McDermott on no trades: "There have been too many years of irresponsible decision-making, let's just put it that way."

[GG]

8 minutes ago, Ethan in Portland said:

What current roster players need to be paid????

There is not a single starter that needs a new contract. They are all under contract through 2020. 

 

It would be wise to extend Hyde & Poyer while they still have the cap room.  

[Ethan in Cleveland]

10 minutes ago, GG said:

 

It would be wise to extend Hyde & Poyer while they still have the cap room.  

Why? Poyer is replacable. They need to spend money on a pass rusher. Hyde and Poyer are locked up. No need to waste money paying them more. Hyde is a bit underpaid but not much.

[YoloinOhio]

26 minutes ago, Ethan in Portland said:

What current roster players need to be paid????

There is not a single starter that needs a new contract. They are all under contract through 2020. 

Poyer is underpaid and should be extended with a new deal. Tre is eligible for an extension, as is Matt Milano. They should consider extending Lawson imo. 

[Hapless Bills Fan]

On 10/30/2019 at 10:41 AM, In Summary said:

I think McDermott would fess up to Benjamin if asked directly.

 

Well, I wish someone had asked him to clarify if he was referring to trades or decisions he/Beane had made while employed by the Bills?

[Ethan in Cleveland]

1 minute ago, YoloinOhio said:

Poyer is underpaid and should be extended with a new deal. Tre is eligible for an extension, as is Matt Milano. They should consider extending Lawson imo. 

You and I both know they won't extend Lawson and its BS. He will get a decent deal in free agency. He might opt for a 1yr prove it deal with someone else hoping a different coaching staff will give him more opportunities and thus a bigger signing bonus the following year.

Poyer is underpaid but Bills have leverage.  They have other safeties on the roster and will almost certainly draft one next year.

Agree they should extend Tre, but they won't.  They will just use the 5th year extension to buy some time.

Im not as enamored with Milano as most but he has mostly made me look silly. Again, there is no need to extend him. He's signed on a rookie deal for two more years. He is not an all-pro so he has little leverage. 

Save the dollars for 2021 or spend on edge, wr, or OT this offseason

[Dr. Who]

6 minutes ago, Ethan in Portland said:

Save the dollars for 2021 or spend on edge, wr, or OT this offseason

I expect all three of these to be priorities in free agency and the draft. WR1, DE, and RT ought to be top of the list.

[Hapless Bills Fan]

On 10/30/2019 at 5:38 PM, GoBills808 said:

Right, because combined point differential is always the first stat you bring up when assessing coaches.

 

It’s a point, but what would you like to assess?

[GoBills808]

2 minutes ago, Hapless Bills Fan said:

 

It’s a point, but what would you like to assess?

With coaches it’s typically wins and losses. Playoff appearances. Division titles. Super Bowls. 

[Solomon Grundy]

It seems as McDermott is suffering from footinmouth syndrome 

12 minutes ago, ScottLaw said:

The Buffalo media is weak as *****. Amazing no follow up question was asked on that. 

?

[Hapless Bills Fan]

3 minutes ago, GoBills808 said:

With coaches it’s typically wins and losses. Playoff appearances. Division titles. Super Bowls. 

 

OK, so in his 2 years here, Ryan was 15-17.  #10 and 12 offense on points; #18 and 16 defense on points.  No playoffs.

In his first 2 years here, McDermott was 15-17.  #22 and 30 offense on points; #18 x2 on points.  Playoffs first year (with a lot of the talent the prev. GM ID’d.)

 

Naturally I hope that the McDermott/Beane philosophy of tear it all down/build it up new is creating something special and better, but the fact is, he’s yet to ‘show me’

[Hapless Bills Fan]

On 10/30/2019 at 10:30 AM, YoloinOhio said:

Oh snap. 

 

Dear Coach McDermott,

 

As a long time Bills fan, I write to express my gratitude that you have eschewed irresponsible decisions.  It would clearly have been irresponsible, for example, to risk a conditional 2020 5th round pick on Kenyan Drake.  His first week contributions for the Cardinals would clearly have had no place on our team.

 

A 3rd and 4th round pick would clearly have been irresponsible decision making to spend for Emmanuel Sanders and a 5th relative to trading a 3rd for Kelvin Benjamin and paying a $3.5M for a week or two of Corey Coleman.  Sanders initial contributions to the 49ers and his savvy as a route runner would have been of no use to our offense.

 

Signed, 

Hapless Bills Fan

 

 

[GoBills808]

40 minutes ago, Hapless Bills Fan said:

 

OK, so in his 2 years here, Ryan was 15-17.  #10 and 12 offense on points; #18 and 16 defense on points.  No playoffs.

