Over 29 years of fanhood Posted May 30, 2018 Posted May 30, 2018 (edited) Good topic; Marone, by far the best. Don’t like him fine, but he turned the organization around. Gailey: best of the worst. Made the most of his JV wr, secondary and LB squads. Trent Edwards v Ryan Fitzpatrick... ugh Juaron: (7–9 no matter how good/bad the talent) Mularkey: actually had a winning season, although he left town a goat, his resemblance to Kevin Costner makes him look like a leadership figure. So there’s that. Greggo: meh Rex: actually took a good team with a stout defense and totally jacked it up by imposing his scheme which completely misfit the talent. The whole time in front of the podium he was acting like he was winning rings... what an epic failure Edited May 30, 2018 by Over 29 years of fanhood 1
The Jokeman Posted May 30, 2018 Posted May 30, 2018 18 minutes ago, sullim4 said: Gailey Marrone, obviously. Gregggo Cheeseburgers Mularkey Rex, fully pregnant. Skeletor Gailey had the least amount of talent to work with and actually adapted his schemes to his players rather than the opposite... for that he gets the top spot imo. Except for the defense when he made us go 3-4 after being a 4-3 base. Which lead us to take Troupe etc. I'm also upset we drafted Spiller when had Lynch and Jackson already on the team, we could have used that pick to draft Dez Bryant and done so much better in retrospect. My rankings: Marone Gailey Williams Mularkey Jauron Ryan
GunnerBill Posted May 30, 2018 Posted May 30, 2018 Marrone *Big drop off* Mularkey Chan Jauron Williams *Big drop off* Rex !@#$ing Ryan. 1
TheBrownBear Posted May 30, 2018 Posted May 30, 2018 (edited) Marrone Jauron (Terrible talent level on those teams. Did their best to wring blood from a stone) Mularkey Gailey Williams Ryan Edited May 30, 2018 by TheBrownBear
Andrew in CA Posted May 30, 2018 Posted May 30, 2018 55 minutes ago, Over 29 years of fanhood said: Good topic; Marone, by far the best. Don’t like him fine, but he turned the organization around. Gailey: best of the worst. Made the most of his JV wr, secondary and LB squads. Trent Edwards v Ryan Fitzpatrick... ugh Juaron: (7–9 no matter how good/bad the talent) Mularkey: actually had a winning season, although he left town a goat, his resemblance to Kevin Costner makes him look like a leadership figure. So there’s that. Greggo: meh Rex: actually took a good team with a stout defense and totally jacked it up by imposing his scheme which completely misfit the talent. The whole time in front of the podium he was acting like he was winning rings... what an epic failure I agree with this
WhitewalkerInPhilly Posted May 30, 2018 Posted May 30, 2018 Uggh, this is rough Marrone: Actually left with a winning season. If he had been willing to change offense, and let Schwartz have the defense I wouldn't have been shocked if we resembled what the Jags are now. Gailey: Got what he could get out of a sub-par QB. I wonder what he could have done with Shady and Tyrod. Mularky: Meh Greggo: Meh Jauron: Lower Meh Rex: It's hard, because I was thrilled when he got here. I still enjoy his personality. But man, the defense backslid hard and he bears a lot for that. Tie in that he had one of the most talented rosters in years, and still couldn't do it, I think he is deserving of the bottom of the pile.
MDH Posted May 30, 2018 Posted May 30, 2018 Technically, Wade Phillips should be included on this list. His last season as HC was the first season of "the drought." So he kicked things off. 1
row_33 Posted May 30, 2018 Posted May 30, 2018 20 minutes ago, MDH said: Technically, Wade Phillips should be included on this list. His last season as HC was the first season of "the drought." So he kicked things off. Wade would be #1..... 1
Tcali Posted May 30, 2018 Posted May 30, 2018 3 hours ago, The Real Buffalo Joe said: Rank 'em. REX RYAN, 2015-2016 DOUG MARRONE, 2013-14 CHAN GAILEY, 2010-12 DICK JAURON, 2006-09 MIKE MULARKEY, 2004-05 GREGG WILLIAMS, 2001-03 (Not including interim coaches Lynn and Fewell) Marrone Mularkey Gregg Williams Rex Ryan Dick Jauron Chan Gailey
OldTimeAFLGuy Posted May 30, 2018 Posted May 30, 2018 Marrone Gailey Mularkey TIE: Jauron, Williams DEAD LAST: Train Wrecks
FrankoElTanko Posted May 30, 2018 Posted May 30, 2018 Gotta go w/ 1. Chan, 2. Marrone (boring however, he was trending up) and 3. (ugh, unfortunately) Mularky. Although if I had to not vote for 3-6, I could do that without remorse also. Mularky showed promise and actually led us to a 9-7 record but he was a patsy for Donahue and the roster could never recover. In regard to the foot soldier: Rex, he brought some recognition with him and followed suit by falling flat on his fat face and somehow utterly ruining a defense. Gregg was meh and Dick Jauron was by far the worst... We NEEDED a HC badly at the time, in particular we were looking for more of a big time name. Instead we chose Chicago cast-off DJ... to make matters worse we extended him when we all knew the experiment was over...
