Domdab99 Posted April 3, 2018 Author Posted April 3, 2018 This time I gave the giants 12, 22, 53, 96, and 2019's first. Your score is: 19612 (GRADE: B) Your Picks: Round 1 Pick 2 (NYG): Rosen, Josh, QB, UCLA (A) Round 2 Pick 26 (ATL): Sutton, Courtland, WR, Southern Methodist (A-) Round 3 Pick 1: Settle, Tim, DT, Virginia Tech (B+) Round 3 Pick 26 (ATL): Hurst, Hayden, TE, South Carolina (A+) Round 4 Pick 21: Jones, Jamarco, OT, Ohio State (A+) Round 5 Pick 29: Adeniyi, Olasunkanmi, DE/OLB, Toledo (A) Round 6 Pick 16 (BALT): Coutee, Keke, WR, Texas Tech (A+) Round 6 Pick 41 (BALT): Adams, Tony, OG, North Carolina State (A+) Not great....
Domdab99 Posted April 3, 2018 Author Posted April 3, 2018 This time, I traded up to 4 to get Darnold. for 12, 22, 53, and 2019 1st. Your Picks: Round 1 Pick 4 (CLE): Darnold, Sam, QB, Southern California (A+) Round 2 Pick 24: Harrison, Ronnie, SS, Alabama (A+) Round 3 Pick 1: Cain, Deon, WR, Clemson (A-) Round 3 Pick 34 (HOU): Brown, Orlando, OT, Oklahoma (A) Round 4 Pick 14 (CLE): Freeman, Royce, RB, Oregon (A+) Round 4 Pick 21: Fatukasi, Folorunso, DT, Connecticut (A) Round 5 Pick 13 (CLE): Burks, Oren, OLB, Vanderbilt (A+) Round 5 Pick 29: Nelson, Nick, CB, Wisconsin (A+) Round 6 Pick 3 (HOU): Dickson, Michael, P, Texas (A+) Round 6 Pick 13: Dion Hamilton, Shaun, ILB, Alabama (B) Round 6 Pick 37 (HOU): Trumbetti, Andrew, DE, Notre Dame (A-) A little better...but it's goning to be really hard to get any sure-fire starters beyond the QB position this way...plus, we're giving up next year's first. I'm not sure trading up into the top 4 is worth it. Not when we'll have a great chance at Mayfield or Jackson...or, grab Rudolph or someone else later. I'd almost rather stack a roster with talent first...then go get a QB next year or 2020. Depending. It's a conundrum, I know.
ghostwriter Posted April 3, 2018 Posted April 3, 2018 Problem I have with draft-pick is they have no idea which prospects are any good value so your score is essentially meaningless...
Domdab99 Posted April 3, 2018 Author Posted April 3, 2018 (edited) Now here's what happens if we actually move down a couple of times: Your score is: 22568 (GRADE: A+) Your Picks: Round 1 Pick 22: Jackson, Lamar, QB, Louisville (B+) Round 1 Pick 28 (PITT): Evans, Rashaan, OLB/ILB, Alabama (B) Round 2 Pick 21: Goedert, Dallas, TE, South Dakota State (A) Round 2 Pick 24: Ragnow, Frank, C/OG, Arkansas (B+) Round 2 Pick 28 (PITT): Chubb, Nick, RB, Georgia (A) Round 3 Pick 1: Davis, Carlton, CB, Auburn (A+) Round 3 Pick 35 (DEN): Gallup, Michael, WR, Colorado State (A) Round 4 Pick 13 (DEN): Settle, Tim, DT, Virginia Tech (A+) Round 5 Pick 12 (DEN): Richardson, Will, OT, North Carolina State (A) Round 5 Pick 29: Igwebuike, Godwin, FS, Northwestern (A+) Round 6 Pick 8 (DEN): Dickson, Michael, P, Texas (A+) Round 6 Pick 13: McCray, Mike, OLB, Michigan (A+) Granted, it's rare to see this much moving - but look at the top of this draft: By trading down from 12 to 28 with PITT, we pick up another 2 - and get a potential placement for Shady one day. I don't think Tim Settle lasts until round 4, but Michael Gallup is one of the vastly underrated WRs in this draft - PFF has him rated as their No. 1 WR this year. And look what we pick up in the 3rd - a day 1 starter opposite Tre White in Davis Carlton. I would be thrilled with this draft - even with three fewer picks at the bottom. This draft gives us - literally - 8 potential starters. That's insane. 6 minutes ago, NewDayBills said: Problem I have with draft-pick is they have no idea which prospects are any good value so your score is essentially meaningless... Yes, draft-pick's rating are crap. But I'm not going for a good score - I'm going for potential starters and/or contributors. Edited April 3, 2018 by Domdab99
Doc Brown Posted April 3, 2018 Posted April 3, 2018 (edited) Your score is: 23406 (GRADE: A+). I'm fired in three years after Mayfield decides to pursue a career in acting after multiple concussions. Your Picks: Round 1 Pick 6 (IND): Mayfield, Baker, QB, Oklahoma (A-) Round 2 Pick 24: Washington, James, WR, Oklahoma State (B+) Round 2 Pick 28 (PITT): Andrews, Mark, TE, Oklahoma (A) Round 3 Pick 12 (G.B.): Jewell, Josey, ILB, Iowa (A-) Round 3 Pick 26 (ATL): Christian, Geron, OT, Louisville (A) Round 3 Pick 31 (N.E.): Corbett, Austin, OG, Nevada (A+) Round 3 Pick 35 (DEN): Freeman, Royce, RB, Oregon (A) Round 4 Pick 1 (G.B.): Bates III, Jessie, FS, Wake Forest (A+) Round 4 Pick 8 (NYG): Brown, Andrew, DT, Virginia (A) Round 4 Pick 28 (S.F.): Aruna, Ade, DE, Tulane (A+) Round 4 Pick 36 (N.E.): Burks, Oren, OLB, Vanderbilt (A) Round 5 Pick 6 (S.F.): Harris, Davontae, CB, Illinois State (A+) Round 5 Pick 29: Ateman, Marcell, WR, Oklahoma State (A) Round 6 Pick 8 (DEN): Bawden, Nick, FB, San Diego State (A+) Round 6 Pick 16 (BALT): Henderson, Trayvon, SS, Hawaii (A+) Round 7 Pick 24 (CAR): Atkins, John, DT, Georgia (A+) Round 7 Pick 29 (JAX): Chachere, Andre, CB, San Jose State (A+) Edited April 3, 2018 by Doc Brown
entropyrules Posted April 3, 2018 Posted April 3, 2018 Let there be no mistake - we will have a QB of the future one way or the other. 4 1
Blokestradamus Posted April 3, 2018 Posted April 3, 2018 I wanted to see how insane I could play the trade game. I just kept trading back from #12 until the CPU ran out of partners for me and forced me to pick. We got down to #68. These are the Bills 3rd round picks: Round 3 Pick 4 (HOU), Round 3 Pick 7 (DEN), Round 3 Pick 9 (MIA), Round 3 Pick 11 (OAK), Round 3 Pick 12 (G.B.), Round 3 Pick 13 (CINN), Round 3 Pick 14 (K.C.), Round 3 Pick 15 (ARI), Round 3 Pick 16 (HOU), Round 3 Pick 19 (BALT), Round 3 Pick 20 (LAC), Round 3 Pick 22 (K.C.), Round 3 Pick 23 (LAR), Round 3 Pick 25 (TENN), Round 3 Pick 26 (ATL), Round 3 Pick 27 (N.O.), Round 3 Pick 31 (N.E.), Round 3 Pick 32, Round 3 Pick 33 (ARI), Round 3 Pick 35 (DEN), Round 3 Pick 36 (CINN) You think you're a wheeler-dealer do ya, Beane? 1
