Rubes Posted June 12, 2015 Posted June 12, 2015 personally, I have been told I have the best practice swing of any golfer anyone has ever seen, but once the ball is in front of my club all bets are off, and I'm lucky not to kill anyone withing 200 yard of my shot immediately to my right. I think this is what we are seeing... a great practice performance. Man, I can completely relate to that. I'd go so far as to say most objects within 200 yards on either side aren't safe. Especially houses.
hondo in seattle Posted June 12, 2015 Posted June 12, 2015 WAY TOO EARLY to say anyone is beating out anyone.
TSOL Posted June 12, 2015 Posted June 12, 2015 As an big supporter of EJ for the last three years, if he DOSENT win the job, I don't know, I'm done with him. And if he does win the job, how many games, or quarters, does he get before the pitchforks come out?
PromoTheRobot Posted June 12, 2015 Posted June 12, 2015 First, you have to stop posting 'stories" from the Buffalo Sun Sentinel. All it is one guy rewriting other people's stuff. In this case he is making news out of the Bills recently released depth chart that shows EJ as #1 QB. From that the BSS guy is making the leap that EJ is out-playing everyone.
Solomon Grundy Posted June 12, 2015 Posted June 12, 2015 I don't really think you can blame a QBs development entirely on the coaching staff. Was Dan Marino's QB coach a superstar? Was Elway, Manning or Jim Kelly's QB coaches really what made them successful? Or even more, was Marv Levy, or Tony Dungy what made them winners? How about this thought: Maybe...... juuuuuust maybe EJ really isn't that good, and we whiffed on the pick. Maybe he is exactly what he appears to be, a great, intelligent, hard working guy that just can't handle the speed of the game once he's on the field. I can't see how Marrone did that to him when you watch some game film from FSU, read the breakdown of his game, and the pre-draft analysts analysis and tell me those things don't read like a post game analysis of any game he played in for the Bills. I would love to see him prove all of that wrong, I like the guy, he seems like the perfect fit to be a franchise guy on size and maturity alone, but I'd also like to win the lottery and I don't see either happening. personally, I have been told I have the best practice swing of any golfer anyone has ever seen, but once the ball is in front of my club all bets are off, and I'm lucky not to kill anyone withing 200 yard of my shot immediately to my right. I think this is what we are seeing... a great practice performance. Tom Martinez helped mentor Elway and Tom Brady David Cutcliffe helped mentor the Manning brothers. They also had a former NFL QB as a father Mouse Davis and Ted Marchibroda helped Kelly's development I bet they would give them credit for making them the players they were/are. So yes you can blame a QBs development on a coaching staff. Drew Brees wasn't any good until he hooked up with Sean Payton. Brett Favre wasn't considered good until he got to GB. Do we think the "BAAD MAN" would be giving discount double checks had he not been developed by GB. Joe Flacco development happened right before our eyes in Baltimore. Many thought he was a BUST after his first couple seasons. Manuel was supposed to develop here in Buffalo, but a mat altered that plan.
Big C Posted June 12, 2015 Posted June 12, 2015 I don't really think you can blame a QBs development entirely on the coaching staff. Was Dan Marino's QB coach a superstar? Was Elway, Manning or Jim Kelly's QB coaches really what made them successful? Or even more, was Marv Levy, or Tony Dungy what made them winners? How about this thought: Maybe...... juuuuuust maybe EJ really isn't that good, and we whiffed on the pick. Maybe he is exactly what he appears to be, a great, intelligent, hard working guy that just can't handle the speed of the game once he's on the field. I can't see how Marrone did that to him when you watch some game film from FSU, read the breakdown of his game, and the pre-draft analysts analysis and tell me those things don't read like a post game analysis of any game he played in for the Bills. Well, we will definitely know after this camp/season whether or not it was really the coaches.
Canadian Bills Fan Posted June 12, 2015 Posted June 12, 2015 The real test will be TC but more importantly the preseason games CBF
chris heff Posted June 12, 2015 Posted June 12, 2015 Here's a good one - EJ was Screwed From the Start: http://www.sportsgrid.com/nfl/e-j-manuel-was-screwed-from-the-start/ Kind of conveniently ignores any reports that he's not a total dumpster fire in OTAs thus-far or that we have a Greg Roman led Offensive staff. o_O And apparently still screwed because of Rex. It seems to me that they have now done everything to help Manuel become successful, by adding both coaches and players.