GunnerBill Posted May 30, 2018 Posted May 30, 2018 I think a lot of people are a bit high on Chan because he was likeable. Classy guy, nice guy and his team was fun and embodied a kind of underdog spirit. I thought that watching the Fred Jackson roast clips... that team tried and tried and tried and they were fun. If I could have wished any of the drought teams to the post-season it would have been that Gailey squad.... but ultimately as a coach he was also the man who hired Wannatasche and couldn't get that side of the ball sorted out at all.
OldTimeAFLGuy Posted May 30, 2018 Posted May 30, 2018 ...this is a dreadfully painful thread.....almost like picking what cancer you want....
Freddie's Dead Posted May 30, 2018 Posted May 30, 2018 WADE PHILLIPS #1 BY FAR, AND IT AIN'T EVEN CLOSE FOR 2ND!
baskingridgebillsfan Posted May 30, 2018 Posted May 30, 2018 Marrone Ryan Mario took a big step down and he lost his safties i wouldn't blame Rex for the defense regressing. He didn't help or adapt but there were a lot of variables Dickie j the team was hard to watch but he got a lot out of very little talent Chan on the hand Chan's teams didn't win much but they were fun Mularkey WIlliams
BuffaloMatt Posted May 31, 2018 Posted May 31, 2018 (edited) 6 hours ago, The Real Buffalo Joe said: Rank 'em. REX RYAN, 2015-2016 DOUG MARRONE, 2013-14 CHAN GAILEY, 2010-12 DICK JAURON, 2006-09 MIKE MULARKEY, 2004-05 GREGG WILLIAMS, 2001-03 (Not including interim coaches Lynn and Fewell) Just remove Rex completely, he was such a jackass! Then leave list as is. Edited May 31, 2018 by BuffaloMatt
oldmanfan Posted May 31, 2018 Posted May 31, 2018 Malarkey may have had a shot but got paranoid when Marv came back in the picture.
mjohns85 Posted May 31, 2018 Posted May 31, 2018 6 hours ago, sullim4 said: Gailey Marrone, obviously. Gregggo Cheeseburgers Mularkey Rex, fully pregnant. Skeletor Gailey had the least amount of talent to work with and actually adapted his schemes to his players rather than the opposite... for that he gets the top spot imo. This^^^
formerlyofCtown Posted May 31, 2018 Posted May 31, 2018 8 hours ago, The Real Buffalo Joe said: Rank 'em. REX RYAN, 2015-2016 DOUG MARRONE, 2013-14 CHAN GAILEY, 2010-12 DICK JAURON, 2006-09 MIKE MULARKEY, 2004-05 GREGG WILLIAMS, 2001-03 (Not including interim coaches Lynn and Fewell) They might have been 2 of the better ones.(Lynn and Fewell) Gailey Marrone Mularkey Jauron Williams Rex Really don't think any of them got a fair shake. God rest his soul Mr. Wilson may have been the biggest issue.
Agent 91 Posted May 31, 2018 Posted May 31, 2018 8 hours ago, BBills88 said: CHAN GAILEY, 2010-12 DOUG MARRONE, 2013-14 MIKE MULARKEY, 2004-05 GREGG WILLIAMS, 2001-03 DICK JAURON, 2006-09 REX RYAN, 2015-2016 I personally would flip Jauron and Rex but this is great
Recommended Posts