eball Posted May 26, 2016 Posted May 26, 2016 (edited) Personally, I do not think that Rex is very good. I think that the Bills have done a nice job on the personnel side. I would have the FO around the top ten. I would have the coaching bottom ten (and that is with getting a boost from Roman). Rex did less with more last year than any coach that I can remember. In addition, he is a horrible game manager. Always toeing the company line... Edited May 26, 2016 by eball
D. L. Hot-Flamethrower Posted May 26, 2016 Posted May 26, 2016 (edited) Personally, I do not think that Rex is very good. I think that the Bills have done a nice job on the personnel side. I would have the FO around the top ten. I would have the coaching bottom ten (and that is with getting a boost from Roman). Rex did less with more last year than any coach that I can remember. In addition, he is a horrible game manager. 100%. Got your back if you need it when the FO haters attack. Edited May 26, 2016 by The Thurmanator
billykaykay Posted May 26, 2016 Posted May 26, 2016 Personally, I do not think that Rex is very good. I think that the Bills have done a nice job on the personnel side. I would have the FO around the top ten. I would have the coaching bottom ten (and that is with getting a boost from Roman). Rex did less with more last year than any coach that I can remember. In addition, he is a horrible game manager. I agree - he is not a very good game manager. The KC game could have been won if he simply had someone in the booth checking replays. I noted here many times during the season that MW was simply playing pattycake with the tackle in front of him. OK, fine. If we can see that, why didn't he get benched. My brother , an ardent Jets fan, told me when we got RR that he goes very conservative at the end of the half & the end of the game defensively. I noticed this in a couple of games. This isn't necessarily a bad thing but it shows to me a lack of confidence in his own scheme. I guess we'll see this year.
BobbyC81 Posted May 26, 2016 Posted May 26, 2016 Personally, I do not think that Rex is very good. I think that the Bills have done a nice job on the personnel side. I would have the FO around the top ten. I would have the coaching bottom ten (and that is with getting a boost from Roman). Rex did less with more last year than any coach that I can remember. In addition, he is a horrible game manager. For me, nothing will top his answer as to why he didn't challenge calls in KC "because they didn't show it on the board." He'll have to do a lot to get me behind him after that one.
Augie Posted May 26, 2016 Posted May 26, 2016 I'd have Rex a bit lower for doing less with more and his general game management. I also wish there was just a little suspense regarding who would be #1.
D. L. Hot-Flamethrower Posted May 26, 2016 Posted May 26, 2016 (edited) I haven't seen many comments on the rest of the list. Here goes nothing: 1. Why are Chip Kelly and Bill O'Brien ranked ahead of Gary Kubiak? 2. Why is Hue Jackson, a first year coach in effect ranked 18th, not down with the other guys who've just started? 3. Not sure that Arians deserves to be #3 ahead of guys who've accomplished alot more like McCarthy and Payton! 4. Same with Zimmer, ahead of Tomlin? Edited May 26, 2016 by The Thurmanator
26CornerBlitz Posted May 26, 2016 Author Posted May 26, 2016 I haven't seen many comments on the rest of the list. Here goes nothing: 1. Why are Chip Kelly and Bill O'Brien ranked ahead of Gary Kubiak? 2. Why is Hue Jackson, a first year coach in effect ranked 18th, not down with the other guys who've just started? 3. Not sure that Arians deserves to be #3 ahead of guys who've accomplished alot more like McCarthy and Payton! 4. Same with Zimmer, ahead of Tomlin? Hue has been a HC before with Oakland and did a pretty good job.
iinii Posted May 26, 2016 Posted May 26, 2016 All seems pretty accurate. Sir Cheats-a-lot is number 1 and Mularkey is the worst. I would like to see Tomlin a little higher but not sure where. I might drop Zimmer to six and move Payton to four. Fisher gets slammed as needed. How does he still has a job?
D. L. Hot-Flamethrower Posted May 26, 2016 Posted May 26, 2016 All seems pretty accurate. Sir Cheats-a-lot is number 1 and Mularkey is the worst. I would like to see Tomlin a little higher but not sure where. I might drop Zimmer to six and move Payton to four. Fisher gets slammed as needed. How does he still has a job? Fisher is close to breaking the all time record for losses I heard. Hue has been a HC before with Oakland and did a pretty good job. Ok I see 8-8. For some reason I thought he had been an interim and only coached a few games. Thanks. Still think he's pretty high!
