Josh Rosen, not worth a 2018 1st rounder.

[gr8billsfan]

Josh Rosen, QB of UCLA, has been a top prospect for a QB pick in he 2018 draft by many analysts. He's had some great games last year. Many Bills fans have urged us to go grab him, ONLY if he enters the draft next year. Tonight I'm watching him face Texas A&M and he looks horrible so far. Under thrown passes, miss timed throws and weak throws.

 

My question is, even after this one game, can we afford to draft a guy who may enter the draft next year if he's a downgrade of Peterman? I know one game doesn't count, but his performance is sub-par so far. Do we go get Darnold? Or another top tier QB?

 

Hate away...

[Kirby Jackson]

2 quarters is a really small portion of his resume.

[gr8billsfan]

He played last year, had good games and terrible games. More of a lottery pick than anything. You want to spend 1-2 first round picks on a guy who can't complete half his throws?

[Buffalo Barbarian]

Here we go, bust!

[John from Riverside]

i guess we will just have to wait till next year

 

 

(No we shouldnt)

[buffaloboyinATL]

We Bills fans are jinxing all of the first round QB's by cheering for them to do well.

[H2o]

It's early. Mayfield was a beast yesterday. I think Rudolph looked good too. Darnold and Allen are still the #1 & #2 QB's.

[Kirby Jackson]

He played last year, had good games and terrible games. More of a lottery pick than anything. You want to spend 1-2 first round picks on a guy who can't complete half his throws?

He's been a star his whole life. He will be a good pro.

[Captain Murica]

Don't worry we'll end up taking either Falk or Rudolph 😉

[Bangarang]

Say it with me, Luke Falk

[gr8billsfan]

He's been a star his whole life. He will be a good pro.

So was losman, beside the pro part.

Edited September 4, 2017 by gr8billsfan

[Bubba Gump]

Just chucked a nice 54 yarder

[Rico]

I just turned it on, at least he looks like a prototypical QB, unlike the dork from Wyoming.

 

31-3, now 31-10, let's see if he can bring them back.

[gr8billsfan]

I'm glad other people are rooting for some other QBs. I guess I have to watch more of their play.

 

New question, do we go for the "best" QB or go for the second best. Similar to the dilemma between Wentz & Goff.

Just chucked a nice 54 yarder

Yeah with a safety with his back turned. No doubt. Nice completion and throw. But would this translate to the NFL?

I just turned it on, at least he looks like a prototypical QB, unlike the dork from Wyoming.

 

31-3, now 31-10, let's see if he can bring them back.

Not with that run for a TD 38-10. Good game. Edited September 4, 2017 by gr8billsfan

[Kelly the Dog]

I'm glad other people are rooting for some other QBs. I guess I have to watch more of their play.

 

New question, do we go for the "best" QB or go for the second best. Similar to the dilemma between Wentz & Goff.

 

Yeah with a safety with his back turned. No doubt. Nice completion and throw. But would this translate to the NFL?

The drop back, set up, motion, velocity, length and accuracy? Inarguably.

[gr8billsfan]

The drop back, set up, motion, velocity, length and accuracy? Inarguably.

1 good throw is worth a first round pick?

[Rico]

I'm glad other people are rooting for some other QBs. I guess I have to watch more of their play.

 

New question, do we go for the "best" QB or go for the second best. Similar to the dilemma between Wentz & Goff.

 

Yeah with a safety with his back turned. No doubt. Nice completion and throw. But would this translate to the NFL?

 

Not with that return for a TD 38-10. Good game.

If he's good, he'll at least get them close. Home game, too.

[ALF]

So far I would not trade up for him . The season is young , and college QBs are very hard to judge how they will do in NFL.

 

I'm shocked how good Peterman looks so far for a 5th rd pick. I hate the spread offense in college , no way to judge NFL potential.

[Buffalo Barbarian]

i guess we will just have to wait till next year

 

 

(No we shouldnt)

For sure, 2019 baby!

[Kelly the Dog]

1 good throw is worth a first round pick?

He's already a guaranteed first round pick. You asked if that one pass would translate to NFL. An NFL scout watching that one pass would jerk off to it later in his hotel room because of six different reasons.