Jump to content

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 172
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted

Look, when a team has an elite QB on their team, the coach and GM always look good. An elite QB covers up poor defensive play and a lot of sub-par skill players as the QB can overcome this. Then the team wins and everybody thinks the GM is a genius. If Aaron Rodgers weren't the QB and you were judging this man solely on the other areas of the Packers, you likely wouldn't be impressed.

Posted

Look, when a team has an elite QB on their team, the coach and GM always look good. An elite QB covers up poor defensive play and a lot of sub-par skill players as the QB can overcome this. Then the team wins and everybody thinks the GM is a genius. If Aaron Rodgers weren't the QB and you were judging this man solely on the other areas of the Packers, you likely wouldn't be impressed.

But when you are using 18% of the salary cap on the QB, its a bigger challenge to fill out the rest of the roster.

Posted

He scouted/evaluated every player for the packers for the last 12 years.

 

Eliot Wolfs scouting has comprised over 80% of the Packers current roster in 2015.

 

That is simply amazing!!!

The guy may have had a major impact on all those drafts in presenting all the right players. However it was still GM Ted Thompson made those choices, and not the director of player personnel.

 

This team is lacking that knowledgeable football person at the top of the flow chart before another new GM. JMO

Posted (edited)

Wrong Wolf.

 

It's going to take Winston Wolfe to clean up this mess.

 

That is priceless! Nice name drop.

The guy may have had a major impact on all those drafts in presenting all the right players. However it was still GM Ted Thompson made those choices, and not the director of player personnel.

 

This team is lacking that knowledgeable football person at the top of the flow chart before another new GM. JMO

 

Oh I understand that. It takes two to tango like Doug Whaley putting a 1st round grade on EJ Manuel then Buddy Nix selecting him.

Edited by BuffaloBillsForever
Posted

I hope they re-sign Doug Whaley for 40 years.

Yea, the team needs to keep drafting fragile WR's with two first rounders while they keep hoping a 6th rounder will be the franchise QB.

Posted (edited)

There is zero chance of a new GM and rightfully so

You couldn't me more wrong.

 

Pegula was looking to hire a football "czar" while Whaley was under contract last offseason. Rex was Pegulas pet hiring.

 

Whaley is done.

Edited by BuffaloBillsForever
Posted

You couldn't me more wrong.

 

Pegula was looking to hire a football "czar" while Whaley was under contract last offseason. Rex was Pegulas pet hiring.

 

Whaley is done.

Not a chance

Posted

He's done too well with personnel overall. Not just the draft but who to let go, who to keep. He's quite a good young GM.

Injuries and drafts with no quality qb's are not the fault of any GM.

Posted

Look, when a team has an elite QB on their team, the coach and GM always look good. An elite QB covers up poor defensive play and a lot of sub-par skill players as the QB can overcome this. Then the team wins and everybody thinks the GM is a genius. If Aaron Rodgers weren't the QB and you were judging this man solely on the other areas of the Packers, you likely wouldn't be impressed.

 

and Not getting a QB is all on Whalenix

Posted (edited)

He's done too well with personnel overall. Not just the draft but who to let go, who to keep. He's quite a good young GM.

Injuries and drafts with no quality qb's are not the fault of any GM.

I would strongly disagree.

 

Can you name a single player that Doug Whaley drafted that is a pro bowler?

 

Also overpaying for FA talent is horrible GM'ing IMO. Clay, McCoy, Felton just to name a few. Well technically McCoy wasn't a FA but giving up assets too makes it even worse.

Edited by BuffaloBillsForever
Posted

Wrong Wolf.

 

It's going to take Winston Wolfe to clean up this mess.

 

who?

 

 

Oh I understand that. It takes two to tango like Doug Whaley putting a 1st round grade on EJ Manuel then Buddy Nix selecting him.

 

:lol::lol:

Yea, the team needs to keep drafting fragile WR's with two first rounders while they keep hoping a 6th rounder will be the franchise QB.

 

:worthy:

×
×
  • Create New...