Jump to content

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 335
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted

The only part of his critique offered in the piece that I question is the "aging and unathletic" line. The OL actually moves pretty well and most of the guys are relatively young with the notable exception of Incognitio. The right side of the line is in need of upgrades obviously.

Agreed, I edited to add that on the OLine. This is just roster talk. I'd love to hear what he says about coaching and front office. Especially coaching!

Posted

He left us for Carolina, then went to Indy to work for a madman. Don't know if we want his "help??"

Stop writing revisionist history. He never left he was fired by Wilson, mainly for saying Wilson's daughter shouldn't be a scout for the team.

Posted (edited)

The only two guys on the OL who are "aging" are wood and incognito. They are pretty good IMO and not what needs fixed (RG, RT - both really young). Struck me as odd.

 

Btw Polian and Carucci are close friends so that's how he got the interview, I respect Polian's work but he's not coming back to consult in any real "role" - he is done working for any team. That's not my opinion, that is something I know.

Edited by YoloinOhio
Posted

He left us for Carolina, then went to Indy to work for a madman. Don't know if we want his "help??"

You're very wrong... He didn't leave. He was canned by Ralph.

Posted

Agreed, I edited to add that on the OLine. This is just roster talk. I'd love to hear what he says about coaching and front office. Especially coaching!

 

He pretty much did later in the article.

 

And what of the many problems with players struggling to learn or flat-out rejecting Ryan’s defensive scheme?

 

His answer will no doubt be music to the ears of Mario Williams, Jerry Hughes, Marcell Dareus, Preston Brown, and other players who have openly questioned the defense’s fit for those who have to play it.

 

“You need veterans to make that defense work,” Polian said. “First of all, the players thrived in another system – in a simple, straight forward, very easy to understand, very easy to communicate system where there was constant repetition of the same thing, over and over again, taught in a very straight-forward way.

 

And the techniques were geared toward what the players could do, what their skill sets were, and the plans were constructed around the players and what they could do.

 

Posted

Wood was terrible over the past two years. It's blatant. He's gotta go.

 

Doug Moron's coaching will do that. He looks like a different player this season.

@TyDunne

Polian wants to be a consultant, yet is very critical of Doug Whaley, Rex Ryan and the team personnel in place. Outta be interesting.

Posted

I'm down for whatever helps. Yeah we constantly do revisit the past but he's a great talent evaluator and he knows personnel. I like Whaley though he's a good GM.

Posted

Agreed with being critical of Rex, but personnel? Not so much

 

He did by saying too many 30+ year old guys and only one pro bowler. Also was critical of Clay's and Shady's price tag. All shots at personnel and Whaley IMO.

Posted

The only two guys on the OL who are "aging" are wood and incognito. They are pretty good IMO and not what needs fixed (RG, RT - both really young). Struck me as odd.

 

Btw Polian and Carucci are close friends so that's how he got the interview, I respect Polian's work but he's not coming back to consult in any real "role" - he is done working for any team. That's not my opinion, that is something I know.

And urbik if he's a starter. So either 40% or 60%, which isn't crazy to note

Posted (edited)

And urbik if he's a starter. So either 40% or 60%, which isn't crazy to note

he isn't a starter though. Not saying he's not knowledgeable but that part didn't click for me. Edited by YoloinOhio
Posted

Yea he criticized the offense which I found puzzling.

 

The defense has been the biggest disappointment as we all know.

Likewise where we saw the references from the Whaley rumors last week

Posted

All playoff teams! Veteran leadership needed.

 

@mikerodak

Mike Rodak Retweeted Vic Carucci

Polian notes how BUF has 9 players who are 30+ and how that could lead NFL, but NE, CIN, AZ, DEN have just as many.

so it's a good thing? Or a bad thing?
×
×
  • Create New...