BADOLBILZ Posted May 27, 2016 Posted May 27, 2016 (edited) Personally, I do not think that Rex is very good. I think that the Bills have done a nice job on the personnel side. I would have the FO around the top ten. I would have the coaching bottom ten (and that is with getting a boost from Roman). Rex did less with more last year than any coach that I can remember. In addition, he is a horrible game manager. It's really unusual to see a head coach do such an obviously awful job. And as you mentioned that was DESPITE hiring the best offensive coordinator he'd ever had......by a lot. It was a shock........I was not a HUGE Rex fan after watching his team play dead in most of the 2014 season until showing up at the end to try to save themselves an extra minicamp engagement.......but I thought he had actually did a borderline "great" job with the 2013 Jets......actually getting a lot more production than that roster should have. Edited May 27, 2016 by #BADOL
boyst Posted May 27, 2016 Posted May 27, 2016 I haven't seen many comments on the rest of the list. Here goes nothing: 1. Why are Chip Kelly and Bill O'Brien ranked ahead of Gary Kubiak? 2. Why is Hue Jackson, a first year coach in effect ranked 18th, not down with the other guys who've just started? 3. Not sure that Arians deserves to be #3 ahead of guys who've accomplished alot more like McCarthy and Payton! 4. Same with Zimmer, ahead of Tomlin? because lists are jokes. arians is not that good.
Buffalo Barbarian Posted May 27, 2016 Posted May 27, 2016 USA Today recently ranked the NFL coaches 16. Rex Ryan, Bills Ryan is known as a brilliant defensive mind, but he’s going to need a bounce back season to retain that title. He hasn’t produced a top-10 unit in three seasons, and he hasn’t led his team to a winning record since 2010. @SInow Time for Rex Ryan to rise above mediocrity, prove his worth with Bills (by @amy_parlapiano) http://on.si.com/1qLMb9B with only two winning seasons he has to be lower OOO says that's top half of the league! NNN says lower half, HA! RRR says lower middle 13 years with same system and no playoff wins if certain idiots weren't morons last yr they beat Pittsburgh, just saying.
Buffalo Barbarian Posted May 27, 2016 Posted May 27, 2016 because lists are jokes. arians is not that good. yeah he was horrible with Roethlisberger and Luck and resurrected Palmers Career. I'd take him in a heart beat and is who we should have hired instead of Maroon and we probably would have Palmer too and be in the playoffs, which would of course be bad for this board.
YoloinOhio Posted May 27, 2016 Posted May 27, 2016 with only two winning seasons he has to be lower NNN says lower half, HA! RRR says lower middle if certain idiots weren't morons last yr they beat Pittsburgh, just saying. im not saying Lewis isn't a good coach. But he's accountable for the fact those guys acted like idiots. His teams lack discipline and poise.
machine gun kelly Posted May 27, 2016 Posted May 27, 2016 Chip Kelly at 11. They must be kidding. These rankings are dumb as they inspire comments like mine and no one will ever agree on a list. FWIW I agree where RR is at 16.
boyst Posted May 27, 2016 Posted May 27, 2016 yeah he was horrible with Roethlisberger and Luck and resurrected Palmers Career. I'd take him in a heart beat and is who we should have hired instead of Maroon and we probably would have Palmer too and be in the playoffs, which would of course be bad for this board. head coachis vastly different than positional or coordinator. And what's he ever won?
Manther Posted May 27, 2016 Posted May 27, 2016 Personally, I do not think that Rex is very good. I think that the Bills have done a nice job on the personnel side. I would have the FO around the top ten. I would have the coaching bottom ten (and that is with getting a boost from Roman). Rex did less with more last year than any coach that I can remember. In addition, he is a horrible game manager. Agreed, well said.
JohnC Posted May 27, 2016 Posted May 27, 2016 Personally, I do not think that Rex is very good. I think that the Bills have done a nice job on the personnel side. I would have the FO around the top ten. I would have the coaching bottom ten (and that is with getting a boost from Roman). Rex did less with more last year than any coach that I can remember. In addition, he is a horrible game manager. With Rex it is always about Rex. Instead of taking the view of how best to utilize the players he has on hand his view is how do I get them to make my system work. This draft was dedicated to propping up Rex and making it work within the confines of his system. What worked before his arrival didn't work under him so it now is undergoing a deconstruction to accommodate him. Another example of our organization moving forward and then taking a step back to start all over again. Roman is the antithesis to Rex. Look at how he handled Tyrod Taylor? He was aware of TT's limitations as an inexperienced qb and managed his limitations very smartly. The outcome was that he got as much production out of him as was possible. This season I'm confident that the playbook will be expanded and his responsibilities will be increased. Roman also had a major deficiency on the OL, most evident on the right side. He managed that liability and still had one of the better running games in the league. My point is obvious: Good coaches manage their deficiencies and accentuate their strengths. Rex did the opposite. I still shake my head at the Rex hiring and repeatingly say: WTF!
Recommended Posts