In his first 2 years here, McDermott was 15-17.  #22 and 30 offense on points; #18 x2 on points.  Playoffs first year (with a lot of the talent the prev. GM ID’d.)

 

Naturally I hope that the McDermott/Beane philosophy of tear it all down/build it up new is creating something special and better, but the fact is, he’s yet to ‘show me’

Odd way of characterizing two vastly different first two years, philosophically speaking, of each regime...especially omitting the fact that Ryan and Co. were fired with a game left to play in their second year. And I would imagine the fact that McD took what was essentially someone else's squad (minus secondary, Dareus, and Watkins) to the playoffs would be a positive in their favor. 

 

These guys are pretty clearly on the upswing, whereas Ryan never improved, either on his first year or on Marrone's last. These guys have done both. They needed 2018 to reboot everything. I think your comparison of the two doesn't tell the whole story. 

 

 

[Hapless Bills Fan]

Just now, GoBills808 said:

Odd way of characterizing two vastly different first two years, philosophically speaking, of each regime...especially omitting the fact that Ryan and Co. were fired with a game left to play in their second year. And I would imagine the fact that McD took what was essentially someone else's squad (minus secondary, Dareus, and Watkins) to the playoffs would be a positive in their favor. 

 

These guys are pretty clearly on the upswing, whereas Ryan never improved, either on his first year or on Marrone's last. These guys have done both. They needed 2018 to reboot everything. I think your comparison of the two doesn't tell the whole story. 

 

Well, I hope it doesn’t tell the whole story.   As I said, naturally I hope their philosophy is correct and they’re building something better.

 

But I asked what metrics you’d use if point differential doesn’t please you, and I added in another that’s often used (offensive and defensive rank, I like points) 

The point is, while I hope they’re building something better, one can make a case that objectively, they’ve yet to lay down common coaching metrics that are a clear step above their predecessors.

[GoBills808]

1 minute ago, Hapless Bills Fan said:

 

Well, I hope it doesn’t tell the whole story.   As I said, naturally I hope their philosophy is correct and they’re building something better.

 

But I asked what metrics you’d use if point differential doesn’t please you, and I added in another that’s often used (offensive and defensive rank, I like points) 

The point is, while I hope they’re building something better, one can make a case that objectively, they’ve yet to lay down common coaching metrics that are a clear step above their predecessors.

Sure, if you leave out this season's record and the fact that Ryan was fired with one game to go in his second year. 

 

And points is the defensive metric you'd use to paint the picture you did. Yards isn't as convenient for your argument.

[Hapless Bills Fan]

Just now, GoBills808 said:

Sure, if you leave out this season's record and the fact that Ryan was fired with one game to go in his second year. 

 

And points is the defensive metric you'd use to paint the picture you did. Yards isn't as convenient for your argument.

 

I’m very consistent in using PF/PA always for every comparator I ever make anywhere on this board and have argued at length about why I don’t like or use yards.  Points are what win or lose football games.  Asserting I pick and choose by what’s “convenient” is, frankly, beneath you.

 

I don’t know what I’d do with this season’s record - the season isn’t done yet, and we had the identical record at this point in the season in McD’s 1st season 2017 and finished 9-7.  So stuff happens.

 

I think the point remains - we all hope they’re better, but what, so far, have they done that clearly demonstrates this?  Because we had a playoff game With the same record that wasn’t good enough for playoffs in 2014 and only good enough in 2017 because the Bengals won?  A bit tenuous don’t you think?

 

[GoBills808]

3 minutes ago, Hapless Bills Fan said:

 

I’m very consistent in using PF/PA always for every comparator I ever make anywhere on this board and have argued at length about why I don’t like or use yards.  Points are what win or lose football games.  Asserting I pick and choose by what’s “convenient” is, frankly, beneath you.

 

I don’t know what I’d do with this season’s record - the season isn’t done yet, and we had the identical record at this point in the season in McD’s 1st season 2017 and finished 9-7.  So stuff happens.

 

I think the point remains - we all hope they’re better, but what, so far, have they done that clearly demonstrates this?  Because we had a playoff game With the same record that wasn’t good enough for playoffs in 2014 and only good enough in 2017 because the Bengals won?  A bit tenuous don’t you think?

 

 

We have a QB who is in his second year and improving, drafted by this regime. We have a MLB in his second year and improving, also drafted by this regime. We have one of the top DBs in the league, again drafted by this regime. We have a top secondary overall, built 100% by this regime.  The Bills are currently 5-2 and in great position for a wildcard spot. I don't see what's so tenuous about any of that, I see a team very much on the upswing.