wagon127 Posted April 3, 2018 Posted April 3, 2018 3 hours ago, Blokestradamus said: I wanted to see how insane I could play the trade game. I just kept trading back from #12 until the CPU ran out of partners for me and forced me to pick. We got down to #68. These are the Bills 3rd round picks: Round 3 Pick 4 (HOU), Round 3 Pick 7 (DEN), Round 3 Pick 9 (MIA), Round 3 Pick 11 (OAK), Round 3 Pick 12 (G.B.), Round 3 Pick 13 (CINN), Round 3 Pick 14 (K.C.), Round 3 Pick 15 (ARI), Round 3 Pick 16 (HOU), Round 3 Pick 19 (BALT), Round 3 Pick 20 (LAC), Round 3 Pick 22 (K.C.), Round 3 Pick 23 (LAR), Round 3 Pick 25 (TENN), Round 3 Pick 26 (ATL), Round 3 Pick 27 (N.O.), Round 3 Pick 31 (N.E.), Round 3 Pick 32, Round 3 Pick 33 (ARI), Round 3 Pick 35 (DEN), Round 3 Pick 36 (CINN) You think you're a wheeler-dealer do ya, Beane? Oh good! We will finally "fill" all those holes on the team. I think Mason Rudolph might still be available when you get to the third round in this game. lol
What a Tuel Posted April 3, 2018 Posted April 3, 2018 Super unrealistic, the Giants rejected my trade to #2
Blokestradamus Posted April 3, 2018 Posted April 3, 2018 48 minutes ago, wagon127 said: Oh good! We will finally "fill" all those holes on the team. I think Mason Rudolph might still be available when you get to the third round in this game. lol We got Lamar at 68
TOboy Posted April 3, 2018 Posted April 3, 2018 Here's my best effort yet (in terms of score - I've far preferred being able to move up and get Rosen): Your score is: 24268 (GRADE: A+) Your Picks:Round 1 Pick 12: Allen, Josh, QB, Wyoming (A)Round 2 Pick 1 (CLE): Price, Billy, C/OG, Ohio State (B+)Round 2 Pick 3 (CLE): Daniels, James, C/OG, Iowa (A+)Round 2 Pick 29 (JAX): Washington, James, WR, Oklahoma State (A-)Round 2 Pick 32 (CLE): Davis, Carlton, CB, Auburn (A+)Round 3 Pick 3 (IND): Kiser, Micah, ILB, Virginia (A)Round 3 Pick 32: Settle, Tim, DT, Virginia Tech (A+)Round 4 Pick 4 (IND): Warner, Fred, OLB, Brigham Young (A)Round 4 Pick 6 (DEN): Brown, Orlando, OT, Oklahoma (A+)Round 4 Pick 8 (NYG): Freeman, Royce, RB, Oregon (A+)Round 4 Pick 21: Sweat, Josh, OLB, Florida State (A)Round 5 Pick 12 (DEN): Cruikshank, Dane, SS, Arizona (A+)Round 5 Pick 29: Haley, Grant, CB, Penn State (A)Round 6 Pick 8 (DEN): Thomas, Jordan, TE, Mississippi State (A+)Round 6 Pick 13: Ateman, Marcell, WR, Oklahoma State (A+)Your Future Picks: 2019 Round 1 Pick2020 Round 1 Pick Well that format didn't work too well!
