YoloinOhio Posted December 31, 2018 Posted December 31, 2018 (edited) I included Quenton Nelson because OL never get love and he has transformed the Colts OL and kept Luck upright all year Edited December 31, 2018 by YoloinOhio
whatdrought Posted December 31, 2018 Posted December 31, 2018 (edited) Should be Mayfield. Barkley disappeared for whole games at a time, and Jackson has played well but has mostly benefitted from a great cast and good play call. Baker has had a huge impact on that team. Edited December 31, 2018 by whatdrought
TuelTime Posted December 31, 2018 Posted December 31, 2018 Most TDs by a rookie and didn't even play a full 16 games. I'd say its Baker Mayfield. 1
Rico Posted December 31, 2018 Posted December 31, 2018 Lamar, the bottom-line results speak for themselves. 1 1
Rebel101 Posted December 31, 2018 Posted December 31, 2018 Barkley is the 3rd rookie ever to amass 2,000 scrimmage yards. Baker on the other hand broke the record for most touchdown passes by a rookie QB. But I think I would go Barkley 1
PetermansRedemption Posted December 31, 2018 Posted December 31, 2018 I like Lamar because of his record. 6-1 as a starter is damn impressive. 1
downunderbill Posted December 31, 2018 Posted December 31, 2018 Mayfield deserves to win it. He's an arrogant douche, but the best QB drafted this year.
billsbackto81 Posted December 31, 2018 Posted December 31, 2018 31 minutes ago, Bills2ref said: I like Lamar because of his record. 6-1 as a starter is damn impressive. 5-1 58% 1022 yds 6 TDS, 3 picks 170 yds passing per game behind a scheme designed to run and a stellar D. OROY? Uh.. nope Mayfield or Barkley will be the pick.
PetermansRedemption Posted December 31, 2018 Posted December 31, 2018 17 minutes ago, billsbackto81 said: 5-1 58% 1022 yds 6 TDS, 3 picks 170 yds passing per game behind a scheme designed to run and a stellar D. OROY? Uh.. nope Mayfield or Barkley will be the pick. You are conveniently forgetting the 605 rushing yards and 3 rushing tds. If he was so simple to stop, teams would. He has been impressive and is tailor made for that stellar defense. I wouldn’t be surprised at all if Baltimore does damage in the playoffs, I like them to beat the Chargers next week.
BullBuchanan Posted December 31, 2018 Posted December 31, 2018 Barkley is the easiest pick there is. If the giants were a playoff team He'd be in the MVP conversation. He's better than the rest of the Giants roster combined. 1
JerseyBills Posted December 31, 2018 Posted December 31, 2018 53 minutes ago, Bills2ref said: You are conveniently forgetting the 605 rushing yards and 3 rushing tds. If he was so simple to stop, teams would. He has been impressive and is tailor made for that stellar defense. I wouldn’t be surprised at all if Baltimore does damage in the playoffs, I like them to beat the Chargers next week. I just can't help but see Tyrod 2.0... If we had the #1 D , we would have went to the playoffs with Roman , when we had the #1 Rush O. We would have been praising Taylor up n down but u take away Roman or the #1 D and he's a backup QB. Not saying Lamar can't progress, it's just what I see watching him. The kid is super athletic , the scheme is phenomenal and the D is great . He's extremely limited in the pass game though, and that's not going to get you far in the playoffs imo.
DCOrange Posted December 31, 2018 Posted December 31, 2018 If we're going based on who was the most valuable rookie, I'd say it's Baker and then Lamar. In terms of who was simply the best player, it's a tough call between Baker and Saquon. I'd probably lean towards Saquon. 1
formerlyofCtown Posted December 31, 2018 Posted December 31, 2018 1 hour ago, Rebel101 said: Barkley is the 3rd rookie ever to amass 2,000 scrimmage yards. Baker on the other hand broke the record for most touchdown passes by a rookie QB. But I think I would go Barkley QB is a harder position to set Rookie records. Unless they are Peterman type records. Does Barkley have the most scrimmage yards ever by a Rookie.
BillyWhiteShows Posted December 31, 2018 Posted December 31, 2018 Gotta be Baker. Completely turned around the culture in Cleveland
Gugny Posted December 31, 2018 Posted December 31, 2018 Barkley and it's not even close. 4 hours ago, Bills2ref said: I like Lamar because of his record. 6-1 as a starter is damn impressive. (W-L) is a team stat; not a QB stat. 1
KD in CA Posted December 31, 2018 Posted December 31, 2018 4 hours ago, YoloinOhio said: I included Quenton Nelson because OL never get love and he has transformed the Colts OL and kept Luck upright all year Quenton Nelson is a great football player, best of the group, but Mayfield is the rookie MVP.
from_dunkirk Posted December 31, 2018 Posted December 31, 2018 4 hours ago, YoloinOhio said: I included Quenton Nelson because OL never get love and he has transformed the Colts OL and kept Luck upright all year You included Lamar, but not Josh Allen? 2 hours ago, DCOrange said: If we're going based on who was the most valuable rookie, I'd say it's Baker and then Lamar. In terms of who was simply the best player, it's a tough call between Baker and Saquon. I'd probably lean towards Saquon. Josh has way better rushing stats than Lamar nad is a better passer. 3 hours ago, Bills2ref said: You are conveniently forgetting the 605 rushing yards and 3 rushing tds. If he was so simple to stop, teams would. He has been impressive and is tailor made for that stellar defense. I wouldn’t be surprised at all if Baltimore does damage in the playoffs, I like them to beat the Chargers next week. LOL. Josh Allen has 631 yards and 8 TD's with 58 less attempts than Jackson. He is averaging 7.1 yards per attempts, vs. only 4.1 for Lamar.
Recommended Posts