Big Gun Posted September 23, 2014 Posted September 23, 2014 You absolutely do draft projects in the 1st round and it happens all the time. OMG....is this really a retort? And you cant throw out prior QBs in EJ's face......especially ones that we had no shot at. Every situation is different. Over the past dozen or so years, name some of them?
The_Dude Posted September 23, 2014 Posted September 23, 2014 You absolutely do draft projects in the 1st round and it happens all the time. OMG....is this really a retort? And you cant throw out prior QBs in EJ's face......especially ones that we had no shot at. Every situation is different. GMs that draft project QBs that are regarded as mid round talent in the first round get fired. You DONT do it. If you want to insist upon it's sound reason then that says all sorts of things about you. John, I get it. I want our QB woes to be over too. But they're not!
RuntheDamnBall Posted September 23, 2014 Posted September 23, 2014 And to the 'EJ was a project' bs...you DONT draft projects in the first round. Never. Aaron Rodgers says hi. Drew Brees missed the bus, barely, but is also present.
FireChan Posted September 23, 2014 Posted September 23, 2014 (edited) Aaron Rodgers says hi. Drew Brees missed the bus, barely, but is also present. If there's a guy I like to bet the farm on, it's the guy whose position has only produced 2 successful QB's in 20+ years. The last successful first round project was almost 10 years ago. Let's celebrate! Edited September 23, 2014 by FireChan
John from Riverside Posted September 23, 2014 Posted September 23, 2014 GMs that draft project QBs that are regarded as mid round talent in the first round get fired. You DONT do it. If you want to insist upon it's sound reason then that says all sorts of things about you. John, I get it. I want our QB woes to be over too. But they're not! Dude....they do tend to get drafted later in the first round I will grant you that.....I absolutely thought Aaron Rogers was a developmental QB. Lets keep in mind here that Kolb was here that first year and got hurt. My stance is that Kolb was supposed to be the starter last year and it didnt work out....but that train has left the station. QB woes wont go away by starting a backup QB and sit the 1st round pick when the team is 2-1.....that is the definition of insane. And yes I do think Orton is a decent QB.....but you just dont do that.
Captain Hindsight Posted September 23, 2014 Posted September 23, 2014 Highly likely. Which still puzzles me why Whaley didn't take a flyer on Murray or Mettenberger this year. Because at the time Thad Lewis appeared to be a competent backup
Deranged Rhino Posted September 23, 2014 Posted September 23, 2014 (edited) Because at the time Thad Lewis appeared to be a competent backup Which, undoubtedly, has been Whaley's largest (and perhaps only) misstep to date as GM. Edited September 23, 2014 by GreggyT
26CornerBlitz Posted September 23, 2014 Posted September 23, 2014 Which, undoubtedly, has been Whaley's largest (and perhaps only) misstep to date as GM. The LG and CB situations last season were missteps.
K-9 Posted September 23, 2014 Posted September 23, 2014 Aaron Rodgers says hi. Drew Brees missed the bus, barely, but is also present. I sense a moving of the goalposts in response to this post. GO BILLS!!!
John from Riverside Posted September 23, 2014 Posted September 23, 2014 Which, undoubtedly, has been Whaley's largest (and perhaps only) misstep to date as GM. To be fair....if we based it off last years performance I think we ALL thought we had a backup QB in Thad
Deranged Rhino Posted September 23, 2014 Posted September 23, 2014 The LG and CB situations last season were missteps. You could argue the G situation is still a problem (and be awarded a medal for being obvious), so you're probably correct. But it's tough to overturn an entire roster in one season, so I tend to give Whaley a pass for the crime that was Justin Rogers.
Captain Hindsight Posted September 23, 2014 Posted September 23, 2014 The LG and CB situations last season were missteps. I wouldn't say that. Its really difficult to plan losing you top 3 corners Brooks, Mcloving and Gilmore all suffered injuries within a week. Not sure what Whaley could do there
Deranged Rhino Posted September 23, 2014 Posted September 23, 2014 To be fair....if we based it off last years performance I think we ALL thought we had a backup QB in Thad It's a fair point, though I'm not sure it was as universal as it seemed then. I was never impressed with Tuel or Thad whenever I saw them live. Neither one inspired much confidence and had the Bills been in a true playoff hunt last year instead of circling the drain, I think their deficiencies would have been harped on more.
