Jump to content

Andre Reed Criticizes Personnel Decisions


Recommended Posts

42 minutes ago, The Drought said:

I'm almost positive that there are more former Bills in the playoffs this year than there are current Bills.

 

You can say that about any team not in the playoffs.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, MJS said:

 

You can say that about any team not in the playoffs.

Exactly. The number of current Bills in the playoffs in going to be zero because we came up short. You could say the same about the Jets or Fins. If you don't make the playoffs and there is even one former player on any of the remaining teams, that statement will hold true.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 1/13/2019 at 1:40 PM, LSHMEAB said:

As long as they start winning, they'll be fine. I would think all Bills fans would be tired of other teams popping up everywhere. It's our turn. Make or break in 2019.

Why is it we have have to continue to remind people of the plan? Get our QB, fix the cap, have extra draft picks- those 3 main components have been achieved along with 2 good drafts in a row! 

Edited by billsfan_34
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, billsfan_34 said:

Why is it we have have to continue to remind people of the plan? Get our QB, fix the cap, have extra draft picks- those 3 main components have been achieved along with 2 good drafts in a row! 

Good. So we're making the playoffs in 2019, right? Awesome.

  • Like (+1) 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, LSHMEAB said:

Good. So we're making the playoffs in 2019, right? Awesome.

I love it when people take something and spin it- kudos to you. No one has a crystal ball especially with injuries etc- but one thing is for certain; this team is heading in the right direction. QB position 1-3 settled, cap will allow for some FA’s of need, ten draft picks gives flexibility. Year 2 of the same offensive system and year 3 of the same defensive system is huge also. Oh, new ST/O line coordinators inbound- one possibly being Philbin. But yeah, its all doom and gloom.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, billsfan_34 said:

I love it when people take something and spin it- kudos to you. No one has a crystal ball especially with injuries etc- but one thing is for certain; this team is heading in the right direction. QB position 1-3 settled, cap will allow for some FA’s of need, ten draft picks gives flexibility. Year 2 of the same offensive system and year 3 of the same defensive system is huge also. Oh, new ST/O line coordinators inbound- one possibly being Philbin. But yeah, its all doom and gloom.

What's the spin? If everything is going according to plan, we should see some serious results in 2019, correct? That's what Bills fans should expect from their team. We've been bottom feeders long enough. Time to start winning lots of games.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 hours ago, LSHMEAB said:

What's the spin? If everything is going according to plan, we should see some serious results in 2019, correct? That's what Bills fans should expect from their team. We've been bottom feeders long enough. Time to start winning lots of games.

I expect a super bowl and this thing to be built the right way- which it appears they are doing. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

11 hours ago, billsfan_34 said:

I love it when people take something and spin it- kudos to you. No one has a crystal ball especially with injuries etc- but one thing is for certain; this team is heading in the right direction. QB position 1-3 settled, cap will allow for some FA’s of need, ten draft picks gives flexibility. Year 2 of the same offensive system and year 3 of the same defensive system is huge also. Oh, new ST/O line coordinators inbound- one possibly being Philbin. But yeah, its all doom and gloom.

This right here is a major reason you don't do a complete tear down in the NFL. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Pretty sure there are ex-Bills on almost every other NFL team - through trades, free agency, cuts, etc.

Pointing out that a former player is on a playoff team is a pretty lame way to criticize the front office.

 

If you want to criticize a personnel decision, then state your case why that individual decision was a bad one.

Don't just say "that guy is in the playoffs now." 

 

Was the Sammy Watkins trade BAD, just because he is in the playoffs?  That's a really poor argument.

- It doesn't take into account that the 2nd Round Pick we got was vital in the trade-up to get Josh Allen, who could end up being a franchise QB. 

- It doesn't take into account that we made the playoffs in 2017 even without Watkins on the roster. 

- It doesn't take into account that Los Angeles got him on a one-year rental, and still got knocked out after one playoff game (just like us). 

- It doesn't take into account that he signed for a whopping $16 million per year in Free Agency to be the #3 receiving option on the Chiefs. 

- It doesn't take into account that Watkins still hasn't broken 600 yards in a season since leaving Buffalo, which is statistically less-productive than Zay Jones. 

