Jump to content

Rotoworld ranks Whaley as worst GM in NFL


Recommended Posts

I would take Josh Dobbs in the 4th. My point still stands. If you believe a QB has franchise potential and you can draft them in the 1st you draft them. You don't wait and hope.

I know this sounds crazy but this is standard thinking in the NFL. The Bills are unique in that they think they can win with other teams backups at QB. It's a bizarre faith that had kept them out of the playoffs for almost 20 years.

The Seahawks believed that Russel Wilson had franchise potential and waited until the 3rd to draft him. There were even those stories about how they were sweating bullets that the Bills would take him ahead of their pick in the 3rd.

 

Oakland thought Carr had franchise potential and waited until the 2nd to draft him.

 

There are plenty of stories like this throughout the years.

 

Teams want players to meet the draft pick value. Teams talk about this often. They weigh the potential of that player not succeeding with the value of the pick and pull the trigger when they think it's right.

Edited by BillsFan4
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 381
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Ha HA, 1-7 all because of the QB? They didn't do that bad last year and they had a train Wrecks for a game day coach. I would think I need to fill more holes on the team before I draft a QB at that point. By the time the rest of the team catches up it will be time to draft another QB. If you're 1-7 you have bigger problem than a QB.

 

I think Vegas will have Bills as underdog in at least 6 out of their first 8 games. Not my special take. Just telling you what the view outside Bills world is.

Edited by jeffismagic
Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

Again, they did better than that with Wrecks and Taylor.

 

Every year is different. McDermott's defense finished worse than Rex's last year in points per game and yards.

 

 

Let me ask you, how many games do you believe the Bills will be a favorite to win in their first 8 games and which teams are they?

Edited by jeffismagic
Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

Every year is different. McDermott's defense finished worse than Rex's last year in points per game and yards.

 

 

Let me ask you, how many games do you believe the Bills will be a favorite to win in their first 8 games and which teams are they?

 

I have no idea to be honest. It's April 23, haven't even gotten past the draft yet. Same players different coach. Let's see what happens in September.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

Every year is different. McDermott's defense finished worse than Rex's last year in points per game and yards.

 

 

Let me ask you, how many games do you believe the Bills will be a favorite to win in their first 8 games and which teams are they?

As of right now, they would probably be favored in two of the eight, with two games in the "pick-em" category. So what? It's completely meaningless at this point, before the draft, before training camp, and before preseason. And after the first game, the deck will be shuffled all over again.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

As of right now, they would probably be favored in two of the eight, with two games in the "pick-em" category. So what? It's completely meaningless at this point, before the draft, before training camp, and before preseason. And after the first game, the deck will be shuffled all over again.

They seem to do better as underdogs anyways.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

I think if we draft Mahomes or Trubisky they would win the #2 spot on the roster. I would expect Mahomes or Trubisky to be inserted into the Bills lineup around week 9 or week 10 as the Bills could have a 1-7 record by then.

 

 

right.

 

 

 

For sure. That's what this board is for. It would be boring if we all thought the same thing.

 

 

you got that right. your posts are always entertaining, not really in a good way but entertaining none the less.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

Thanks! I do what I can.

 

do you even look forward to the season? I ask because you having them winning only one game by the halfway point of the season, why watch? I mean maybe you like to see them lose, or you look forward to it?

 

 

I hate seeing them lose and if I knew the season was a wash before the halfway point, I wouldn't even !@#$ing watch...

Edited by DaBillsFanSince1973
Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

do you even look forward to the season? I ask because you having them winning only one game by the halfway point of the season, why watch? I mean maybe you like to see them lose, or you look forward to it?

 

 

I hate seeing them lose and if I knew the season was a wash before the halfway point, I wouldn't even !@#$ing watch...

They'll be better than 1-7.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

do you even look forward to the season? I ask because you having them winning only one game by the halfway point of the season, why watch? I mean maybe you like to see them lose, or you look forward to it?

 

 

I hate seeing them lose and if I knew the season was a wash before the halfway point, I wouldn't even !@#$ing watch...

 

Yes, I hate seeing them lose. That's why I hope they start flying right. But I've been waiting for a long time.

