Tyrod to remain starter

[MAJBobby]

What about the injury risk?

What about it? Contract is insured

[jms62]

Yes they do have insurance

 

 

After 5 minutes of debate among myselves in spare time I want EJ Manuel to start and to me there is no other reasonable desire for Jones or Taylor

 

Manuel is a backup QB at best. He is an impending FA. We are likely done with Taylor or if not we need a decent backup. We don't need to rush Jones, he is going to be here a while and still not likely an answer for 2017.

 

EJ Manuel could and should have more impact on our roster as a backup QB in 2017 than anyone.

 

We need to see if Manuel has anything he can offer us for 2017 as a backup. We need to do that now and it won't happen because Rex needs wins for his only hope to stay and tied his horse to Taylor. If Rex wanted to do the best thing for this team he would not start Taylor. He would start anyone else to see what's in the toolbag.

 

But Rex is a damn disaster who needs to drive his truck in to the damn lake with this dumbass brother tied to it.

 

What does EJ have to show on this try to absolutely convince you he doesn't have a future as a starting NFL QB.. Why are people willing to toss Tyrod after a decent season last year becuase he has regressed yet give EJ chance after chance

despite prior failings.

[MAJBobby]

 

But they still lose the cap space.

 

GENIUS.

A lot of contracts are written that way. Unless it is a major issue he will be cleared by team Drs and no loss of anything.

Only way TT sees the Bench is if Rex is fired.

 

After all he is coaching for his job of course he is gonna ride with Taylor.

[MDH]

 

 

 

What does EJ have to show on this try to absolutely convince you he doesn't have a future as a starting NFL QB.. Why are people willing to toss Tyrod after a decent season last year becuase he has regressed yet give EJ chance after chance

despite prior failings.

 

EJ has started a grand total of 16 games in his career yet somehow he's been given "chance after chance" while we still don't know enough about Tyrod to toss him aside?

 

I want to start EJ, not to evaluate him, but because I doubt Jones is ready and I don't want TT to get hurt. It's that simple.

[NorthBuffaloKid]

SIGH!!!

 

I feel like Charlie Brown on Halloween.

 

Always disappointed.

[BrooklynBills]

A lot of contracts are written that way. Unless it is a major issue he will be cleared by team Drs and no loss of anything. Only way TT sees the Bench is if Rex is fired.

After all he is coaching for his job of course he is gonna ride with Taylor.

How does that work if it is an injury that takes him past when the option needs to be picked up? Wouldn't they have to exercise the option if he were to suffer a long term injury?

[GottaRun]

According to Wiki

'If a player has a legitimate long-term injury, his cap hit is still counted; however, the team is permitted to replace him with one or more players whose combined salary is equal to (or less than) that of the injured player, even if the additional players would put the team over the salary cap. If the team's cap room is larger than the injured player's cap hit, they may take on as much as their cap room; however, the injured player may not return to play until the team is again compliant with the original cap.'

 

So if Tyrod is severely injured in the next 3 games, never plays again, gets his money then

 

An insurer probably pays him, in 2017 the Bills can use the $16 million cap hit and 2018 the $17 million cap hit to sign someone else.

 

I don't claim to understand this stuff, but if this is the case the risk of playing Tyrod does not seem too bad.

 

** so the $27 million being thrown around is his guaranteed money for the next 2 years ** I think?

Edited December 13, 2016 by driddles

[ndirish1978]

This guy isn't an NFL quarterback. He doesn't have the skill or temperament to win. Did you guys see Tom Brady lose his mind after an incompletion on a deep ball to Edelman? That's called being competitive. Tyrod lofts 3 terrible passes per series and then just goes to sit quietly on the sideline.

[dave mcbride]

After 5 minutes of debate among myselves in spare time I want EJ Manuel to start and to me there is no other reasonable desire for Jones or Taylor

 

Manuel is a backup QB at best. He is an impending FA. We are likely done with Taylor or if not we need a decent backup. We don't need to rush Jones, he is going to be here a while and still not likely an answer for 2017.

 

EJ Manuel could and should have more impact on our roster as a backup QB in 2017 than anyone.

 

We need to see if Manuel has anything he can offer us for 2017 as a backup. We need to do that now and it won't happen because Rex needs wins for his only hope to stay and tied his horse to Taylor. If Rex wanted to do the best thing for this team he would not start Taylor. He would start anyone else to see what's in the toolbag.

 

But Rex is a damn disaster who needs to drive his truck in to the damn lake with this dumbass brother tied to it.

To keep EJ Manuel next year, the Bills will be required to pay him over $11 million next season. That's what the Bills had to pay Gilmore when opting to pursue the club option they possessed. Needless to say, the Bills will not do this. He will not be in Buffalo in 2017 unless he hits the open market and decides to come back to Buffalo. The chances of that happening are close to zero.

