PrimeTime101 Posted April 30, 2018 Posted April 30, 2018 [Note to all So.. Lets take the Rookies out of the equation because we do not know where they will end up. Keep QB conversation out of this topic please.] So. How much more talent does this team need talent wise other then the QB position. I still think we are hurting at the following positions *RB (this is a future thing because of McCoy's age) Guard. I think in FA or next years draft we really have to hammer this position. DE I think this is another position of need in future drafts. OLB. we have one good player here but who is on the other side this year? *S. Again this is future because I doubt we can keep both FS and S after this year. so G, DE and OLB are instant concerns. Thoughts? also with poll do not take QB in consideration! thanks.
LeGOATski Posted April 30, 2018 Posted April 30, 2018 6, they can get into the playoffs with this talent, but they're definitely at the low end of playoff-caliber teams. If we're simply assessing talent, I don't think you need to take future availability issues into account.
Mango Posted April 30, 2018 Posted April 30, 2018 If 5 is average, I went with 4, we are a bit below and lacking depth just about everywhere. That is just what happens when you cut/trade 30 players two years in a row I guess...??♂️
DriveFor1Outta5 Posted April 30, 2018 Posted April 30, 2018 This very difficult for me to do, because there is a major discrepancy between offensive and defensive talent imo. I like a lot of our young defensive talent, and would be willing to give them a 7. Our offense is worthy of about a 3.
Chuck Wagon Posted April 30, 2018 Posted April 30, 2018 I'm the pessimist who said 3. I think we have the worst WR and worst OL situation in the league, given there's nothing proven at QB we are near the bottom there, we are VERY inexperienced at LB and McD relies heavily on the position in his scheme and I'm not convinced we have anyone on the DL who is going to dictate blocking schemes. 1
Over 29 years of fanhood Posted April 30, 2018 Posted April 30, 2018 (edited) Mediocre/unproven roster with an excellent secondary and running back. O-line, front seven and WR a huge ? not to mention QB.. not to mention offensive scheme. I think its just just too hard to tell until they hit the field Edited April 30, 2018 by Over 29 years of fanhood
hondo in seattle Posted April 30, 2018 Posted April 30, 2018 PT101, thanks for not starting another thread about why we did or didn't get the wrong QB in the draft! (Yikes, I'm usually a patient man but I'm getting tired of people thinking their opinion on the Allen pick needs a new thread). I was debating 4 or 5 and decided to let the optimist in me win out and voted 5. We have a lot of JAGs who could maybe start on other teams but few stars.
thurst44 Posted April 30, 2018 Posted April 30, 2018 2 minutes ago, Chuck Wagon said: I'm the pessimist who said 3. I think we have the worst WR and worst OL situation in the league, given there's nothing proven at QB we are near the bottom there, we are VERY inexperienced at LB and McD relies heavily on the position in his scheme and I'm not convinced we have anyone on the DL who is going to dictate blocking schemes. I'm the optimist (as usual) who went with 7. The offensive talent is certainly meh right now (although our RBs pull us out of the gutter, and Dawkins is strong, Benjamin and the TEs have talent and if Logan Thomas ever comes together), but I truly believe we are rolling very deep on defense. The 26th ranking was very misleading as they were dominant in more games than they were bad, but in that three-game stretch, everything was near-historically bad, and that tanked our defensive ratings.
