The Tyrod Taylor Question

[Noogie75]

The fact that you think I'm even making excuses for Tyrod shows just how little you're paying attention.

a month ago someone made a comparison with Rivers and Brees. Because they also didn't make the playoffs like TT. They gave the excuse that TT did not have the weapons. That's what I was referring to.

[Foxx]

 

This is just silly. Tyrod and the offense were at least viable and much more effective the last two seasons than the Rex Ryan defense. Woods left to get paid and go back home to LA. Your post is all fabrication that is completely divorced from reality.

is this trying to equate the lessor of two evils and say that evil one was less evil than evil 2?

Edited August 20, 2017 by Foxx

[Noogie75]

Can someone answer my question???

[26CornerBlitz]

is this trying to equate the lessor of two evils and say that evil one was less evil than evil 2?

 

You tell me.

[BillsFan4]

Most of TT supporters make up to many excuses. All the time. There is always one or many. I defend CJ. But I agree that he is not ready. I have no problems with it. But speak about TT unexcusable poor play and everyone jumps. I don't agree of trading him to keep Yates who can not even get close it CJ's intangibles. Now Petterman is not bad but people put him over CJ based on a Clemson win. When he was at Tenn.and had to transfer to a weaker division where he looked decent. Thats when I counter about CJ in college. Yes, he was benched after a national championship and winning every single of the 11 games he started. I'll give you that. Now supposely the guys in front of him were better. I'll give you that too. But my big question is ( please answer) why could they not win without him giving that they had the same best products when he WON the previous year? Now answer me someone because I wanna know.Aaaah he was in Baltimore 4 years where in a few or one of those years Kubiak was his offensive coach. and you're running out of excuses.

He had 1 year with Kubiak in Baltimore. That is much different than saying he's had 4 years in that offense.

 

As for why people say Peterman looks better than CJ, just watch them play. It's very easy to see why people say that. Peterman looks like a legit QB. Cardale does not.

 

And you keep bringing up CJ's 3 game run to a championship like it's super meaningful. It's not. It's was much more the team around CJ that won the championship than it was CJ. They may not have even got to that championship game with CJ starting the whole year. Football is a team sport. Cardale was a very small part of that championship win.

 

You continually asking why Ohio St didn't win a championship the following year... but every year is different. That's like asking why doesn't the same team win a championship every year?

 

Ohio State just ran into a super hot Clemson team and lost. Clemson had a phenomenal year.

 

The fact is Cardale stunk that year and was benched. He was given every opportunity to hang on to that starting job and he just couldn't do it. Go back and watch that season. You will see why they had no choice but to bench him.

 

 

Here's a question for you - how many championship winning college QBs have gone on to have great NFL careers?

 

Here's a list - http://www.thegridfe.com/2015/05/21/national-championship-quarterbacks-in-the-nfl/

 

As you can see, winning a college championship as a QB is meaningless in the NFL.

 

 

To be clear, I am not trying to argue that Tyrod is the Bills future at QB. I think that is a long shot. As of now he is a mediocre NFL starting QB. But he is light years ahead of Cardale. I'd also take Peterman any day over Cardale as well. And that's what it came down to - Cardale or Peterman. It's too hard to develop 1 QB in the NFL, let alone 2 at the same time. There's simply not enough reps to go around, especially with the way the CBA limited practice time.

[SlimShady'sSpaceForce]

I think he's talking about the one that Darby almost jumped the out route to Boldin. It wasn't picked but it was close.

That's the one Thanks transplant.

[Noogie75]

He had 1 year with Kubiak in Baltimore. That is much different than saying he's had 4 years in that offense.

 

As for why people say Peterman looks better than CJ, just watch them play. It's very easy to see why people say that. Peterman looks like a legit QB. Cardale does not.

 

And you keep bringing up CJ's 3 game run to a championship like it's super meaningful. It's not. It's was much more the team around CJ that won the championship than it was CJ. They may not have even got to that championship game with CJ starting the whole year. Football is a team sport. Cardale was a very small part of that championship win.

 

You continually asking why Ohio St didn't win a championship the following year... but every year is different. That's like asking why doesn't the same team win a championship every year?

 

Ohio State just ran into a super hot Clemson team and lost. Clemson had a phenomenal year.

 

The fact is Cardale stunk that year and was benched. He was given every opportunity to hang on to that starting job and he just couldn't do it. Go back and watch that season. You will see why they had no choice but to bench him.

 

 

Here's a question for you - how many championship winning college QBs have gone on to have great NFL careers?

 

Here's a list - http://www.thegridfe.com/2015/05/21/national-championship-quarterbacks-in-the-nfl/

 

As you can see, winning a college championship as a QB is meaningless in the NFL.