 

EJ has started a grand total of 16 games in his career yet somehow he's been given "chance after chance" while we still don't know enough about Tyrod to toss him aside?

 

I want to start EJ, not to evaluate him, but because I doubt Jones is ready and I don't want TT to get hurt. It's that simple.

MDH: He is not good. It's obvious, at least in my opinion. Most of the NFL seems to think similarly. I don't like Marrone, but he knows more than I do. Rex isn't a fan either.

[Nostradumbass]

This guy isn't an NFL quarterback. He doesn't have the skill or temperament to win. Did you guys see Tom Brady lose his mind after an incompletion on a deep ball to Edelman? That's called being competitive. Tyrod lofts 3 terrible passes per series and then just goes to sit quietly on the sideline.

 

That's your measurement? Reaction after a Int? You're talking about our QB who takes more hellacious hits in a QRT trying to stretch out drives with his legs than Brady does in a year? What a@#@# joke statement that is

 

It's amazing to me that the QB who has provided us with the best play from that position in a decade is being @#@## on so bad by fans

 

Yes he has faults and isn't a top tier QB but Tyrod has led this team to 6 wins and in the losses had us up in 3rd quarter in three of the biggest games we played Mia, NYJ and Oak

 

If this defense makes a single stand in one of those games we are possibly talking playoffs

 

1. Defense

2. Coaching

3.Offense

 

In that order in terms of what needs to be fixed

 

If Tyrod is mediocre than the Defense should be categorized as "Dumpster Fire"

Edited December 13, 2016 by Nostradumbass

[Formerly Allan in MD]

It's only because Taylor gives him the best chance of winning remaining games. This loser of a coach thinks that by winning he'll likely be retained. Cardaele needs to play and should be doing it now. But logic hasn't mattered in this organization since the Levy era.

[Nostradumbass]

Like I said.

 

You put this offense with the 2014 defense and they are a playoff team.

 

Wasn't that the blueprint to win when Rex was hired?

Yes unfortunately NFL coaches are burdened with a disproportionate sense of their own worth/ability and it behooves them to ever accept that something isn't broker and should be left alone

 

In the next set of coaching interviews a question should be asked "what do you think of the Bills running game?"

 

Any coach that answers "It's good but I can make it better" should be scratched from the list

[Pine Barrens Mafia]

 

That's your measurement? Reaction after a Int? You're talking about our QB who takes more hellacious hits in a QRT trying to stretch out drives with his legs than Brady does in a year? What a@#@# joke statement that is

 

It's amazing to me that the QB who has provided us with the best play from that position in a decade is being @#@## on so bad by fans

 

Yes he has faults and isn't a top tier QB but Tyrod has led this team to 6 wins and in the losses had us up in 3rd quarter in three of the biggest games we played Mia, NYJ and Oak

 

If this defense makes a single stand in one of those games we are possibly talking playoffs

 

1. Defense

2. Coaching

3.Offense

 

In that order in terms of what needs to be fixed

 

If Tyrod is mediocre than the Defense should be categorized as "Dumpster Fire"

 

I take it you're OK with being 32nd in passing in the NFL...

 

Imagine if this team was, say, 20th in passing. Think we could have won those games? I do.

[Sisyphean Bills]

 

EJ has started a grand total of 16 games in his career yet somehow he's been given "chance after chance" while we still don't know enough about Tyrod to toss him aside?

 

I want to start EJ, not to evaluate him, but because I doubt Jones is ready and I don't want TT to get hurt. It's that simple.

 

EJM was a QB that Buddy and Doug talked themselves into. Buddy freely admitted that he had reservations about EJM on film, but it was after he talked to him that he started to come around. I'm sure EJM is a nice guy and said a lot of great things, but Nix should've believed his eyes. Unfortunately, Nix had also driven the bus into a cul-de-sac. He didn't have many options and had to roll the dice.

 

And that underscores the lack of strategic thinking in the organization. Instead of drafting and developing guys, this team has been of the treadmill of letting players go, rather than paying them, and having to draft to patch holes. Multiply that by the fact that draft picks don't work out anywhere close to 100% of the time, and the team is always playing guys from the "Modrak Wheelhouse" on the field. 6th and 7th rounders, UDFAs, and street FAs no other team wanted. And the everything-is-fine narrative offered is that this is somehow doing a really terrific job.

 

But back to QB. If the Bills had drafted a backup QB with the intention of having Chan Gailey mold him into his starting QB, then we might actually have a QB. But they didn't. Instead they spent their drafts trying to switch to a 3-4 and then a Miami defense and then ...

[boyst]

To keep EJ Manuel next year, the Bills will be required to pay him over $11 million next season. That's what the Bills had to pay Gilmore when opting to pursue the club option they possessed. Needless to say, the Bills will not do this. He will not be in Buffalo in 2017 unless he hits the open market and decides to come back to Buffalo. The chances of that happening are close to zero.