[Locomark]

Arrogance without big results is deadly. Sean, I still remember how badly you get blown out at home twice every year, how you were outcoached last week and versus Belicheat. Your pal Mr. Beane also hasn't been the best, giant money for mediocre Star, spending a high 2nd round pick on a kid that can't seem to be good enough to play either guard or tackle but we want him because he's position flexible when you could have had AJ Brown or Mecole Hardman as a WR2 or spending a 3rd round pick on a kid that sits the pine every game. Meanwhile you hoard draft capital while the good teams get better by making deals with theirs. We look for "value talent." and our teams shows it. We need play makers on both side of the ball.  No pass rushers and no big play makers on O will get us nowhere.

 

  I am sick of the tired Pegula mantra of "we are only a few years away" which they have been saying since they owned both teams. Next year's schedule will be tough again. Let's just start winning some meaningful games and then Sean can insinuate how great this regime is.  Your culture only goes so far. Winning is everything. Start winning games that matter and then you can talk with some attitude. Until then,  stop talking about the sins of the past when you haven't proven anything yet. 

Edited November 1, 2019 by Locomark

[Hapless Bills Fan]

29 minutes ago, GoBills808 said:

 

We have a QB who is in his second year and improving, drafted by this regime. We have a MLB in his second year and improving, also drafted by this regime. We have one of the top DBs in the league, again drafted by this regime. We have a top secondary overall, built 100% by this regime.  The Bills are currently 5-2 and in great position for a wildcard spot. I don't see what's so tenuous about any of that, I see a team very much on the upswing.

 

What you’re describing is promise.  We hope Allen continues to develop and is the QB of the offense.  We hope Edmunds continues to develop as the QB of the defense.  WE have a good secondary.  

 

But what have they actually achieved yet?  The Bills were 5-2 at this point in 2017.  We were just totally pwn’d on both lines and given an ass-whupping by the same run play, called over and over again.  Allen is having some struggles.  Edmunds is having some troubles.  What is the actual demonstrated achievement by some hard metric other than that 5-2 record?  I’m not saying it’s “tenuous” or against bad teams blah blah- I’m just saying it’s the same record we had in 2017, so I can’t point at it and say “Look!  Demonstrably better !”

 

Against this background, I think McDermott has a lot of nerve to take a poke at the previous administrations, if that is what he was doing with his comment “"There have been too many years of irresponsible decision-making, let's just put it that way." -- Sean McDermott“   I mean, Kenyon Drake just gained 152 combined yards, and AZ just got him for a conditional 5th in 2020.  Are there really NO player acquisitions that could have been “responsible” but helped our team?    I just feel he should prove something before he runs his mouth.

 

 

[GoBills808]

5 minutes ago, Hapless Bills Fan said:

 

What you’re describing is promise.  We hope Allen continues to develop and is the QB of the offense.  We hope Edmunds continues to develop as the QB of the defense.  WE have a good secondary.  

 

But what have they actually achieved yet?  The Bills were 5-2 at this point in 2017.  We were just totally pwn’d on both lines and given an ass-whupping by the same run play, called over and over again.  Allen is having some struggles.  Edmunds is having some troubles.  What is the actual demonstrated achievement by some hard metric other than that 5-2 record?  I’m not saying it’s “tenuous” or against bad teams blah blah- I’m just saying it’s the same record we had in 2017, so I can’t point at it and say “Look!  Demonstrably better !”

 

Against this background, I think McDermott has a lot of nerve to take a poke at the previous administrations, if that is what he was doing with his comment “"There have been too many years of irresponsible decision-making, let's just put it that way." -- Sean McDermott“   I mean, Kenyon Drake just gained 152 combined yards, and AZ just got him for a conditional 5th in 2020.  Are there really NO player acquisitions that could have been “responsible” but helped our team?    I just feel he should prove something before he runs his mouth.

 

 

Let me put this another way: what could a rational observer of this team reasonably expect to be better? Outside offensive production, which I think we can all acknowledge is an issue due in large part to a lack of true playmakers (which I believe will be resolved this offseason)...what more do you want out of this team at this particular point in time?

[Mango]

On 11/1/2019 at 12:18 AM, GoBills808 said:

Let me put this another way: what could a rational observer of this team reasonably expect to be better? Outside offensive production, which I think we can all acknowledge is an issue due in large part to a lack of true playmakers (which I believe will be resolved this offseason)...what more do you want out of this team at this particular point in time?

Dude, the offense is basically half of a team, and you want people to give an honest criticism of the team, MINUS the most glaring issue. 

Edited November 2, 2019 by Mango