 

 

To be clear, I am not trying to argue that Tyrod is the Bills future at QB. I think that is a long shot. As of now he is a mediocre NFL starting QB. But he is light years ahead of Cardale. I'd also take Peterman any day over Cardale as well. And that's what it came down to - Cardale or Peterman. It's too hard to develop 1 QB in the NFL, let alone 2 at the same time. There's simply not enough reps to go around, especially with the way the CBA limited practice time.

I can see how bias you are? So 6'5 with rocket arm vs 6'2 weak arm the next so called Tom Brady. How many late round HOF Qbs. I'll help Tom Brady,Warner(free agent). But CJ again he had not lost but he sits and they loose to Michigan State. Wow good. Now a days is happening more with QBs we can say the same at tight ends what's your point. Well then again Pitt beat Clemson and Barrett couldn't with a better team than Pitt??? Ok you just can't hang. I'mma give you TT like you said, what has he done for me lately, are already digesting bricks because for a so called best option he is and has been playing bubu. It really ugly and it's gonna be uglier when the season starts. And if by chance Petterman ever gets on the field he better do good. For now here comes my "I Told You". Only bias people speak like you speak about CJ. It only gets you so far. Right now TT is making you look bad. CJ. is not making me look bad because he is a sophomore... Next year I guarantee CJ will be in a better spot TT will be watching from the sidelines. He might not even make it through the year.

Billsfan4 where are you from??? What state?

Edited August 20, 2017 by Noogie75

[Crusher]

Taylor's 2 best career games were against playoff teams.... sooo, there's that.

Miami was one of the poorest defensive team's last season. A schedule as weak as it comes, too.

 

Seattle had maybe it's two biggest impact guys on D out, also.

Edited August 20, 2017 by Crusher

[Noogie75]

J

[Noogie75]

Well if you don't wanna answer Fan 4 it's ok. I'm from the state of Florida. Where I grew up watching NFL legends once again legends. I'm not just talking about the college program success. Like Micheal Irvin said the best football players ever were breaded in the state of Florida. You name them. So we in this state know more about evaluating talent than any other state. I'll put that in everything I own. Other coaches or programs throughout the country could not match our evaluation of talent. We do not give away positions they earn them. Everyone gets a fair evaluation. They don't ticky tack about he seems better. They earn it and every year is up for grabs. Like belicheck, doesn't care who got picked in what round he will bench a first rounder if he is not better than the man in front. You keep the better player not who might be. That is the difference of winning constantly not guessing, fan favorite or the ban wagon like it is in Buffalo because of people that think like you. By the way Antonio Gates a first Ballot HOF is praising CJ. Anthony Lynn a Superbowl Champ sees the talent CJ has. A great coach who coached with Bill Parcels is saying it. But you say he is sorry. I believe you. You win. Just don't let me down on what your writings have read. I'll be waaatching.

[Big Gun]

Well if you don't wanna answer Fan 4 it's ok. I'm from the state of Florida. Where I grew up watching NFL legends once again legends. I'm not just talking about the college program success. Like Micheal Irvin said the best football players ever were breaded in the state of Florida. You name them. So we in this state know more about evaluating talent than any other state. I'll put that in everything I own. Other coaches or programs throughout the country could not match our evaluation of talent. We do not give away positions they earn them. Everyone gets a fair evaluation. They don't ticky tack about he seems better. They earn it and every year is up for grabs. Like belicheck, doesn't care who got picked in what round he will bench a first rounder if he is not better than the man in front. You keep the better player not who might be. That is the difference of winning constantly not guessing, fan favorite or the ban wagon like it is in Buffalo because of people that think like you. By the way Antonio Gates a first Ballot HOF is praising CJ. Anthony Lynn a Superbowl Champ sees the talent CJ has. A great coach who coached with Bill Parcels is saying it. But you say he is sorry. I believe you. You win. Just don't let me down on what your writings have read. I'll be waaatching.

 

This is interesting

 

https://howtheyplay.com/team-sports/US-States-With-Most-NFL-Hall-of-Famers

Edited August 21, 2017 by old school

[Buffalo716]

Well if you don't wanna answer Fan 4 it's ok. I'm from the state of Florida. Where I grew up watching NFL legends once again legends. I'm not just talking about the college program success. Like Micheal Irvin said the best football players ever were breaded in the state of Florida. You name them. So we in this state know more about evaluating talent than any other state. I'll put that in everything I own. Other coaches or programs throughout the country could not match our evaluation of talent. We do not give away positions they earn them. Everyone gets a fair evaluation. They don't ticky tack about he seems better. They earn it and every year is up for grabs. Like belicheck, doesn't care who got picked in what round he will bench a first rounder if he is not better than the man in front. You keep the better player not who might be. That is the difference of winning constantly not guessing, fan favorite or the ban wagon like it is in Buffalo because of people that think like you. By the way Antonio Gates a first Ballot HOF is praising CJ. Anthony Lynn a Superbowl Champ sees the talent CJ has. A great coach who coached with Bill Parcels is saying it. But you say he is sorry. I believe you. You win. Just don't let me down on what your writings have read. I'll be waaatching.