26CornerBlitz Posted September 23, 2014 Posted September 23, 2014 You could argue the G situation is still a problem (and be awarded a medal for being obvious), so you're probably correct. But it's tough to overturn an entire roster in one season, so I tend to give Whaley a pass for the crime that was Justin Rogers. I wouldn't say that. Its really difficult to plan losing you top 3 corners Brooks, Mcloving and Gilmore all suffered injuries within a week. Not sure what Whaley could do there Fair points Gents.
GG Posted September 23, 2014 Posted September 23, 2014 Aaron Rodgers says hi. Drew Brees missed the bus, barely, but is also present. Those are isolated cases, and in no way support history & odds. If you look at the draft over the last 20 years' of first round QBs, the odds of success for a QB picked outside top 10 drop dramatically (and get worse outside top 12). If a team didn't have a top 10 pick, they had nearly equal odds of getting a staring caliber QB in the second round than they did in latter half of 1st round. That's why it's not common for teams to pick a project in the first round, because the smart ones know you can fish for a project later on.
Garranimal Posted September 23, 2014 Posted September 23, 2014 EJ sucks, nothing will ever change that. the reason it was windy on Sunday is because EJ sucks. No, that would be because he blows!
John from Riverside Posted September 23, 2014 Posted September 23, 2014 Those are isolated cases, and in no way support history & odds. If you look at the draft over the last 20 years' of first round QBs, the odds of success for a QB picked outside top 10 drop dramatically (and get worse outside top 12). If a team didn't have a top 10 pick, they had nearly equal odds of getting a staring caliber QB in the second round than they did in latter half of 1st round. That's why it's not common for teams to pick a project in the first round, because the smart ones know you can fish for a project later on. Oh for christ sake.....WE DID NOT HAVE DRAFT POSITION TO TAKE ANY OF THE TOP QBS
GG Posted September 23, 2014 Posted September 23, 2014 To be fair....if we based it off last years performance I think we ALL thought we had a backup QB in Thad I think you're exaggerating ALL, a little bit. I think there was a pleasant surprise at some of his throws, but rest assured not EVERYBODY was happy that he came into camp as the incumbent back up, with Tuel & Dixon in tow. Oh for christ sake.....WE DID NOT HAVE DRAFT POSITION TO TAKE ANY OF THE TOP QBS Oh for Heavens sake, get the point. If you don't have the draft position to take a top QB, then you shouldn't reach for a project late in round one. If they want to preach analytics, they should have learned the basic statistics of success rates of late first round QBs.
RuntheDamnBall Posted September 23, 2014 Posted September 23, 2014 Those are isolated cases, and in no way support history & odds. If you look at the draft over the last 20 years' of first round QBs, the odds of success for a QB picked outside top 10 drop dramatically (and get worse outside top 12). If a team didn't have a top 10 pick, they had nearly equal odds of getting a staring caliber QB in the second round than they did in latter half of 1st round. That's why it's not common for teams to pick a project in the first round, because the smart ones know you can fish for a project later on. Except Duder wasn't talking about history and odds. He said "NEVER," and I pointed pretty easily to two examples in the past 10 years. Outliers? Sure. Precedents? Yes.
The_Dude Posted September 23, 2014 Posted September 23, 2014 Dude....they do tend to get drafted later in the first round I will grant you that.....I absolutely thought Aaron Rogers was a developmental QB. Lets keep in mind here that Kolb was here that first year and got hurt. My stance is that Kolb was supposed to be the starter last year and it didnt work out....but that train has left the station. QB woes wont go away by starting a backup QB and sit the 1st round pick when the team is 2-1.....that is the definition of insane. And yes I do think Orton is a decent QB.....but you just dont do that. John, buddy, think about what you're saying. I'm not quite sure what you're trying to say cause it doesn't really make sense. Basically you're validating EJs selection because of Rogers. Rogers slid big tiiiime. Then what you're saying is because Kolb got injured I have to grant excess patience to EJ. No. And that doesn't make sense. I don't care about the 'master plan'. Then you're missing the biggest point. It's do or die for the Doug's. They don't want to get fired. EJ looks like a bust. Everybody thinks so except for a faction of Bills fans. But to everybody else EJ is a joke. And they're right. Being that the the Doug's have to win NOW who's their best shot at survival? EJ or Orton? What would you do if you were them? Would you risk your career on EJs shoulders? I doubt it. And yeah, I've seen enough to know the guy doesn't have it. EJ is what he was on Sunday. He'll have a great play like that dance party he had escaping pressure before his pass to Chandler. Then he's the guy who throws out of bounds from the end zone... That's what he is. Inconsistent.
Recommended Posts