MAJBobby Posted April 3, 2018 Posted April 3, 2018 3 minutes ago, TOboy said: Here's my best effort yet (in terms of score - I've far preferred being able to move up and get Rosen): Your score is: 24268 (GRADE: A+) Your Picks:Round 1 Pick 12: Allen, Josh, QB, Wyoming (A)Round 2 Pick 1 (CLE): Price, Billy, C/OG, Ohio State (B+)Round 2 Pick 3 (CLE): Daniels, James, C/OG, Iowa (A+)Round 2 Pick 29 (JAX): Washington, James, WR, Oklahoma State (A-)Round 2 Pick 32 (CLE): Davis, Carlton, CB, Auburn (A+)Round 3 Pick 3 (IND): Kiser, Micah, ILB, Virginia (A)Round 3 Pick 32: Settle, Tim, DT, Virginia Tech (A+)Round 4 Pick 4 (IND): Warner, Fred, OLB, Brigham Young (A)Round 4 Pick 6 (DEN): Brown, Orlando, OT, Oklahoma (A+)Round 4 Pick 8 (NYG): Freeman, Royce, RB, Oregon (A+)Round 4 Pick 21: Sweat, Josh, OLB, Florida State (A)Round 5 Pick 12 (DEN): Cruikshank, Dane, SS, Arizona (A+)Round 5 Pick 29: Haley, Grant, CB, Penn State (A)Round 6 Pick 8 (DEN): Thomas, Jordan, TE, Mississippi State (A+)Round 6 Pick 13: Ateman, Marcell, WR, Oklahoma State (A+)Your Future Picks: 2019 Round 1 Pick2020 Round 1 Pick Well that format didn't work too well! Gotta switch to test only not HTML 1
whatdrought Posted April 3, 2018 Posted April 3, 2018 Your score is: 19045 (GRADE: Your Picks: Round 1 Pick 14 (G.B.): Mayfield, Baker, QB, Oklahoma (A) Round 2 Pick 8 (DEN): Michel, Sony, RB, Georgia (B) Round 2 Pick 13 (G.B.): Jewell, Josey, ILB, Iowa (B-) Round 2 Pick 21: Leonard, Darius, OLB/ILB, South Carolina State (C-) Round 2 Pick 24: Settle, Tim, DT, Virginia Tech (B) Round 2 Pick 29 (JAX): Sutton, Courtland, WR, Southern Methodist (A) Round 2 Pick 32 (CLE): Miller, Kolton, OT, UCLA (B+) Round 3 Pick 1: Ragnow, Frank, C/OG, Arkansas (A-) Round 3 Pick 7 (DEN): Oliver, Isaiah, CB, Colorado (A+) Round 3 Pick 32: Hamilton, DaeSean, WR, Penn State (A-) Round 4 Pick 21: Frazier, Marcell, DE, Missouri (C) Round 5 Pick 29: Mataafa, Hercules, OLB, Washington State (A-) Round 6 Pick 13: Malone, KJ, OG, LSU (B+) The trades are obviously unrealistic, I thought I took most of those players at good places... I think the rankings they use are a little screwy. 6 hours ago, entropyrules said: Let there be no mistake - we will have a QB of the future one way or the other. A+ from me. As far as the depth chart goes, I say we do a cage fight tournament to whittle the group down to 6 (including AJ and Nate) and then have an open competition.
Rock-A-Bye Beasley Posted April 3, 2018 Posted April 3, 2018 First try a+ Kept trading down because Mayfield and Allen were both available. Would much rather have Mayfiled but Arizona took him. Got Allen at 26. Your score is: 24158 (GRADE: A+) Your Picks:Round 1 Pick 26 (ATL): Allen, Josh, QB, Wyoming (A+)Round 1 Pick 28 (PITT): Evans, Rashaan, OLB/ILB, Alabama (B)Round 2 Pick 4 (IND): Chark, DJ, WR, LSU (B)Round 2 Pick 5 (IND): Crosby, Tyrell, OT, Oregon (A-)Round 2 Pick 15 (ARI): Hernandez, Will, OG, Texas-El Paso (A)Round 2 Pick 18 (DAL): Griffin, Shaquem, OLB, Central Florida (B+)Round 2 Pick 21: Harrison, Ronnie, SS, Alabama (A)Round 3 Pick 26 (ATL): Thompson, Trenton, DT, Georgia (A+)Round 3 Pick 32: Fitts, Kylie, DE/OLB, Utah (A)Round 4 Pick 21: Toliver II, Kevin, CB, LSU (A+)Round 4 Pick 36 (N.E.): Allen, Brian, C, Michigan State (C)Round 5 Pick 29: Scarbrough, Bo, RB, Alabama (A+)Round 6 Pick 13: Bawden, Nick, FB, San Diego State (A+)Round 6 Pick 31 (N.E.): Jackson, Justin, RB, Northwestern (A+)Round 6 Pick 36 (N.E.): Ateman, Marcell, WR, Oklahoma State (A+)
