick) was traded for two #rd round picks and a 7th rounder, Lynch was traded for a 4th rounder. I forget about Whitner (don't remember if his contract expired or was traded), when we could of had Ngata instead. A lot of dumb decisions back then.

 

IMO, the Bills should of tanked for a couple of years after Bledsoe was released and built the team up the right way, instead of the path they went, which they ended up going 6-10/7-9 almost every year.

 

I forgot about the run on CB's and RB's forever. Ngata was obviously the better pick. Whitner gets a lot of hate. He had a nice career for himself and was a good SS. We were just a really bad team that needed a lot of help everywhere. Not his fault. 

I actually had some knee jerk PTSD with this FO at first. I stand by my logic for fear, but it is working out at the moment.  We traded our starting LT, to draft another LT. We traded our starting CB, that we drafted in preparation to let our CB walk in FA. And that starting CB we let walk was to replace another stating CB with a ton of athleticism but terrible ball skills. We did all of this, only to draft another CB in the first after passing on 2 QB's, so that we could take those picks and draft another QB a year later. Cut Shady, draft Singletary. It was just constant flashbacks for a while there. 

[Jerry Jabber]

1 minute ago, Mango said:

 

I forgot about the run on CB's and RB's forever. Ngata was obviously the better pick. Whitner gets a lot of hate. He had a nice career for himself and was a good SS. We were just a really bad team that needed a lot of help everywhere. Not his fault. 

I actually had some knee jerk PTSD with this FO at first. I stand by my logic for fear, but it is working out at the moment.  We traded our starting LT, to draft another LT. We traded our starting CB, that we drafted in preparation to let our CB walk in FA. And that starting CB we let walk was to replace another stating CB with a ton of athleticism but terrible ball skills. We did all of this, only to draft another CB in the first after passing on 2 QB's, so that we could take those picks and draft another QB a year later. Cut Shady, draft Singletary. It was just constant flashbacks for a while there. 

I thought Whitner was good in run support, not so much on pass defense.

 

You nailed it! It was a constant recycling of the same positions.

[Jauronimo]

Poz and London Fletcher were both excellent linebackers no matter how many times Bills fans claim they only made tackles "5 yards down field".  Neither player was Ray Lewis but that doesn't mean they sucked.

 

Bills fans will always cherish marginal NFL talents and resent blue chip players for making millions of dollars playing a kid's game.

[GunnerBill]

34 minutes ago, Mango said:

The Bills in the early 2010's-ish were basically an expansion team without an expansion draft, and they did it to themselves. 

 

Agree with that. Gailey and Nix made plenty of errors and were probably both in over their skies but my word was that roster an utter mess. There were no real cornerstone pieces there. They inherited a couple of decent running backs in Lynch and Fred. Other than that there was Kyle, Poz, Wood, Levitre and Byrd. I don't think there was a single other credible NFL starter on the roster. " I know Stevie Johnson and Fitz emerged as credible NFL players that season but that just came from Gailey and Nix sifting through the crap they had. And not a single one of those players.... not even Kyle... is a guy you say "that is a franchise piece we can build a winner around."

Edited August 21, 2020 by GunnerBill