Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

If he doesn't get charged at all would think it would be tough to warrant 4 games. Not arguing that he doesn't deserve it, but without much evidence likely would get appealed and reduced down to two??

 

Roger is in a tough spot, does he dole out smaller suspensions in hopes they don't get over turned, but then look soft or does he still go for big ones and watch them all get lowered. I suppose you can argue he's better to go high so after the appeal there is still something left of a punishment.

 

 

It looked pretty obvious he threw a punch from the video, so even if not indicted, he should get a 4 game suspension. That's four game checks. If he doesn't learn from that, he's an idiot.

  • Replies 795
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted Images

Posted

If he doesn't get charged at all would think it would be tough to warrant 4 games. Not arguing that he doesn't deserve it, but without much evidence likely would get appealed and reduced down to two??

 

Roger is in a tough spot, does he dole out smaller suspensions in hopes they don't get over turned, but then look soft or does he still go for big ones and watch them all get lowered. I suppose you can argue he's better to go high so after the appeal there is still something left of a punishment.

 

He can suspend him for domestic violence even without a charge. Look at Ray Rice.

Posted (edited)

 

He can suspend him for domestic violence even without a charge. Look at Ray Rice.

Rice was charged and indicted for aggravated assault before Rog did anything.

Edited by FireChan
Posted

Rice was charged and indicted for aggravated assault before Rog did anything.

Yeah. I misread "charged" as convicted.

Posted

and can you all remember how many Manziel fans insisted he was going to tear up the NFL and the rest of us were just morons and haters

Posted

and can you all remember how many Manziel fans insisted he was going to tear up the NFL and the rest of us were just morons and haters

Oh, so you knew he was an alcoholic, not a college kid having a good time and drinking a few pops but you're assessment was based on your diagnosis of alcoholism, got it. Where is your medical practice located?

Posted (edited)

Oh, so you knew he was an alcoholic, not a college kid having a good time and drinking a few pops but you're assessment was based on your diagnosis of alcoholism, got it. Where is your medical practice located?

 

 

LMAO.. .. are you serious.

 

LMFAO

 

how many smoking guns did he have during his college days.

Edited by ddaryl
Posted

and can you all remember how many Manziel fans insisted he was going to tear up the NFL and the rest of us were just morons and haters

 

I remember the Bulldeog on WGR saying (at the time) how he thought JM should be the #1 overall pick of the draft and that he was a franchise QB

 

 

Man Im glad he doesnt run the Bills lol

 

 

 

CBF

 

Dude had bust written all over him before he was even drafted. Beyond all of the character and behavior concerns, his game simply does not translate to any kind of sustained success at the NFL level.

Posted

 

 

his game simply does not translate to any kind of sustained success at the NFL level.

 

I agree I never thought even sober he was going to be much of an NFL QB... but his off field actions should of been plenty enough to keep any team form drafting him so early

Posted

Oh, so you knew he was an alcoholic, not a college kid having a good time and drinking a few pops but you're assessment was based on your diagnosis of alcoholism, got it. Where is your medical practice located?

yes we did.

Posted

and can you all remember how many Manziel fans insisted he was going to tear up the NFL and the rest of us were just morons and haters

I actually thought he had a chance after this past season. A few games he looked pretty dynamic and displayed better accuracy than I expected. The he started hitting the bottle again....

 

Oh, so you knew he was an alcoholic, not a college kid having a good time and drinking a few pops but you're assessment was based on your diagnosis of alcoholism, got it. Where is your medical practice located?

To me it seemed like he liked the spotlight more than football and that was concerning. I'm sure many successful QBs in college enjoyed having a few drinks, but I had never seen anyone on an inflatable swan before or possibly doing coke in a bathroom at a club.

 

I wouldn't have used a first rounder on him. Not a chance. Far too many red flags for me to spend that high a resource

Posted

Oh, so you knew he was an alcoholic, not a college kid having a good time and drinking a few pops but you're assessment was based on your diagnosis of alcoholism, got it. Where is your medical practice located?

No, but we all thought his attitude and playing ability would prevent him from succeeding in the NFL

Posted

Oh, so you knew he was an alcoholic, not a college kid having a good time and drinking a few pops but you're assessment was based on your diagnosis of alcoholism, got it. Where is your medical practice located?

 

People who thought Manziel wouldn't succeed didn't base this belief on an armchair diagnosis of alcoholism.

 

They based it on his running a very collegiate offense that might not transfer well to the pros and on scouting reports like this:

"The way we talked about him in meetings, the kid never put in the time he needed to -- studying film, organizing workouts, 7-on-7 workouts -- he didn't do it," said one NFC scout with a Southeastern Conference focus. "His thing would be he's going to show up on Saturdays, 'I'm a gamer.' He'd show up for practices and games but that's about it. Johnny thought he was an NFL superstar before he came [into the league]."

One A&M source said Manziel's attitude is catching up to him. Manziel was lax in preparation unless the Aggies were playing a top-tier opponent, such as Alabama or Auburn, when "you couldn't get him out of the film room," the source said. Against Rice or Sam Houston State, not so much."

 

QB who don't run a pro-style offense in college can succeed in the NFL, but it usually takes them time and a lot of effort. By all reports, Manziel wasn't willing to put in either in college, so why would one expect him to put in both after he's paid?

Posted

 

People who thought Manziel wouldn't succeed didn't base this belief on an armchair diagnosis of alcoholism.

 

They based it on his running a very collegiate offense that might not transfer well to the pros and on scouting reports like this:

"The way we talked about him in meetings, the kid never put in the time he needed to -- studying film, organizing workouts, 7-on-7 workouts -- he didn't do it," said one NFC scout with a Southeastern Conference focus. "His thing would be he's going to show up on Saturdays, 'I'm a gamer.' He'd show up for practices and games but that's about it. Johnny thought he was an NFL superstar before he came [into the league]."

One A&M source said Manziel's attitude is catching up to him. Manziel was lax in preparation unless the Aggies were playing a top-tier opponent, such as Alabama or Auburn, when "you couldn't get him out of the film room," the source said. Against Rice or Sam Houston State, not so much."

 

QB who don't run a pro-style offense in college can succeed in the NFL, but it usually takes them time and a lot of effort. By all reports, Manziel wasn't willing to put in either in college, so why would one expect him to put in both after he's paid?

 

well, those things, plus a number of incidents with alcohol involved even after it was clearly a hot button issue for his draft stock, so it was a concern that he would not be able to stop - or perhaps even escalate, as the fame grew and he had less structure around him.

Posted

His play is borderline NFL level his attitude and behaviour is way below that line.

 

He is what I thought he was.

 

Have you even seen him play? Wouldn't call it borderline NFL level at all. Borderline Canadien Football League level and right up there with Arena Football League level.

×
×
  • Create New...