Jump to content

FanDuel and DraftKings Banned in NYS


CountDorkula

Daily Fantasy Sites  

199 members have voted

  1. 1. Did/Do you use FanDuel or DrafKings?

    • Yes
      56
    • No
      143
  2. 2. Should Daily Fantasy sports sites such as DraftKings or FanDuel be legal?

    • Yes
      113
    • No
      86


Recommended Posts

 

And that's why the better analogy is to investing and not to gambling. The skilled pros who have access to vastly more and better information will clean the amateurs' clocks 99% of the time. Doesn't mean that the amateur can't hit the right score once in a while.

 

It's no secret that daily fantasy is employing the same marketing gambits that the lotteries and investment houses do. Hey, you never know. But that's a whole different argument of whether the fantasy leagues are games of skill or games of luck.

 

Let's not forget that NYS in its inimitable wisdom held that pinball machines were a form of gambling.

 

I'd go with that. That is why I say NYS has ulterior motives for banning it rather than it simply being technically "gambling" and not liking it. There is a reason they are avoiding season long fantasy, and that difference is the large transfer of money happening weekly with daily fantasy. We are talking about a ton of money. Some people have been saying it's NYS supporting the brick and mortar gambling ventures like the lottery, and casinos, but I don't buy that,

Edited by What a Tuel
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 250
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

There have been some reports that some paid shrills for Draftkings have been posting on social media how much money they earned but this is more likely just boasting with some stretching of the truth.

 

Hey now, I particiapte in FanDuel and am up $2.50 in the last two weeks. You just have to be smart!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

I'd go with that. That is why I say NYS has ulterior motives for banning it rather than it simply being technically "gambling" and not liking it. There is a reason they are avoiding season long fantasy, and that difference is the large transfer of money happening weekly with daily fantasy. We are talking about a ton of money. Some people have been saying it's NYS supporting the brick and mortar gambling ventures like the lottery, and casinos, but I don't buy that,

It's nothing more than a money grab by. NYS.

Edited by GG
Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

How so? What do they gain financially by banning it?

 

Currently winners still need to claim their winnings as income for tax purposes. (They are supposed to anyway.)

Banning them is the first step in the negotiations. If the sites are deemed gambling, then NYS gets to let them operate as a gambling entity and extract the fees.

 

This had nothing to do with consumer protection from a state that takes in hundreds of millions in lottery tickets from low income people.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The hypocrisy is what kills me. NYS is saying it's gambling and gambling is illegal. Oh really? Then what's with the NY lottery and the dumb scratch off tickets I get from relatives on my birthday? How about OTB and casinos? Makes no sense. I feel like I'm taking crazy pills. They must think we are pretty stupid

It is only illegal if they don't pay some money to NYS.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Banning them is the first step in the negotiations. If the sites are deemed gambling, then NYS gets to let them operate as a gambling entity and extract the fees.

 

This had nothing to do with consumer protection from a state that takes in hundreds of millions in lottery tickets from low income people.

 

Then why is Online Poker not legal still?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

Then why is Online Poker not legal still?

Several reasons I guess and very few are logical. It's associated with gambling and there isn't one big entity that's fighting to make it legal. Plus many poker sites are run by offshore illicit groups, so there's that organized crime element.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Banning them is the first step in the negotiations. If the sites are deemed gambling, then NYS gets to let them operate as a gambling entity and extract the fees.

 

This had nothing to do with consumer protection from a state that takes in hundreds of millions in lottery tickets from low income people.

Just playing devils advocate... Aren't lottery odds clearly spelled out, albeit in fine print?

 

DFS advertising average expenditures of around $6 and average winnings around $20 (again, fine print at the bottom of ads) is pretty misleading.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Several reasons I guess and very few are logical. It's associated with gambling and there isn't one big entity that's fighting to make it legal. Plus many poker sites are run by offshore illicit groups, so there's that organized crime element.

 

If NY won the courts consideration of banning DFS, I do not believe NYS would then pass a law saying it was legal if they pay them more money. I don't believe they will win this first round though, so I believe they will negotiate a way to take these companies down a notch and regulate the industry. That is still only by failing to ban it though, IMO.

Edited by What a Tuel
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The vast majority of non-DFS people struggle with the idea that DFS isnt simply ONE contest, rather, that a DFS player views his play as a series of many different 1-day contests.

To the non-DFS people, DFS is a 1-day contest, and season-long is a season long contest. From that aspect, if your guy gets hurt in a 1-day contest, your team is probably done, whereas if your guy gets hurt in season-long, you can try to adjust somehow. They dont grasp the concept that DFS is 17 weeks of 1-week contests (for NFL, just to use them as the example), so if your main guy is hurt for the first week, you may lose Week 1, but you still have Weeks 2-17 to end up a winner.

This of course also requires bankroll management, a key skill in DFS.

I know people dont always like to hear the DFS vs Poker comparision, but in this light, poker has the same problem. Its very tough to get non-poker players to understand the skill in poker isnt limited to 1 hand. Yes, in any ONE HAND of No Limit Hold Em, the results are incredibly luck-depedent. But NLHE success is not about any one hand, its about winning the most money when your dealt favorable cards, and losing the least money when youre dealt unfavorable cards.

How do we get people to understand this concept? I dont really know. Poker has struggled for years to get people to understand the idea, and DFS will have the same problems. The focus is always on ONE contest. All the morons out there focus on comparing ONE weeks worth of DFS to season-long, as opposed to 17 weeks worth of DFS to season-long. I havent the foggiest idea how to reframe the discussion, but successfully reframing the discussion would go a LONG way to helping DFS long-term health.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

I for one look forward to this judgement being dismantled here by a suspiciously verbose, unbroken wall of text.

 

Take one drink for each use of the words "daily" and "skill". Two drinks for each reference to some federal law that has nothing to do with the State of NY.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

DraftKings, FanDuel granted emergency stay to continue in N.Y.

http://espn.go.com/chalk/story/_/id/14344676/appeals-court-grants-stay-allowing-draftkings-fanduel-continue-operating-new-york

 

 


DraftKings has stayed open in New York throughout the challenges made by the attorney general. FanDuel, which pulled itself out of the New York market on Nov. 17, will allow fans to once again play on its site starting Friday night, said spokeswoman Justine Sacco.

Friday's ruling does not negate the interpretation made by Mendez that DraftKings and FanDuel were illegally operating within the state. Mendez agreed with Schneiderman's contention that the companies are operating illegal gambling sites based on how New York law defines gambling.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...