Jump to content

Which QB starts in Week 11?  

144 members have voted

  1. 1. Which QB starts in Week 11?

    • Nate Peterman
      43
    • Tyrod Taylor
      101


Recommended Posts

Posted
6 minutes ago, GG said:

 

Well look who's getting sloppy now.  Tell me, how many games did Roethlisberger apprentice under those guys?

 

And the analogy isn't quite valid, because the Steelers are a model franchise of stability, which could get away with mediocre QB play.

 

Why aren't you throwing out the example of the Colts with and without Peyton?  

 

Bills are not a model franchise at this moment, and if anything, McDermott is trying to build that foundation that others tried, but never succeeded because they never hit on the QB and ran out of owners' patience.

 

The last guy who tried to do this kind of rebuild was Donahoe, and he'd still be here if he hit on the trade to get Ben.

 

Winning 9 games this year with Tyrod and clinching the last playoff spot is immaterial from a long term perspective, because there would still be a gaping hole at QB.  Bills can easily sign a Josh McCown or Brian Hoyer for one season while they wait for the rookie to ease into the league.  Hell, Fitz will be available again

 

 

Give it up GG........the Bills roster was decimated by the new regime this past offseason........it's not a good place to start a rookie pocket passer now.

 

Deshaun Watson in an offense catered to his skills?   Maybe......but that's not what they wanted.

 

But there is never a better time to DRAFT one than the present.  

 

 

 

 

Posted
18 minutes ago, Boyst62 said:

Inside source... Take it for what it's worth. Passed to me 3rd hand by someone I trust infinitly

 

Taylors benching was 100% Dennison.   This was per Taylor from a conversation bhe had with confidant in messages exchanged today at halftime.

 

I'd you don't believe me that is fine. But I believe my source. 

I believe in you Boyst62:thumbsup: 

Posted
17 minutes ago, Boyst62 said:

Inside source... Take it for what it's worth. Passed to me 3rd hand by someone I trust infinitly

 

Taylors benching was 100% Dennison.   This was per Taylor from a conversation bhe had with confidant in messages exchanged today at halftime.

 

I'd you don't believe me that is fine. But I believe my source. 

Can you blame Dennison after watching that full body vomit all over the field that was TTs play last week? Funny how suddenly getting benched gave him a little impetus to actually push the ball down the field, albeit in Garbage time

Posted

https://www.buffalorumblings.com/2017/11/19/16677300/richard-sherman-goes-after-buffalo-bills-on-twitter-for-bench-tyrod-taylor-nathan-peterman

Just now, Buffalo Boy said:

Can you blame Dennison after watching that full body vomit all over the field that was TTs play last week? Funny how suddenly getting benched gave him a little impetus to actually push the ball down the field, albeit in Garbage time

Yet he played well in the five wins.

Posted

So....

 

Wide receivers suck

defense sucks

offensive line sucks

taylor sucks

....and now Peterman sucks

 

this team is just so bad.  Why do I keep having any optimism at all. They are who they are, the Buffalo Sevenandnines

 

 

 

Posted
3 minutes ago, Buffalo Boy said:

Can you blame Dennison after watching that full body vomit all over the field that was TTs play last week? Funny how suddenly getting benched gave him a little impetus to actually push the ball down the field, albeit in Garbage time

 

 

Taylor wants to throw the ball deep but the horses aren't there.

 

Did you see the separation our high second round choice Zay Jones got on his nine route today..........against a random backup CB........NONE. 

 

They've mishandled the personnel.

Posted
Just now, JM2009 said:

Dennison is the one that should go. The crusade is over.

While not a Dennison fan, I can appreciate his pain watching a Dimestore M. Vick try to run his offense.

Posted
Just now, JM2009 said:
 
McDermott’s move to start Peterman blew up in his face, and there’s no way he can defend it. The kid was clearly not ready for the moment, and after the third interception, McDermott should have pulled him. Instead, he stuck with him for two more picks and by then the game was unwinnable. When it was 24-7, you never know what could happen, though I think we probably do know the answer. On defense, coordinator Leslie Frazier has big problems, and he has now joined a long list of defensive coordinators who have no answers for this team. His defense is one of the worst in the NFL.
You
Your Vote
Avg
F
Sal
F

 

Posted
1 minute ago, BADOLBILZ said:

 

 

Taylor wants to throw the ball deep but the horses aren't there.

 

Did you see the separation our high second round choice Zay Jones got on his nine route today..........against a random backup CB........NONE. 

 

They've mishandled the personnel.

Shouldn't have traded Watkins... the offense could work with Taylor if Watkins was here. Of course, Dennsion might have screwed that up too 

Posted
2 minutes ago, BADOLBILZ said:

 

 

Taylor wants to throw the ball deep but the horses aren't there.

 

Did you see the separation our high second round choice Zay Jones got on his nine route today..........against a random backup CB........NONE. 

 

They've mishandled the personnel.

Jones was never going to be a deep threat.

Posted
Just now, Buffalo Boy said:

While not a Dennison fan, I can appreciate his pain watching a Dimestore M. Vick try to run his offense.

Why not run an offense that suits the QB strengths? 

Posted (edited)

People should start realizing that only a dozen or so people on earth can play that position well consistently. And all Peterman ever showed since he was drafted, was an ability to make a quick decision and make a nice accurate short throw. That's it. People saw that one thing and somehow extrapolated that he can do the other 23 things that an NFL QB has to be able to do. He didn't handle the rush well in preseason. He just didn't. He threw one TD in four appearances. He didn't get the ball downfield. He made quick decisions and threw a nice accurate 10 yard pass. When that is all you do, defenses jump routes. 

Edited by Kelly the Dog
Posted
1 minute ago, Buffalo Boy said:

Jones was never going to be a deep threat.

I've said it in other threads ......... Thompson should be starting if Taylor is the QB.  He gets production and he gets separation.  Makes everything work.

  • Like (+1) 1
Posted (edited)
4 minutes ago, JM2009 said:

Why not run an offense that suits the QB strengths? 

 

 Dennsion is a limited offensive mind, not an innovator in any way. That's not an ideal choice for an OC , and spelled trouble from the time he was hired. Most NFL assistant coaches aren't . The team needed a McVay with Taylor more than a McDermott 

Edited by Boatdrinks
Posted
Just now, JM2009 said:

Why not run an offense that suits the QB strengths? 

I don’t think it was Dennison’s decision to trade Sammy or gut the roster.  This receiving Corp is capable of playing a short game.

Is asking your QB to throw with timing, Place balls in the field of play and anticipate routes too much for any OC to ask?

 

×
×
  • Create New...