Jump to content

Topic of the day 7/2: Who are the best coordinators?


Recommended Posts

so much of this is based on players, for the offense a QB. Gilbride with Bledsoe and Moulds/Price combo was fantastic

for the defense you have to have a pass rusher or several. Schwartz had a motivated Hughes to go with Mario and the others

specials teams what sad is we had tremendous special teams for years and we sucked. Bobby April and there is not a close second

 

who was chuck knox d coord in 1980

Link to comment
Share on other sites

so much of this is based on players, for the offense a QB. Gilbride with Bledsoe and Moulds/Price combo was fantastic

for the defense you have to have a pass rusher or several. Schwartz had a motivated Hughes to go with Mario and the others

specials teams what sad is we had tremendous special teams for years and we sucked. Bobby April and there is not a close second

 

who was chuck knox d coord in 1980

 

Just thinking outloud...

 

Bruce DeHaven isn't a close second as ST Coordinator?

 

Ted Marchibroda maybe for OC.

 

Wade Phillips maybe for DC.

Edited by hondo in seattle
Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

Just thinking outloud...

 

Bruce DeHaven isn't a close second as ST Coordinator?

 

Ted Marchibroda maybe for OC.

 

Wade Phillips maybe for DC.

 

No "maybe" about it. Wade is one of the best DCs ever in the NFL.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Marchibroda certainly had talent to work with but we still have to give him a lot of credit for transforming an anemic offense into a powerhouse. It took a lot of balls to implement the K-Gun full time and give away play-calling to the QB.

Some interesting comments from Eric Schweitz back in 1997...

 

"In retrospect, it seems hardly a coincidence that while the Colts under Marchibroda were slowly and steadily improving as an offensive team, the Bills, in his absence, were slowly on the decline. The last year Marchibroda was with the Bills, Jim Kelly threw for 33 touchdowns. The next four years, Kelly would hover around 20 touchdowns and bottom out his last season with a meager 14 touchdowns. Meanwhile, under Marchibroda's tutelage, Jim Harbaugh and Vinny Testaverde, two quarterbacks who had each nearly been drummed out of the NFL altogether at times, would have brilliant campaigns in 95 and 96...

 

Along with Kelly's almost naked drop in production after Marchibroda's departure, one can see a dramatic drop statistically in Thurman Thomas's rushing production. Thurman averaged almost 5 yards per carry in Marchibroda's last year and the first year afterward. Since 92 however, Thomas's numbers have dropped to the 3.7 to 3.8 yards per carry range.

 

Could all these factors be linked in some way?

The answer is very definitely in the affirmative. Without Marchibroda, the Bills were left with a creative and innovative void in their offense. While he had put in place a system that would continue to succeed in the short term, in hindsight it becomes obvious that those entrusted to pick up where Ted left off did not do so. "

I think the paradigm nowadays is that any OC could have succeeded with Kelly, Thurman, Reed and Lofton - and Marchibroda was merely a replaceable, unimportant cog in the machine. I'm not convinced Ted was our greatest OC but I do think he's under-appreciated.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...