Jump to content

Would you re-sign Harvin to $3m incentive laden contract?


Kelly the Dog

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 528
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

My point is though 8 games of Harvin and then 8 games of Salas/Boykin/Little/Thompson is better than 16 games of Salas/Boykin/Little/Thompson. There really is little to no downside if the contract is cheap.

 

A degenerative hip condition that has led to knee issues. There is certainly no guarantee that he'll return to being any semblance of the explosive player that we saw early in the 2015 season. Just call me a skeptic given the history of his career.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My point is though 8 games of Harvin and then 8 games of Salas/Boykin/Little/Thompson is better than 16 games of Salas/Boykin/Little/Thompson. There really is little to no downside if the contract is cheap.

Sure, but what you have above ignores the situation where the money that would be spent on Percy can do elsewhere to upgrade at WR. You may not find a guy as explosive as Harvin but you can find a more reliable option whom is an upgrade over the other guys you have listed. You sacrifice a little glitz and glam for some consistency on a week to week basis.

 

That is where this offense needs to improve the most.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

A degenerative hip condition that has led to knee issues. There is certainly no guarantee that he'll return to being any semblance of the explosive player that we saw early in the 2015 season. Just call me a skeptic given the history of his career.

They won't sign him then.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I know a lot are not on board with this but I really liked Salas

 

I mean...not number 1 option like him but he is not supposed to be?

Salas is fine but I'm not scared of his ability as a DC so I'm leaving him alone and am happy to let him beat me as I smother Sammy. He might make a few plays but most DCs are good with that because he's not taking over a game. He's stoppable.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sure, but what you have above ignores the situation where the money that would be spent on Percy can do elsewhere to upgrade at WR. You may not find a guy as explosive as Harvin but you can find a more reliable option whom is an upgrade over the other guys you have listed. You sacrifice a little glitz and glam for some consistency on a week to week basis.

 

That is where this offense needs to improve the most.

We are probably talking about $2M. It may be even less (Kerley was roughly $1.1M). Who are you going to find for that money that will do anything even close to what Harvin is capable of? That list of FA WR in his price range are not that appealing.

 

Yolo really hit the nail on the head. The threat of Harvin is what is most important to the offense. If they draft one early the need for Harvin goes down. I would still consider him at the right price.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I mentioned it before probably in this thread but Miami signed Jordan Cameron to a deal last year where he only got paid per games played. That could be an option, but what I believe is that another team would be ok with giving him more of a gtd contract.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Salas is fine but I'm not scared of his ability as a DC so I'm leaving him alone and am happy to let him beat me as I smother Sammy. He might make a few plays but most DCs are good with that because he's not taking over a game. He's stoppable.

 

In that respect--the only guy (besides Sammy) that really requires opposing DCs to adjust anything is Goodwin.

 

You simply can't play a normal 1-1 coverage on his side of the field and expect your standard boundary guy to keep up with him.

 

His injury issues really take away the team's ability to challenge defenses.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think I'm the only one who hopes he is back. Even if it's not a full time role. They can't pay him a lot so it certainly be on the cheap. Still draft one obviously but he's a good talent to have in the arsenal.

 

He's fast, versatile, experienced and had chemistry with Taylor right off the bat. Clearly injury prone which is why, if he is back, it would be cheap/incentive laden.

not the only. there are two of us !

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Very well done!

no no that was just awful..

 

Exactly. I couldn't care less about any contract he might get expensive or cheap. The real cost of Harvin is the roster spot. Might as well call it a 52 man roster if you sign him. Other potential receivers, although probably less talented, get pushed down a rung and we are less attractive a landing spot for other potential acquisitions. If we could somehow be guaranteed that he would stay healthy for say 14 of 16 games, we should probably sign him.

How many of the WRs Bills have now qualify for PS ?

Harvin goes down early is really my biggest fear, must have a plan in place. This is where i think drafting a 4th rd burner might be wise

 

Initially he was. But he became less effective and explosive as the season wore on.

you mean when he became injured ? twice

lol

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Really?

 

OK

I know a lot are not on board with this but I really liked Salas

 

I mean...not number 1 option like him but he is not supposed to be?

 

Why do you hold every player of the buffalo bills in such high regard ? Not all of them are irreplaceable.

 

Especially the bottom of the barrel guys you seem to pull for.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I agree

as usual, i do too.

 

Sammy, Woods, rookie, harvin, and 1-2 of the depth guys

 

especially if easley is PUP, we could turn around and have him fill harvins spot if harvin does disappoint on the health side.

If he's paid literally the league minimum - with the chance to earn more based on performance.... i would CONSIDER it. Having said that - he brings in some drama and only likely plays what 4 or 5 games?

 

Whats the point?

in 7 years hes played 9 or more 5 times, and 13+ 4 times.

 

his ACL injury, and last year are the only times hes generally missed whole seasons

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...