ndirish1978 Posted April 3, 2018 Posted April 3, 2018 (edited) I'm pretty happy with this one Edited April 3, 2018 by ndirish1978 1
Mr Wild Posted April 4, 2018 Posted April 4, 2018 1 trade back Green bay gets 12 Buffalo gets 14, 3rd and 4th Your score is: 22645 (GRADE: A+) Your Picks: Round 1 Pick 14 (G.B.): Allen, Josh, QB, Wyoming (A+) Round 1 Pick 22: Vea, Vita, DT, Washington (A+) Round 2 Pick 21: Jefferson, Malik, ILB, Texas (A) Round 2 Pick 24: Crosby, Tyrell, OT, Oregon (A) Round 3 Pick 1: St Brown, Equanimeous, WR, Notre Dame (A) Round 3 Pick 12 (G.B.): Turay, Kemoko, OLB, Rutgers (A) Round 3 Pick 32: Armstrong Jr, Dorance, DE/OLB, Kansas (A+) Round 4 Pick 21: Freeman, Royce, RB, Oregon (A+) Round 4 Pick 33 (G.B.): Igwebuike, Godwin, FS, Northwestern (A) Round 5 Pick 29: Blanding, Quin, FS, Virginia (A) Round 6 Pick 13: J Hall, P, DT, Sam Houston State (A+)
4thandGoal Posted April 4, 2018 Posted April 4, 2018 Your score is: 22579 (GRADE: A+) Your Picks: Round 1 Pick 22: Mayfield, Baker, QB, Oklahoma (A+) Round 1 Pick 24 (CAR): Vander Esch, Leighton, OLB/ILB, Boise State (A-) Round 2 Pick 18 (DAL): Price, Billy, C/OG, Ohio State (A) Round 2 Pick 21: Goedert, Dallas, TE, South Dakota State (A) Round 2 Pick 23 (CAR): Washington, James, WR, Oklahoma State (B+) Round 2 Pick 24: Rankin, Martinas, OT, Mississippi State (A) Round 3 Pick 1: Nnadi, Derrick, DT, Florida State (A-) Round 3 Pick 17 (DAL): Penny, Rashaad, RB, San Diego State (A) Round 3 Pick 32: Settle, Tim, DT, Virginia Tech (A) Round 4 Pick 21: Griffin, Shaquem, OLB, Central Florida (A) Round 5 Pick 29: Phillips, Darius, CB, Western Michigan (A) Round 6 Pick 13: Ateman, Marcell, WR, Oklahoma State (A+) Defensive front 7 is all set now-- OLine is all set and Mayfield has targets to throw too
Domdab99 Posted April 6, 2018 Author Posted April 6, 2018 For this one, I traded our first 4 picks to the Giants: Your Picks: Round 1 Pick 2 (NYG): Rosen, Josh, QB, UCLA (A) Round 3 Pick 1: Sutton, Courtland, WR, Southern Methodist (A) Round 4 Pick 1 (G.B.): Cole, Mason, C/OT, Michigan (A) Round 4 Pick 21: Fatukasi, Folorunso, DT, Connecticut (A) Round 4 Pick 33 (G.B.): Avery, Genard, ILB, Memphis (A) Round 5 Pick 29: Adeniyi, Olasunkanmi, DE/OLB, Toledo (A) Round 6 Pick 13: Jackson, Justin, RB, Northwestern (A+)
Elite Poster Posted April 6, 2018 Posted April 6, 2018 Not a big fan of the ones with 500 trade backs but that is how you score well on this site. Not really realistic. I wish it actually penalized you for losing valuable selection spots. 3 seconds is not always better than 2 firsts.
Recommended Posts