 

MDH: He is not good. It's obvious, at least in my opinion. Most of the NFL seems to think similarly. I don't like Marrone, but he knows more than I do. Rex isn't a fan either.

the bills can let him go to free agency then sign him back. We do not have to do that. We would have already had to do that actually to my knieledhe

[All I Need is Hope]

I'm really having trouble understanding this one. I don't get angry anymore, because I realize that the majority of the decisions made by this organization are usually bad.

 

However, why in the world are they starting Tyrod? If he wins against the terrible competition coming up, our draft position suffers. Virtually everyone has decided he's not good enough to get to and win in the playoffs, and there's several rumors that he won't be kept. So, we lose draft position and don't gain a thing.

 

So, there's no down-side to starting Cardale. If he shows REAL (not the Chris Brown / Russ Brandon / John Murphy-fueled false hope) promise, great. If he's ok, great as well, at least we start to know what we have. If he's terrible, we lose and our draft position gets better. NO DOWNSIDE.

 

If I was Pegula, I'm not sure how the hell I'm convinced that starting Tyrod is the right move.

[Alphadawg7]

 

 

 

What does EJ have to show on this try to absolutely convince you he doesn't have a future as a starting NFL QB.. Why are people willing to toss Tyrod after a decent season last year becuase he has regressed yet give EJ chance after chance

despite prior failings.

 

Here is my stance: IF, and ONLY if the FO has already decided to officially NOT pickup Taylors option, then I would sit him and let EJ play. Here are my reasons:

 

1. If they are truly done with Taylor, which none of us know one way or the other as its all just speculation, then there is no value in playing him the last 3 games other than he gives us best chance to win most likely.

2. Season is done essentially, so winning isn't important anymore as draft position is more valuable now that playoffs are all but gone.

3. EJ has been a class act, serious class act, and never complained, always supported Taylor, did everything asked of him, and worked his tail off his whole time in Buffalo. He has had moments of potential, it wasnt all bad. He is about to be a FA, why not give him a chance to show he is worth looking at in FA next year? Reward him with a shot to show he is worth looking at to compete for a starting job somewhere next year. If he fails, it doesnt hurt us as it only improves our draft position. If he does good, then he may be worth bringing back next year to compete for a starting or backup spot given we only have Cardale if Taylor is gone. So we literally have nothing to lose either way. Its not about believing he will do well, its more like who cares if he does or does not, we benefit either way and reward the kid for what he's attempted to give to this franchise.

 

Now, if the team has NOT made up its mind on Taylor, then you should absolutely stick with him the final 3 games to help them with their final decision. Lets not forget, they could always not pick up the option and bring him back cheaper too if he was willing to do so.

[Herb62]

Bring back Kay Stevenson

[jms62]

 

Here is my stance: IF, and ONLY if the FO has already decided to officially NOT pickup Taylors option, then I would sit him and let EJ play. Here are my reasons:

 

1. If they are truly done with Taylor, which none of us know one way or the other as its all just speculation, then there is no value in playing him the last 3 games other than he gives us best chance to win most likely.

2. Season is done essentially, so winning isn't important anymore as draft position is more valuable now that playoffs are all but gone.

3. EJ has been a class act, serious class act, and never complained, always supported Taylor, did everything asked of him, and worked his tail off his whole time in Buffalo. He has had moments of potential, it wasnt all bad. He is about to be a FA, why not give him a chance to show he is worth looking at in FA next year? Reward him with a shot to show he is worth looking at to compete for a starting job somewhere next year. If he fails, it doesnt hurt us as it only improves our draft position. If he does good, then he may be worth bringing back next year to compete for a starting or backup spot given we only have Cardale if Taylor is gone. So we literally have nothing to lose either way. Its not about believing he will do well, its more like who cares if he does or does not, we benefit either way and reward the kid for what he's attempted to give to this franchise.

 

Now, if the team has NOT made up its mind on Taylor, then you should absolutely stick with him the final 3 games to help them with their final decision. Lets not forget, they could always not pick up the option and bring him back cheaper too if he was willing to do so.

 

 

What would you do if you were in Ryan's shoes? If he gets booted at the end of the season you think he has a better shot at getting a new gig coming from a team that is 9-7 or coming from a team that completely collapsed and finished losing 5 in a row and finishing at 6-10?.

[QCity]

 

 

What would you do if you were in Ryan's shoes? If he gets booted at the end of the season you think he has a better shot at getting a new gig coming from a team that is 9-7 or coming from a team that completely collapsed and finished losing 5 in a row and finishing at 6-10?.

 

Rex isn't going to another team, he's going straight to a booth in NY and he's going to collect two paychecks.