Jump to content

Evans or Ebron?


e vs e  

223 members have voted

  1. 1. who would you draft

    • evans
      120
    • ebron
      103


Recommended Posts

Update-no saying youd take OL or anyone else, its assuming the brass is between these two guys

 

realistically both will be there for us. Both are big imposing talents who help in the red zone.

 

I say Ebron since we just drafted 3 WRs with speed so drafting Evans has to take someone off the field be it SJ Woods TJ or Goodwin and replaces speed with size (like a TE could also do.)

 

Also w Ebron we could trade back 3-5 spots and still realistically get him and gain another pick.(maybe even a second)

 

Finally I see Ebron with less bust potential than Evans and a guy who finally gives us a true threat at TE which has been missing since the K-gun (honorable mention to reimersma)

 

what do you think? vote is with the stipulation that all other BPAs are gone, I.e. Watkins Mack etc.

Edited by enlightener
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 202
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

realistically these two will be there for us. Both are big imposing talents who help in the red zone.

 

I say Ebron since we just drafted 3 WRs with speed so drafting Evans has to take someone off the field be it SJ Woods TJ or Goodwin and replaces speed with size (like a TE could also do.)

 

Also w Ebron we could trade back 3-5 spots and still realistically get him and gain another pick.(maybe even a second)

 

Finally I see Ebron with less bust potential than Evans and a guy who finally gives us a true threat at TE which has been missing since the K-gun (honorable mention to reimersma)

 

what do you think? vote is with the stipulation that all other BPAs are gone, I.e. Watkins Mack etc.

That's what I am hoping for, a trade down and Ebron! But I don't see it happening. I feel like the Bills brass are content with what they have at TE....

Edited by ricojes
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I would pick whichever can hold onto the ball, break tackles, go up for the ball and wrestle it from a DB, somewhat fast, strong, and has good vision on the field. Ebron, for a TE, is shorter than Evans but heavier by 20 lbs. Evans plays in a tougher conference and may be more "NFL ready". I'd take either one. Unless we take Evans and add 20 pounds of pure muscle...then we have a "slash" TE.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ebron. But real vote is NEITHER. My biggest draft day fear is Evans. Bills just invested a 2nd, 3rd and another 3rd on WR's, in addition, this draft is deep and the difference between Evans and the guy they could get in 2nd or 3rd is not significant. I want one of the OT's (Matthews or Robinson), if they are not there, I'm okay with Lewan or Barr (as rush end in Schwartz D).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ebron. But real vote is NEITHER. My biggest draft day fear is Evans. Bills just invested a 2nd, 3rd and another 3rd on WR's, in addition, this draft is deep and the difference between Evans and the guy they could get in 2nd or 3rd is not significant. I want one of the OT's (Matthews or Robinson), if they are not there, I'm okay with Lewan or Barr (as rush end in Schwartz D).

 

I'm with you.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'd go to OL, like others above if both of those are available. And if both of those are available, I am trading back. Even if it is not a big pick up, someone might want to move up. Carolina! I'd put the call in now to them. Say "hey homie, so if we're at 9 and Evans is there, you interested in him? We're not really looking to add him and you need WR's. We would take your 1st, 3rd this year and 3rd next year - how's that sound?

 

We might even get their 1st and 2nd, the value would still be in their favor, at that point. But, even to get their 2nd, I'd trade 4th rounds with them or something.

Edited by jboyst62
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I can't believe I actually agree with you on something but I'm 100% with you on this.

 

Trade back a few spots, pick up extra 2nd or 3rd, draft Ebron, use 2nd round pick on Benjamin, then use the rest of the draft on OL and LB.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I vote NEITHER by not voting... drafting a WR not named Watkins is silly with a #9 and goes against their plans if you look at last year, and we already have 5 TEs on the roster, so that should tell you we're not drafting Ebron.

 

Judging by our recent signings, I would have to go with Taylor Lewan, OT, or a trading scenario to either get Watkins or to trade down and to get more picks.

Edited by BmoreBills
Link to comment
Share on other sites

At 9? Neither. I think O-Line is most likely the pick, but I wouldn't discount Cinton-Dix IF he is the playmaker that Byrd was. If they were willing to throw $7M at Byrd, I think the Bills would be open to drafting the right safety.

 

I'd be shocked if the Bills took the WR.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Chandler resigning tells me that this is not going to happen. Chandler is roughly league average in terms of offensive production. We're not resigning him and bringing in Moeaki to take a TE at #9.

 

The top 5 tight ends in the league averaged 11.4 TDs last year. Scott Chandler had 2. Chandler is one of the worst starting TEs in the league...

 

http://www.footballo...rs.com/stats/TE

 

IMO they only signed Chandler because they needed a reliable second TE to go with a new offense featuring a 2 TE formation with Eric Ebron flexed out and with Johnson and Woods as the featured wide outs. I think Revis signing with the Pats for two years only solidifies the Bills picking Ebron who Revis can't cover even if they did move him from his island position on the outside.

 

As for Evans, he wouldn't even be on my first round board since I think he's got a high probability to be a bust as a first round pick. IMO the guy is built and plays like a TE and will be forced into the WR position which he just doesn't look athletic or agile enough to play at a high level.

Edited by 1billsfan
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Rags wow ! its a new dawn I guess lol

 

interesting, Ive read in other post how people despise the idea of going OL at 9, how Evans would be great at 9, now it may be Cinton Dix? That some are now convinced it will be Ebron. Im more confused than ever at how so many people are so "sure"of what the Bills will or wont do!

Edited by enlightener
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Mike Evans is the biggest need for this team. A massive WR, who can jump (Best Verticle in the combine) is very fast, and does not drop a lot of balls.

 

Evans can win jump balls when EJ gets into scramble mode.

 

Seems like a no brainer to me.

 

OL can be found in the later rounds.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Mike Evans is the biggest need for this team. A massive WR, who can jump (Best Verticle in the combine) is very fast, and does not drop a lot of balls.

 

Evans can win jump balls when EJ gets into scramble mode.

 

Seems like a no brainer to me.

 

OL can be found in the later rounds.

 

Seems like a no brainer to me that Buffalo will not draft a WR early on,

 

Bills WR corp already has plenty of untapped potential,

 

How about giving the guys we have a chance to gel ...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Update-no saying youd take OL or anyone else, its assuming the brass is between these two guys

 

realistically both will be there for us. Both are big imposing talents who help in the red zone.

 

I say Ebron since we just drafted 3 WRs with speed so drafting Evans has to take someone off the field be it SJ Woods TJ or Goodwin and replaces speed with size (like a TE could also do.)

 

Also w Ebron we could trade back 3-5 spots and still realistically get him and gain another pick.(maybe even a second)

 

Finally I see Ebron with less bust potential than Evans and a guy who finally gives us a true threat at TE which has been missing since the K-gun (honorable mention to reimersma)

 

what do you think? vote is with the stipulation that all other BPAs are gone, I.e. Watkins Mack etc.

 

Well, the issue is as you stated, you're only picking if it's between those two at 9, if we're trading back, your voting scenario doesn't allow for that...and, b/c the BILLS just signed Chandler, and have Moekai through next season, not to mention a fast TE in Gragg and Rookie TEs, except for an extremely rare few, take a couple years to develop and Ebron would be asked to do things he hasn't done in college, I think Evans is the better bet plus, he doesn't have to carry the receiving workload for a group of WRs...plus, and this purely speculation, but I think the BILLS trade SJ at some point during the Off-Season, maybe during the Draft, and cut ties with Graham...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...