Whaley's Performance

[The Real Buffalo Joe]

Want to see how many people's opinion has changed.

[Gugny]

Where's the A+ option?

[ricojes]

Most excitement for the upcoming season in recent history, so I can only give A's at this point...

[Big C]

A's for both. Brought on some big time talent, drafted well so far, it seems. i think bringing in Tyrod and Cassel (especially after the cut and re-sign and especially especially if tyrod pans out) was about as good as it could get. Was not into Hoyer, Mallett, McCown, etc. The price for Foles/Bradford was too much and I think both don't have a track record to place such value on them. The swap of the two was fair. But of course we will have to see how this season actually plays out.

[BLizzyMeock]

He gets B's until we make the playoffs

[White Linen]

Whoever voted C or below is a complete psycho.

[LeGOATski]

A for building the most talented team we've had since the turn of the century.

 

GMs can only build the team. The coaches have to get them to the playoffs.

[Gugny]

Whoever voted C or below is a complete psycho.

 

Who voted for: C

jahnyc, negativo, CodeMonkey

[bobobonators]

I gave him two A's. This team is stocked w talent. If EJ had been able to live up to his end of the bargain a bit more this team could've made the playoffs last season already.

[negativo]

Who voted for: C

jahnyc, negativo, CodeMonkey

 

You got at least one right. I'm impressed with your great psychic powers. I felt a D or F was too negative, and A or B too positive. Jury is still out on Whaley.

[K D]

if Tyrod ends up being good then who gets the credit? I've heard it was Rex's guy but Whaley went out and got him to sign and Roman and Lee coached him up

[BuffaloHokie13]

if Tyrod ends up being good then who gets the credit? I've heard it was Rex's guy but Whaley went out and got him to sign and Roman and Lee coached him up

Ozzie Newsome

Edited September 9, 2015 by BuffaloHokie13

[negativo]

if Tyrod ends up being good then who gets the credit? I've heard it was Rex's guy but Whaley went out and got him to sign and Roman and Lee coached him up

 

Whaley would never have signed Tyrod if not for Rex.

[Whites Bay]

I think he's done a very good job. I guess I'm wondering how many Doug Whaley report card polls we're going to do this week.

 

Pre-season is almost over. Thank God.

[3rdand12]

Whoever voted C or below is a complete psycho.

what what what. what?

 

I did not vote. i think Whaley is a nut bucket. but he is ours.

if nothing, he is an interesting GM.

Who voted for: C

jahnyc, negativo, CodeMonkey

Profiling are we? dangerous territory to tread, wouldn't you consider?

 

You got at least one right. I'm impressed with your great psychic powers. I felt a D or F was too negative, and A or B too positive. Jury is still out on Whaley.

agreed.

But it sure is fun to watch!

Ozzie Newsome

great retort 13 !!

[BringBackOrton]

Whoever voted C or below is a complete psycho.

 

I voted C. C is average. We have been average since he's been here. Until we take the next step with the 53 he stocks the cupboard with, the letter grade stays the same.

[DrDawkinstein]

Im a big Whaley fan, and I gave him two Bs and an Increased. It's great to have an aggressive GM with a vision and plan, working with a coach he helped pick. We have a great team on paper, I think he's leveraged resources well to increase talent, but we need to see it all come together on the field before I can give an A.

[jr1]

[PromoTheRobot]

 

I voted C. C is average. We have been average since he's been here. Until we take the next step with the 53 he stocks the cupboard with, the letter grade stays the same.

If the Jets, Pats or Fins had our roster, would it be an A+.

Edited September 9, 2015 by PromoTheRobot

[FireChan]

If the Jets, Pats or Fins had our roster, would it be an A+.

You know the GM is responsible for more than "talent on paper" right?