Hapless Bills Fan Posted April 30, 2018 Posted April 30, 2018 26 minutes ago, PrimeTime101 said: [Note to all So.. Lets take the Rookies out of the equation because we do not know where they will end up. Keep QB conversation out of this topic please.] So. How much more talent does this team need talent wise other then the QB position. I still think we are hurting at the following positions *RB (this is a future thing because of McCoy's age) Guard. I think in FA or next years draft we really have to hammer this position. DE I think this is another position of need in future drafts. OLB. we have one good player here but who is on the other side this year? *S. Again this is future because I doubt we can keep both FS and S after this year. so G, DE and OLB are instant concerns. Thoughts? also with poll do not take QB in consideration! thanks. PrimeTime, no offense (ha!) but that's pretty hard to rank with taking the rookies out of the equation. Every team has talent holes due to salary cap sacrifices and FA, and tries to boost the talent through the draft, and if you leave out FA and QB its kind of "dismal city"
Chuck Wagon Posted April 30, 2018 Posted April 30, 2018 14 minutes ago, thurst44 said: I'm the optimist (as usual) who went with 7. The offensive talent is certainly meh right now (although our RBs pull us out of the gutter, and Dawkins is strong, Benjamin and the TEs have talent and if Logan Thomas ever comes together), but I truly believe we are rolling very deep on defense. The 26th ranking was very misleading as they were dominant in more games than they were bad, but in that three-game stretch, everything was near-historically bad, and that tanked our defensive ratings. Outside of White, I think the defense truly was an example of the "sum is better than the parts". There's just not all that much individual talent that jumps off the page at you, but when they all play together it's a strong bunch. On offense, god forbid if Shady got hurt we would have no prayer. The biggest thing, I think we have buy in on "the process" across the roster. Guys give it their all and believe in what's happening. That goes a long way towards overcoming talent deficiencies. But this team has lost a ton of individual talent since McBeane arrived, the problem was that talent played like individuals. 1
ddaryl Posted April 30, 2018 Posted April 30, 2018 were in the bottom half for sure. I rated us at 4 for now
Bill Murray Posted April 30, 2018 Posted April 30, 2018 (edited) i think we were a 7 or 6 last year, but losing E Wood, Incognito, and Tyrod i think we downgrade to 5 heading into the season. D slightly above average, O slightly below. O ex-Shady is bottom quartile in the league On the tyrod point, im not saying McCaron doesnt have more upside, and wont be better than tyrod at some point during this season, but he at this point hasnt started any games and TT has won many, so lets not hijack the threat w TT partisanship... Edited April 30, 2018 by Bill Murray
Kelly the Dog Posted April 30, 2018 Posted April 30, 2018 Amongst the worst in the league at OL, WR, QB, LB. There isn't one position we are loaded although our DL and DB are pretty solid as far as starters go but we lack depth. I agree though that especially on D, the sum is great than the parts. Barring a lot of injuries, if Edmunds is decent, we should have a pretty good defense.
BigPappy Posted April 30, 2018 Posted April 30, 2018 I rated them a 5 and I am thinking that might even be pushing it right now. HUGE question mark with the offense in general but especially OL and WR's. The defensive line is average, LB is a ?. Right now the only positives we have are RB and our defensive backfield. McD seems to have the knack of coaching players up so hopefully he can do that again this year. I hope who ever is the starting QB is as mobile as TT was.
SCBills Posted April 30, 2018 Posted April 30, 2018 (edited) I went with a 7. Our defense is probably an 8 in terms of talent. The DL as a whole is now very talented and deep, we have two young stud linebackers and the secondary has 3 studs and whatever Vontae Davis turns out to be. Our offense, a 5.5 because one of one the best players in the league is on it. The O side is tough, we don't really know what we have until an actual QB takes the field with them. Edited April 30, 2018 by SCBills
BuffaloHokie13 Posted April 30, 2018 Posted April 30, 2018 Feels like a 4 right now, but that's typical of a roster that was stripped of it's large contracts and is rebuilding and relying on youth at several positions.
Bob in STL Posted April 30, 2018 Posted April 30, 2018 I picked 6 - meaning we can make a wildcard playoff birth with some good luck and some great coaching ---- like last year. If a few rookies and free agents step up and are solid starters we can move to 7, wont know until week 10 if that is true.
PrimeTime101 Posted April 30, 2018 Author Posted April 30, 2018 4 hours ago, Hapless Bills Fan said: PrimeTime, no offense (ha!) but that's pretty hard to rank with taking the rookies out of the equation. Every team has talent holes due to salary cap sacrifices and FA, and tries to boost the talent through the draft, and if you leave out FA and QB its kind of "dismal city" Lol I agree and that's why it makes it interesting because we can tank where they are at in hopes that players turn out. example if we have them ranked 6 now imagine if QB pans out asap. that's whole point.. without making it about the QB I am actually amazed at how far apart the votes really are!
Recommended Posts