Jump to content

Go on the record: who should the Bills have taken at 19?

johnwalter

By johnwalter
in The Stadium Wall Archives

 Share

  

95 members have voted

  1. 1. Who should the Bills have taken at 19?

    • Whaley got it right: Shaq Lawson!
      78
    • Darron Lee
      3
    • Paxton Lynch
      2
    • Robert Nkemdiche
      3
    • Myles Jack
      3
    • Jarran Reed
      0
    • Reggie Ragland
      2
    • Noah Spence
      0
    • Chris Jones
      0
    • Josh Doctson
      1
    • Laquon Treadwell
      2
    • Will Fuller
      0
    • Someone Else (Comment!)
      1

Recommended Posts

johnwalter RFA

johnwalter

Posted
Posted

Picks 1-18 have already happened.

 

Jared Goff, Carson Wentz, Joey Bosa, Ezekiel Elliott, Jalen Ramsey, Ronnie Stanley, DeForest Buckner, Jack Conklin, Leonard Floyd, Eli Apple, Vernon Hargreaves, Sheldon Rankins, Laremy Tunsil, Karl Joseph, Corey Coleman, Taylor Decker, Keanu Neal, and Ryan Kelly are all off the board.

 

No trading back.

 

Go on the record: who should the Bills have taken at 19?

26CornerBlitz Hall of Famer

26CornerBlitz

Posted
Posted

Let's put it this way. A numbnuts like Ryan and Whaley picked a non-descript DE, while a Super Bowl winner like John Elway MOVED UP to take Lynch. Says it all.

 

Enlightening. :rolleyes:

thebandit27 Hall of Famer

thebandit27

Posted
Posted

Let's put it this way. A numbnuts like Ryan and Whaley picked a non-descript DE, while a Super Bowl winner like John Elway MOVED UP to take Lynch. Says it all.

Yeah, why take a versatile, talented defender when you can overdraft a passer that doesn't read the field and misses intermediate throws waaaaaay too often?

And I would've taken Jack, but Shaq was my 2nd

boyst Hall of Famer

boyst

Posted
Posted

drop down would have been fine with me. drop to 31. pick up an extra 3rd? than use that pick and the extra 4th or the 5th to move up to 23-25?

 

otherwise, i liked lee. treadwell. then lawson.

nucci Hall of Famer

nucci

Posted
Posted

Let's put it this way. A numbnuts like Ryan and Whaley picked a non-descript DE, while a Super Bowl winner like John Elway MOVED UP to take Lynch. Says it all.

What does it say?

bananathumb Veteran

bananathumb

Posted
Posted

These D guys are a dime a dozen


What does it say?

Says Buffalo FO knows little. Who is going to play QB here in a year or two? I know who's going to play in Denver. The guy we should have picked. Book it.

Alphadawg7 Hall of Famer

Alphadawg7

Posted
Posted

Let's put it this way. A numbnuts like Ryan and Whaley picked a non-descript DE, while a Super Bowl winner like John Elway MOVED UP to take Lynch. Says it all.

Denver also moved up to take Tim Tebow, so what's your point?

K-9 Hall of Famer

K-9

Posted
Posted

Whaley got this pick about as right as you can get a pick. Most prognosticators had taken before our turn to pick and it's hard to imagine there was anyone else above him on our board. And it's a HUGE bonus when BPA meets an area of need.

 

GO BILLS!!!

hondo in seattle All Pro

hondo in seattle

Posted
Posted

I think this is a great thread. So often fans - with 20/20 hindsight - say we should have take this Pro Bowler or that Pro Bowler instead of the bum we actually drafted.

 

So let's say it now.

 

For myself, I'm going to guess this: if I had the same input from the scouting staff that DW had, I probably would have picked Shaq too.

 

As a Bills/NFL fan who doesn't study college game tape, I agree entirely with K-9:

 

Whaley got this pick about as right as you can get a pick. Most prognosticators had taken before our turn to pick and it's hard to imagine there was anyone else above him on our board. And it's a HUGE bonus when BPA meets an area of need.

 

GO BILLS!!!

Marty McFly Veteran

Marty McFly

Posted
Posted

Whaley got this pick about as right as you can get a pick. Most prognosticators had taken before our turn to pick and it's hard to imagine there was anyone else above him on our board. And it's a HUGE bonus when BPA meets an area of need.

 

GO BILLS!!!

Yep, I had no doubt he would be gone at 12 or 13 at least. We lucked out and we got him AND Reggie in the 2nd. This draft is looking good for us and Tenessee, jesus the Titans have so many 2nd round picks they are gonna be a good team in a year or two.

Tenhigh Veteran

Tenhigh

Posted
Posted

Let's put it this way. A numbnuts like Ryan and Whaley picked a non-descript DE, while a Super Bowl winner like John Elway MOVED UP to take Lynch. Says it all.

You mean the same John Elway who had no QB on his roster 24 hours ago? At this time yesterday, 55 year old Elway was the most qualified QB in Denver.
What a Tuel Veteran

What a Tuel

Posted
Posted

Let's put it this way. A numbnuts like Ryan and Whaley picked a non-descript DE, while a Super Bowl winner like John Elway MOVED UP to take Lynch. Says it all.

 

How many successful QBs has John Elway drafted?

 Share
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...