Who was better when they arrived in Buffalo

[Buffalo716]

Question is simple. Who do you think was the better QB when they arrived in Buffalo.

 

TT or McCarron

Edited May 6, 2018 by Buffalo716

[Another Fan]

McCarron should have actually won a playoff game.  The Bengals fumbled it away that night when they were on cruise control. 

 

Not sure about starter, but he's a very solid backup

[Buffalo716]

Just now, Another Fan said:

McCarron should have actually won a playoff game.  The Bengals fumbled it away that night when they were on cruise control. 

 

Not sure about starter, but he's a very solid backup

 

I agree that at worst we have a super solid backup 

[Augie]

I haven’t seen much of pro AJ (who has?). I went Tyrod due to the dual threat. We could score, but we had a Rex defense. 

Edited May 6, 2018 by Augie

[Buffalo716]

Just now, Augie said:

I have seen much of pro AJ (who has?). I went Tyrod due to the dual threat. We could score, but we had a Rex defense. 

 

Respectable take 

[Augie]

1 minute ago, Buffalo716 said:

 

Respectable take 

 

I’m of course biased by type fact that I saw what we had in Tyrod, and AJ is almost a complete mystery. I certainly hope I’m wrong, because we have AJ on our current roster! 

[DriveFor1Outta5]

9 minutes ago, Another Fan said:

McCarron should have actually won a playoff game.  The Bengals fumbled it away that night when they were on cruise control. 

 

Not sure about starter, but he's a very solid backup

Did the Bengals fumble away that game, or did AJ McCarron? 

[stony]

Just now, DriveFor1Outta5 said:

Did the Bengals fumble away that game, or did AJ McCarron? 

Burfict?

[26CornerBlitz]

Taylor has never played with a receiving corps with the likes of AJ Green, Marvin Jones, and Mohamed Sanu and he still looked better than AJM.  Taylor is the better player. 

[Aussie Joe]

AJ had started 4 games prior to coming to Buffalo...

 

TT had thrown about 4 passes...

[billsfan89]

Neither is/was really anything when they arrived. AJ played a little more but didn't light the world on fire in his limited playing time. 

[DriveFor1Outta5]

1 minute ago, stony said:

Burfict?

Thanks,  I had forgotten that play. I just remembered a McCarron fumble with a pick or two as well. 

[stony]

Just now, DriveFor1Outta5 said:

Thanks,  I had forgotten that play. I just remembered a McCarron fumble with a pick or two as well. 

I'm not even sure, I just remember a huge meltdown by the Bengals and the knock-out hit on Brown.  I think there were a few more unfortunate events in that meltdown. 

[Stank_Nasty]

1 minute ago, DriveFor1Outta5 said:

Thanks,  I had forgotten that play. I just remembered a McCarron fumble with a pick or two as well. 

It was quite literally Jeremy hill. All the bengals had to do was sit on the clock down inside Pitt territory and then kick an fg to basically seal it. Hill had one job. Don’t fumble.... he fumbled. 

Just now, stony said:

I'm not even sure, I just remember a huge meltdown by the Bengals and the knock-out hit on Brown.  I think there were a few more unfortunate events in that meltdown. 

It should have never come to that. Hill had one job to do. Hold onto the ball. And he didn’t. 

[Buffalo Barbarian]

30 minutes ago, Buffalo716 said:

Question is simple. Who do you think was the better QB when they arrived in Buffalo.

 

TT or McCarron

 

McCarron I think started more games and should won that playoff game against Pittsburgh, so going with him.

 

 

Edited May 6, 2018 by Buffalo Barbarian

[DriveFor1Outta5]

2 minutes ago, Stank_Nasty said:

It was quite literally Jeremy hill. All the bengals had to do was sit on the clock down inside Pitt territory and then kick an fg to basically seal it. Hill had one job. Don’t fumble.... he fumbled. 

It should have never come to that. Hill had one job to do. Hold onto the ball. And he didn’t. 

I vaguely remember that game. I was somewhat impressed by McCarron minus the turnovers. The rest of the team falling apart against the Steelers was something that I had forgotten. Sounds like

typical Bengals stuff. 

[Buffalo Barbarian]

24 minutes ago, Another Fan said:

McCarron should have actually won a playoff game.  The Bengals fumbled it away that night when they were on cruise control. 

 

Not sure about starter, but he's a very solid backup

 

Burfect  lost the game with those stupid fouls.

 

 

[SlimShady'sSpaceForce]

12 minutes ago, 26CornerBlitz said:

Taylor has never played with a receiving corps with the likes of AJ Green, Marvin Jones, and Mohamed Sanu and he still looked better than AJM.  Taylor is the better player. 

 

In the regular season AJM had 6 TD’s 2 INT’s in 3 games (over 14 points in a playoff game).  The 2 INTs were in his first game.  

 

Tyrod has had talent in Buffalo, he just failed to produce.  

 

 

 

The Steelers playoff game — AJM took the lead with about 2 minutes left.  

 

The Steelers were pinned deep and because of two 15 yard penalties by  Burdict and another guy the Steelers ended up in FG range and won the game.  

 

 

[GoBills808]

Obviously McCarron. Taylor hadn’t done anything before coming to Buffalo.

[26CornerBlitz]

Just now, GoBills808 said:

Obviously McCarron. Taylor hadn’t done anything before coming to Buffalo.

 

When McCarron played for CIN there was a significant drop off in production from when Andy Dalton was in the lineup.