Lotta garbage in that post

 

Sure Florida might have some of the best ball in the country but that means jack **** about the evaluators of talent down there.

 

Damn, recruit in western and central New York where you really need to find gems . That takes scouting ability.

 

A blind man can recruit in dade county

[transplantbillsfan]

Well. Not much of a question as to Taylor, anymore.

 

We're gonna move on.

[BringBackOrton]

Well. Not much of a question as to Taylor, anymore.

 

We're gonna move on.

Well, if you really think about it, TT did take that $10M paycut that was a much better contract than his original 6 year deal.

 

Edited August 21, 2017 by jmc12290

[BillsFan4]

Well if you don't wanna answer Fan 4 it's ok. I'm from the state of Florida. Where I grew up watching NFL legends once again legends. I'm not just talking about the college program success. Like Micheal Irvin said the best football players ever were breaded in the state of Florida. You name them. So we in this state know more about evaluating talent than any other state. I'll put that in everything I own. Other coaches or programs throughout the country could not match our evaluation of talent. We do not give away positions they earn them. Everyone gets a fair evaluation. They don't ticky tack about he seems better. They earn it and every year is up for grabs. Like belicheck, doesn't care who got picked in what round he will bench a first rounder if he is not better than the man in front. You keep the better player not who might be. That is the difference of winning constantly not guessing, fan favorite or the ban wagon like it is in Buffalo because of people that think like you. By the way Antonio Gates a first Ballot HOF is praising CJ. Anthony Lynn a Superbowl Champ sees the talent CJ has. A great coach who coached with Bill Parcels is saying it. But you say he is sorry. I believe you. You win. Just don't let me down on what your writings have read. I'll be waaatching.

You're post hardly made any sense. There was nothing to answer, and you didn't address almost any of the points I made, you just ignored them. I didn't feel like your gibberish post deserved a response.

 

And your evaluation of football talent has been absolutely terrible from what I've seen. The next time you're right in a football take will be the very first time ever...

 

Tell us again how great Jordan Mills was last season, or how Cardale should be starting for the Bills this season because he's their only chance at winning... lmao.

[26CornerBlitz]

You're post hardly made any sense. There was nothing to answer, and you didn't address almost any of the points I made, you just ignored them. I didn't feel like your gibberish post deserved a response.

 

And your evaluation of football talent has been absolutely terrible from what I've seen. The next time you're right in a football take will be the very first time ever...

 

Tell us again how great Jordan Mills was last season, or how Cardale should be starting for the Bills this season because he's their only chance at winning... lmao.

 

Maybe it's a result of those 75 Noogies.

[BillsFan4]

Maybe it's a result of those 75 Noogies.

Well, he is also BuffaloBud420 too...

 

Maybe he just smoked himself silly.

[Noogie75]

Lotta garbage in that post

 

Sure Florida might have some of the best ball in the country but that means jack **** about the evaluators of talent down there.

 

Damn, recruit in western and central New York where you really need to find gems . That takes scouting ability.

 

A blind man can recruit in dade county

gentleman I said Florida period. That are legends. I'll help you out Warren Sapp, Rey Lewis, edgerin James, Micheal Irvin, Alvin Harper, Dion Sanders, Sammy Watkins, Santonio Holmes, Vince Wilfork Clinton portis and a lot of HOFamers. I do not even the players that played there like Jim Kelly Ed Reed, regie Wayne. Don't even count any HOF from your states they would never even come close no comparison. Butch Davis coached 28 first round draft picks in 5 years from the U of M. Now tell me about evaluating talent. Talk about some other sport but football, no other State can even come close. No Imo, Fact. Edited August 21, 2017 by Noogie75

[transplantbillsfan]

of course whether you can beat good teams works into the equation. lol.

 

if you can't beat good teams, where do you think you are going?

Congrats. It's blatantly clear we're drafting a QB in the top of round 1 and not picking up that option on Taylor in 2018 barring a miraclulous and Herculean effort on his part... something I think more and more posters will be actively rooting for this year.

 

Still think this year there are no excuses for Taylor???

 

 

God I feel bad for McCoy and especially Meatball at this point.

[Noogie75]

Well, he is also BuffaloBud420 too...

 

Maybe he just smoked himself silly.

fun part is when TT makes you look bad because I'mma laugh like crazy. And of course listen to your excuses excuses excuses. I Told Youuu.

By the way another excuse Bouldin retired from the Bills today.