With all QBs in play...who do you pick?

[Rubes]

With all of the ammunition we have, there is the real possibility that the Bills could move up in the draft high enough to take just about any QB available. Not saying they will, but the possibility exists.

Let's say they do move up. In the hypothetical situation where Cleveland takes Barkley at #1 and the Bills trade with the NYG to move up to #2, all QBs are on the table. If you're Beane, who do you pick?

 

(This is not a poll to say you would stay put at #21 and #22, this is just assuming we move up to pick a QB.)

 

 

 

 

[bigduke6]

Edited March 10, 2018 by bigduke6

[Foxx]

it is probably a foregone conclusion that Cleveland takes Barkley at this point. that just increased the Giants position, by a lot.

[billspro]

If we're going to do it, Sam Darnold is the QB I trust the most in this class.

[MAJBobby]

I took Rosen in this poll, like I have wanted since October 

 

but Darnold is good too

Edited March 10, 2018 by MAJBobby

[Woodman19]

Rosen, looks like the safest QB ATM although the attitude stigma doesn't help.

[H2o]

Mayfield is my guy, but I'm good with Mayfield or Rosen. I still think we could go the Foles route for reasons previously stated, but I would rather have the rookie. 

[dave mcbride]

Darnold is the obvious choice for me. But i realize opinions differ. Despite the noise we're hearing now, this is a freaking great qb class.

[Rubes]

I know, it's a tough choice. I've been thinking for so long that there is no chance of getting one of the top 2-3 QBs that I haven't really been thinking of guys like Darnold...

[Rubes]

Interesting...I like Rosen, just didn't expect that many people to pick him over the others if all QBs were available.

[Zebrastripes]

I like Mayfield the most but if we grab Rosen instead I wouldn't complain.

[BuffaloBillyG]

I picked Rosen. I just think he is going to be the best to come out of this draft.

 

I like Mayfield as well. If we stay at 21 and he's there I'd be good with Jackson at that spot as well. 

[Lurker]

37 minutes ago, Rubes said:

Interesting...I like Rosen, just didn't expect that many people to pick him over the others if all QBs were available.

 

I'm a Rosen fan (which worries me since I'm wrong more often than not in my old age) 

 

But IMO, he's head and shoulders above the rest as a pure passer (I see so much of Brady in him). My worries stem from his intangible leadership/fire in the belly traits.   I just wonder if his personality has enough steel in it to be a franchise-type lay-it-on-the-line kind of player in the NFL.   If those questions could be answered, he'd be the answer, IMO...

[Leftyman]

My first pick is Mayfield but worry that he's coming out of the spread offense. 

Rosen is a good pick also but you have to worry about the attitude. 

 

[White Linen]

Rosen in this scenario

Edited March 10, 2018 by White Linen

[Rubes]

14 minutes ago, Leftyman said:

My first pick is Mayfield but worry that he's coming out of the spread offense. 

Rosen is a good pick also but you have to worry about the attitude. 

 

 

Fascinating...I'm not sure why I'm that surprised, but I would not have figured so many to believe Mayfield or Rosen should be the first QB picked in the draft.

 

[DJB]

Darnold. There is a reason Daniel  Jeremiah  has called him the best QB from the last 3 draft classes

[Solomon Grundy]

I chose Jackson. I still believe that he will be the best QB in this draft in the long run (no pun intended). The athleticism, the ability to read defenses, and the arm strength is what entices me. He's not an "inaccurate" QB, he's an "inconsistent" QB and that can be fixed. Aaron Rodgers fell in the draft because of his "inconsistency". Green Bay solved Rodgers problem. I believe Jackson's can be corrected too.

[JaCrispy]

Mayfield is my first choice, Darnold is my second choice...I am seriously worried about Rosen’s injury history...I believe he has never played a full season in college in three years...and combining his intelligence with his family’s money, I could see him bolting from the NFL for greener pastures if he has a third concussion...remember his first two were within a month of each other to end the season, and it has been said once you get one, it becomes easier to get more.

 

Everyone talks about Rosen’s personality as a potential reason not to draft him...that is actually the least of my worries with him...As good as he is I just don’t think he has the toughness and durability to withstand a full NFL season like Mayfield and Darnold.

Edited March 10, 2018 by JaCrispy

[Chosenone]

I really like this draft class of QB's especially the TOP 4 Darnold, Rosen, J.Allen and Mayfield. I think Darnold will be the best of the bunch though.