- It doesn't take into account that his foot injury kept him off the field AGAIN this season, limiting him to only nine games.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

17 minutes ago, mjt328 said:

Pretty sure there are ex-Bills on almost every other NFL team - through trades, free agency, cuts, etc.

Pointing out that a former player is on a playoff team is a pretty lame way to criticize the front office.

 

If you want to criticize a personnel decision, then state your case why that individual decision was a bad one.

Don't just say "that guy is in the playoffs now." 

 

Was the Sammy Watkins trade BAD, just because he is in the playoffs?  That's a really poor argument.

- It doesn't take into account that the 2nd Round Pick we got was vital in the trade-up to get Josh Allen, who could end up being a franchise QB. 

- It doesn't take into account that we made the playoffs in 2017 even without Watkins on the roster. 

- It doesn't take into account that Los Angeles got him on a one-year rental, and still got knocked out after one playoff game (just like us). 

- It doesn't take into account that he signed for a whopping $16 million per year in Free Agency to be the #3 receiving option on the Chiefs. 

- It doesn't take into account that Watkins still hasn't broken 600 yards in a season since leaving Buffalo, which is statistically less-productive than Zay Jones. 

- It doesn't take into account that his foot injury kept him off the field AGAIN this season, limiting him to only nine games.

 

 

 

it's a lot of ex-bills the last 20 years as major contributors to playoff teams

 

most notable for RB, secondary and WR

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

17 minutes ago, row_33 said:

it's a lot of ex-bills the last 20 years as major contributors to playoff teams

 

most notable for RB, secondary and WR

 

 

The current front office has been here for 2 years.  So the "last 20 years" is completely irrelevant.

Also, I would be curious to see what you would consider a "major contributor" from the guys we traded away:

 

- Sammy Watkins who played 9 games, barely had 500 yards and wasn't missed as the #3 target for the Chiefs

- Ronald Darby who has only played 16 games the last two seasons, and was on IR for both playoff games

- Reggie Ragland who logged 40 less tackles than either Edmunds or Milano, and was generally invisible all season

- Marcel Dareus who... whoops, was not in the playoffs

- Cordy Glenn who... oh yeah, same as above

 

I see two (recent) former Bills who I would consider major contributors to playoff teams.  Both left via free agency.  They were not traded away.

Stephon Gilmore, who has been more than adequately replaced by Tre White

Robert Woods, who would never be putting up these numbers outside of Sean McVay's offense

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, mjt328 said:

Pretty sure there are ex-Bills on almost every other NFL team - through trades, free agency, cuts, etc.

Pointing out that a former player is on a playoff team is a pretty lame way to criticize the front office.

 

If you want to criticize a personnel decision, then state your case why that individual decision was a bad one.

Don't just say "that guy is in the playoffs now." 

 

Was the Sammy Watkins trade BAD, just because he is in the playoffs?  That's a really poor argument.

- It doesn't take into account that the 2nd Round Pick we got was vital in the trade-up to get Josh Allen, who could end up being a franchise QB. 

- It doesn't take into account that we made the playoffs in 2017 even without Watkins on the roster. 

- It doesn't take into account that Los Angeles got him on a one-year rental, and still got knocked out after one playoff game (just like us). 

- It doesn't take into account that he signed for a whopping $16 million per year in Free Agency to be the #3 receiving option on the Chiefs. 

- It doesn't take into account that Watkins still hasn't broken 600 yards in a season since leaving Buffalo, which is statistically less-productive than Zay Jones. 

- It doesn't take into account that his foot injury kept him off the field AGAIN this season, limiting him to only nine games.

 

Did you really want Andre Reed to dissect the personnel decisions in this manner on Twitter? The guy was sitting at home making an observation at the large number of ex Bills currently in the playoffs. He's not applying for a GM position.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, C.Biscuit97 said:

He was 100% right. Not sure why anyone has a problem with it.  We had a very talented roster.  

 

But its smart what what the new regime did.  Trade away/ let talent go and pretend like they had nothing to work with.  Good way to buy yourself some time.

 

 Don’t forget “make the playoffs.“

Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...