bonechiller Posted June 12, 2015 Posted June 12, 2015 I don't really think you can blame a QBs development entirely on the coaching staff. Was Dan Marino's QB coach a superstar? Was Elway, Manning or Jim Kelly's QB coaches really what made them successful? Or even more, was Marv Levy, or Tony Dungy what made them winners? How about this thought: Maybe...... juuuuuust maybe EJ really isn't that good, and we whiffed on the pick. Maybe he is exactly what he appears to be, a great, intelligent, hard working guy that just can't handle the speed of the game once he's on the field. I can't see how Marrone did that to him when you watch some game film from FSU, read the breakdown of his game, and the pre-draft analysts analysis and tell me those things don't read like a post game analysis of any game he played in for the Bills. I would love to see him prove all of that wrong, I like the guy, he seems like the perfect fit to be a franchise guy on size and maturity alone, but I'd also like to win the lottery and I don't see either happening. personally, I have been told I have the best practice swing of any golfer anyone has ever seen, but once the ball is in front of my club all bets are off, and I'm lucky not to kill anyone withing 200 yard of my shot immediately to my right. I think this is what we are seeing... a great practice performance. Sooo, you are saying he are who we thought he are? Well, crown him then.
K D Posted June 12, 2015 Posted June 12, 2015 I want EJ to step up and win the job but not win by default because the other guys are so bad
John from Riverside Posted June 12, 2015 Posted June 12, 2015 What would be interesting here is if the bills Start EJ Manuel Move Tyrod Taylor to backup Cut Cassell Not saying that is gonna happen........but it still accomplishes what I wanted from this QB process.......a starting QB with upside and a veteran backup (Which Taylor is from his 4 years backing up in Baltimore)
BuffaloMatt Posted June 12, 2015 Posted June 12, 2015 I don't really think you can blame a QBs development entirely on the coaching staff. Was Dan Marino's QB coach a superstar? Was Elway, Manning or Jim Kelly's QB coaches really what made them successful? Or even more, was Marv Levy, or Tony Dungy what made them winners? How about this thought: Maybe...... juuuuuust maybe EJ really isn't that good, and we whiffed on the pick. Maybe he is exactly what he appears to be, a great, intelligent, hard working guy that just can't handle the speed of the game once he's on the field. I can't see how Marrone did that to him when you watch some game film from FSU, read the breakdown of his game, and the pre-draft analysts analysis and tell me those things don't read like a post game analysis of any game he played in for the Bills. I would love to see him prove all of that wrong, I like the guy, he seems like the perfect fit to be a franchise guy on size and maturity alone, but I'd also like to win the lottery and I don't see either happening. personally, I have been told I have the best practice swing of any golfer anyone has ever seen, but once the ball is in front of my club all bets are off, and I'm lucky not to kill anyone withing 200 yard of my shot immediately to my right. I think this is what we are seeing... a great practice performance. I think you nailed it right on the head. Unfortunately so. . . .
BuffaloBillsMagic1 Posted June 12, 2015 Posted June 12, 2015 Has anyone ever seen EJ fire the ball on a line in a tight space 15 to 25 yards down the field ever? to me he just lobs the ball and hope it gets ther.
Augie Posted June 12, 2015 Posted June 12, 2015 Man, I can completely relate to that. I'd go so far as to say most objects within 200 yards on either side aren't safe. Especially houses. This is a good analogy. EJ almost killed some people last year, too.
BillsFan-4-Ever Posted June 12, 2015 Posted June 12, 2015 First, you have to stop posting 'stories" from the Buffalo Sun Sentinel. All it is one guy rewriting other people's stuff. In this case he is making news out of the Bills recently released depth chart that shows EJ as #1 QB. From that the BSS guy is making the leap that EJ is out-playing everyone. why? its a report from some sports person (who probably pulled something from the AP). If the story said EJ sucked how would you feel?
John from Riverside Posted June 12, 2015 Posted June 12, 2015 I think you nailed it right on the head. Unfortunately so. . . . I think its way out of whack Last year EJ was HORRIBLE at this time......this year he is ahead of the pack (and no matter how much the media will put "meh" on that....the fact is he does not look like his is lost the way he did last year at this time. There IS something to be said from showing progression in practice from one year to the next like EJ has done. But Its not over yet.....the two QBs he is in competion with are new....which means the scope of play could entirely change......I just dont think that EJ showing progression from last year at this time should be dismissed.
The Wiz Posted June 12, 2015 Posted June 12, 2015 Has anyone ever seen EJ fire the ball on a line in a tight space 15 to 25 yards down the field ever? to me he just lobs the ball and hope it gets ther.Watch the end of this 2 minute drill.
John from Riverside Posted June 12, 2015 Posted June 12, 2015 Watch the end of this 2 minute drill. No....he tries to "point" the ball too much
Recommended Posts