Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

 

Does it matter if he connects? If so, why? And won;t the cop claim the punch connected?

 

And what would McCoy or the NFLPA say in their appeal meeting while that video is rolling that would convince the NFL (or an arbitrator) that the suspension was grossly misapplied and must be reversed?

 

Where Goodell often gets in trouble with his rulings is not that he is out of bounds in punishing players but very often he is wrong in the scale of his punishment, and in the consistency from his prior rulings. For the sake of argument if Roger gave McCoy a one game suspension or a fine the union would be in a weak position to successfully challenge the ruling by the very erratic commissioner.

 

Going back to your original question whether McCoy connected or not being involved in a bar room brawl is enough for him to invoke the off field conduct clause. The same issue of off duty behavior and repercussions will be addressed by the department the officers work for.(That's my opinion.)

  • Replies 2.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted

'Well, we've committed 236 fully deputized investigators to the case, with a wide range of expertise -from criminal psychologists and forensic specialists to societal behavior experts. All under the direction of Captain Beerball. We expect to render our decision in the coming weeks..' Chief Scott Samara

 

HA! I also expected a response from Roger Goodell, one of my favorite TBD personalities.

Posted

Does it matter if he connects? If so, why? And won;t the cop claim the punch connected?

 

And what would McCoy or the NFLPA say in their appeal meeting while that video is rolling that would convince the NFL (or an arbitrator) that the suspension was grossly misapplied and must be reversed?

 

Does it matter if he connects? Really? How do you injure someone if you don't actually make contact him/her?

 

And if it doesn't matter, how does Rog justify suspending him? Because he threw an air punch? Again players aren't even suspended for throwing punches during games.

Posted

CSI: TBD *still* hasnt cracked this case? How many pages of speculation is it going to take!?

 

Still haven't found your cooler either, after all these years.

Posted

 

Does it matter if he connects? Really? How do you injure someone if you don't actually make contact him/her?

 

And if it doesn't matter, how does Rog justify suspending him? Because he threw an air punch? Again players aren't even suspended for throwing punches during games.

 

This in a nutshell. This matter will quietly close with a whimper and McCoy isn't getting any time.

Posted

 

Still haven't found your cooler either, after all these years.

 

CSI: TBD Cold Cases could be a great spin-off show... :beer:

Posted

 

CSI: TBD Cold Cases could be a great spin-off show... :beer:

 

Episode 1: Heitz's cooler.

Episode 2: Where does The Dean disappear to?

Episode 3: Why is Ed a horrible human being?

Posted

 

Does it matter if he connects? Really? How do you injure someone if you don't actually make contact him/her?

 

And if it doesn't matter, how does Rog justify suspending him? Because he threw an air punch? Again players aren't even suspended for throwing punches during games.

intent to harm

 

HA! I also expected a response from Roger Goodell, one of my favorite TBD personalities.

he has been noticeably absent in this matter. Weighing the evidence against the opinion polls perhaps?

Posted

True. But that would require the DA to charge him with that.

of course. just saying the video if entered as evidence shows an intent to injure. i might guess this is just going to fall off the media radar. funny how significant personal and or legal indiscretions disappear when the weapons are off safety.

 

Welcome my friends to the legal Machine.

Posted

True. But that would require the DA to charge him with that.

You are off base in your interpretation of the law/s associated with assault. If you swing at someone you don't have to hit the person in order to qualify it as an assault. If the person you are involved with feels threatened then technically it qualifies as an assault.

 

https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/assault

 

I don't believe that McCoy is going to be charged. There is a good chance that no one will be charged in this case.

Posted

You are off base in your interpretation of the law/s associated with assault. If you swing at someone you don't have to hit the person in order to qualify it as an assault. If the person you are involved with feels threatened then technically it qualifies as an assault.

 

https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/assault

 

I don't believe that McCoy is going to be charged. There is a good chance that no one will be charged in this case.

After this long, I would be shocked if anyone is charged.

Posted

Goodie-dell is present. He is still counting his bonus. That is an awful lot of cash to count. He should be done by draft day so he can get booed again. He knows we love him.

Posted

Goodie-dell is present. He is still counting his bonus. That is an awful lot of cash to count. He should be done by draft day so he can get booed again. He knows we love him.

Doubtful that they pay him in cash. Its probably a wire transfer or an ACH.

Posted

True. But that would require the DA to charge him with that.

 

 

Charge him with intent to...what?

 

You don't need to "connect" on a punch to be charged with assault.

Posted (edited)

Charge him with intent to...what?

 

You don't need to "connect" on a punch to be charged with assault.

In this case, yeah, you would. If anyone were to get charged with assault in this case, it would be the cop. And probably the bottle-wielder. Edited by Doc
Posted

It's really starting to look like this entire thing is going to get swept under the rug. We're closing in on the month and a half anniversary of this thing and no ones been charged.

Posted

In this case, yeah, you would. If anyone were to get charged with assault in this case, it would be the cop. And probably the bottle-wielder.

 

 

Is the law different for this case? How so?

Posted

 

Episode 1: Heitz's cooler. It's in Pinto Kenny's pinto somewhere

Episode 2: Where does The Dean disappear to? North Korea

Episode 3: Why is Ed a horrible human being? Unanswerable

×
×
  • Create New...