 

If we're going to have a bad year I will feel much better if we have a young QB with potential who can play. Otherwise, this can be a very dark year. Nothing is worse than a bad team that doesn't know they are a bad team and my worst case scenario is that our management team is way in over their head.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

Yes, I hate seeing them lose. That's why I hope they start flying right. But I've been waiting for a long time.

 

If we're going to have a bad year I will feel much better if we have a young QB with potential who can play. Otherwise, this can be a very dark year. Nothing is worse than a bad team that doesn't know they are a bad team and my worst case scenario is that our management team is way in over their head.

 

 

glad I don't see it your way, I'm looking forward to the season.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

 

glad I don't see it your way, I'm looking forward to the season.

...ditto bud.....it is a new era with McCoach......don't expect miracles the first year, but the negative Nellies and their crap do get old.....year 55 for me and I still follow them......maybe darts or horseshoes should be in their repertoire.....Jesus.....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

...ditto bud.....it is a new era with McCoach......don't expect miracles the first year, but the negative Nellies and their crap do get old.....year 55 for me and I still follow them......maybe darts or horseshoes should be in their repertoire.....Jesus.....

17 years straight without a playoff appearance is embarrassing. No excuse for that. Even Cleveland made it once.55 years is a long time. You're probably numb to the losing.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

17 years straight without a playoff appearance is embarrassing. No excuse for that. Even Cleveland made it once.55 years is a long time. You're probably numb to the losing.

....embarrassing?.....more like repulsive.....not sure why I want to endure year 55 of following this club.....here is the Cliff Notes version of the "abysmal 17+".....the DonoHOLE era set this club back a decade....sure he inherited cap jail from Butler...BUT....Tom Terrific's ego and freakish control nature set the ball rolling starting with his insistence of being anointed "El Presidente".......made all personnel decisions and force fed them to subordinating, cheap HC's with the "make it work" edict.....$900 grand for Airhorn Greggy?.....once RW realized his "inner circle of trust" was violated, he started promoting Brandon into positions unqualified for (he trusted him) and "re-tired" Marv with 4 new Firestones...hence, the FO and Admin patchwork show began.....sure Nix was a football guy but how much was left in his tank at 70+ (NO disrespect implied)?...then we follow with the Gailey and Jauron eras, hardly pre-eminent guys on the sidelines....followed bty the Marrone "Saban/Petrino" adios via the back door.....now Pegula takes the reins and is raked over the coals because he is NOT allowed any ownership learning curve among the TBD "braintrusts" who wanted to buy the club, but were a tad short on funds....the Wrecks hire was purely a "Brandon ticket sale" sham and me thinks Terry now knows it.....so he is now a business guy only...the Pegulas are proud people and do not want to be associated with losers, be it the Bills, Sabres, Rochester Americans, etc....cut them and McCoach some slack....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

....embarrassing?.....more like repulsive.....not sure why I want to endure year 55 of following this club.....here is the Cliff Notes version of the "abysmal 17+".....the DonoHOLE era set this club back a decade....sure he inherited cap jail from Butler...BUT....Tom Terrific's ego and freakish control nature set the ball rolling starting with his insistence of being anointed "El Presidente".......made all personnel decisions and force fed them to subordinating, cheap HC's with the "make it work" edict.....$900 grand for Airhorn Greggy?.....once RW realized his "inner circle of trust" was violated, he started promoting Brandon into positions unqualified for (he trusted him) and "re-tired" Marv with 4 new Firestones...hence, the FO and Admin patchwork show began.....sure Nix was a football guy but how much was left in his tank at 70+ (NO disrespect implied)?...then we follow with the Gailey and Jauron eras, hardly pre-eminent guys on the sidelines....followed bty the Marrone "Saban/Petrino" adios via the back door.....now Pegula takes the reins and is raked over the coals because he is NOT allowed any ownership learning curve among the TBD "braintrusts" who wanted to buy the club, but were a tad short on funds....the Wrecks hire was purely a "Brandon ticket sale" sham and me thinks Terry now knows it.....so he is now a business guy only...the Pegulas are proud people and do not want to be associated with losers, be it the Bills, Sabres, Rochester Americans, etc....cut them and McCoach some slack....

Can't really argue with any of this, although the Pegulas have to get this thing fixed.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...