Jump to content

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 105
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted

It's a call made because at speed it looks different than in replay. I can't fault the call, as the NFL is trying to make sure defenders don't hurt receivers. What really needs to be done is allow a booth ref to quickly review and potentially overturn close calls like that.

Posted

What is sad is that Walt Anderson had a perfect view of both, and screwed them both up in real time by throwing a flag. Not a hard call-- I saw jersey grabs in real time.

its the yanking that's the issue when unnecessary. never do that to a QB!

Posted

The League reviews personal foul calls during the week and issues fines for blatent fouls

 

The League should also review all penalties called during the week and fine Refs for seriously blown calls like this one

The refs are reviewed weekly and graded by the league. I get pissed at them, too, but I don't think fining them is appropriate, either. As much as I'd like to.

 

GO BILLS!!!

Posted

Hey, speaking of this call, though, did you guys notice how mad the D played after that, but didn't lose their discipline? They hit hard and made the stops. Totally different unit compared to earlier that game. I like how they responded, but wish they would look like that more of the game.

Posted

It's a call made because at speed it looks different than in replay. I can't fault the call, as the NFL is trying to make sure defenders don't hurt receivers. What really needs to be done is allow a booth ref to quickly review and potentially overturn close calls like that

 

Then react accordingly and throw the flag inmediately, not a good 5' after the play.

Posted

Throwing Tennessee a bone, I can only assume. Maybe in real time they thought Graham hit him in the head?

Gonna have to add new rules like college. Targeting calls are reviewed and reversed sometimes. No way these zebras can see impact point in real time in every situation

Posted

Also, I don't think either QB "horsecollar" was an actual horse collar tackle. So the Corey hit, and the Tyrod horse collar effectively offset. But, the call against us was a bigger deal due to context.

Posted

The League reviews personal foul calls during the week and issues fines for blatent fouls

 

The League should also review all penalties called during the week and fine Refs for seriously blown calls like this one

They are all reviewed and all refs are graded on their calls and non- calls. Bad grades will only keep them out of officiating in the playoffs though. They should have some financial penalty though. Maybe have them sit for a game and lose the game check and per diem.
Posted (edited)

 

You must have lost your script

No I truly did pay attention this time. I Like Tyrod. They took awhile to get warmed up, but by the end of the game I felt is was a fair enough scrum.

Edited by 3rdand12
Posted

Bradham didn't get the QB's legs with his body like they did to Taylor. Not saying that makes a difference if it is all about where the hand is on the collar but it certainly makes the injury risk different.

Posted

Which call are we complaining about? The Graham penalty was total BS. He defended the pass, and hit him with his shoulder. Clean hit.

 

The call on Tyrod....he already had the first down, but Tennessee deserved something, either for the horse collar or the late hit. The one on Bradham, he had him by the lower half of his jersey.

 

I hated the pass interference on Gilmore too. But I'm certainly glad we won.

Posted

Which call are we complaining about? The Graham penalty was total BS. He defended the pass, and hit him with his shoulder. Clean hit.

 

The call on Tyrod....he already had the first down, but Tennessee deserved something, either for the horse collar or the late hit. The one on Bradham, he had him by the lower half of his jersey.

 

I hated the pass interference on Gilmore too. But I'm certainly glad we won.

i was complaining about the unnecessary roughness on Graham. The Dpi on Gilmore also bad. Grrrrr
×
×
  • Create New...