TC in St. Louis Posted September 17, 2017 Posted September 17, 2017 The offensive pass interference call on our guy that cost us a first down inside the 20.....in my opinion, that was not pass interference. The ball wasn't even in the air when those two guys banged into each other. They collided, the db fell on his butt, and a couple seconds later Tyrod escaped the pocket and threw the ball to #18. First down. Is it pass interference if the ball hasn't been thrown? If not, is it illegal contact if our guy knocks their guy on his butt....which was beyond the legal 5 yards to make contact....is our guy not allowed to jostle the defender if they engage? I think it was a bad call. Did it cost us the game? We'll never know. Jones could have made the catch, but it would have been an amazing catch.
Numark3 Posted September 17, 2017 Posted September 17, 2017 I'm not a penalty expert, but I don't think PI was the right call since the ball wasn't thrown yet. But it sure looked like it should be some other type of penalty imo
Koko78 Posted September 17, 2017 Posted September 17, 2017 Looked to me like the DB wasn't allowing the receiver to run his route and got run into. I will give the DB props for the fantastic dive though, cause he wasn't pushed.
TC in St. Louis Posted September 17, 2017 Author Posted September 17, 2017 I just googled Offensive Pass Interference, and this is what the rule says: Offensive pass interference rules apply from the time the ball is snapped until the ball is touched. See Article 2 for prohibited acts while the ball is in the air and Article 4 for prohibited acts prior to the pass. So, if our guy knocked their guy over, it's a good call. It it was mutual contact, it is not.
Jukester Posted September 17, 2017 Posted September 17, 2017 Yes be shoved the defender and extended his arms in the process to do it. That was a clear offensive PI.
bobobonators Posted September 17, 2017 Posted September 17, 2017 You cant extend your arms as a WR to gain separation. Holmes did that a little bit. But it was more dramatic bc the defender fell. Had he not fallen perhaps no call.
Buffalo716 Posted September 17, 2017 Posted September 17, 2017 Yes it was pass interference Unfortunately
Kelly the Dog Posted September 17, 2017 Posted September 17, 2017 From where the ref was positioned who made the call it sure looked like it. I don't think it should have been called. The db cut off Holmes route. That's not his fault. The ref saw the arms and the db fall back. So he called it. But at that point of the game it was weak. The non facemask call was just as bad IMO
MAJBobby Posted September 17, 2017 Posted September 17, 2017 Clear pushoff or comonly called Offensive Pass Interference
Rochesterfan Posted September 17, 2017 Posted September 17, 2017 You cant extend your arms as a WR to gain separation. Holmes did that a little bit. But it was more dramatic bc the defender fell. Had he not fallen perhaps no call. Agree it was close but when the DB goes down it gets called
Johnny Hammersticks Posted September 17, 2017 Posted September 17, 2017 Eh, it was the right call given the contact and the amazing acting job by the DB.
Jasovon Posted September 17, 2017 Posted September 17, 2017 it was PI, however it is how "Physical" Receivers like Brown, Jones, Bryant etc. get seperattion and they are allowed to do it because they are superstars. It's difficult for new Bills to learn how the rules apply to us and not other teams. The refs did not cost us todays game but same old same old we can't expect any breaks.
Blokestradamus Posted September 17, 2017 Posted September 17, 2017 It was OPI by the rule of law but I wish it was called more frequently/fairly. Easier to stomach if the rule applies evenly to Gronk.
WhoTom Posted September 17, 2017 Posted September 17, 2017 Looked to me like the DB wasn't allowing the receiver to run his route and got run into. I will give the DB props for the fantastic dive though, cause he wasn't pushed. Bingo. He was touched slightly, but that was one superb acting job, not offensive PI.
JerseyBills Posted September 17, 2017 Posted September 17, 2017 Thought they blew that.. They definitely blew likely a game changing facemask on Shady on the final drive and the Holmes play never happens but oh well
BillnutinHouston Posted September 17, 2017 Posted September 17, 2017 Clear pushoff or comonly called Offensive Pass Interference No, very weak call. Holmes'arms weren't even fully extended into push position. When a DB cuts off your route it's not an offensive penalty.
T-Bomb Posted September 17, 2017 Posted September 17, 2017 The receiver extended his arms when he broke the route, the defender friggin fell down, ofc it was PI.
Big Turk Posted September 17, 2017 Posted September 17, 2017 The offensive pass interference call on our guy that cost us a first down inside the 20.....in my opinion, that was not pass interference. The ball wasn't even in the air when those two guys banged into each other. They collided, the db fell on his butt, and a couple seconds later Tyrod escaped the pocket and threw the ball to #18. First down. Is it pass interference if the ball hasn't been thrown? If not, is it illegal contact if our guy knocks their guy on his butt....which was beyond the legal 5 yards to make contact....is our guy not allowed to jostle the defender if they engage? I think it was a bad call. Did it cost us the game? We'll never know. Jones could have made the catch, but it would have been an amazing catch. Ehh...it's Andre Holmes....if it's Antonio Brown or Grnok, nothing gets called. Gronk pushed off Bradham so badly once that Bradham went 5 yards back and he caught the ball and nothing was called...Bills always get the non-benefit of the doubt on calls...gotta earn them and we haven't
T-Bomb Posted September 17, 2017 Posted September 17, 2017 Ehh...it's Andre Holmes....if it's Antonio Brown or Grnok, nothing gets called. Gronk pushed off Bradham so badly once that Bradham went 5 yards back and he caught the ball and nothing was called...Bills always get the non-benefit of the doubt on calls...gotta earn them and we haven't A lot of other teams/players get those calls too... It's not the world against the Buffalo Bills you know...
Recommended Posts