Jump to content

Who are the top five QBs of all time?


bbb

Recommended Posts

I find it hard to compare guys from the 60s to guys from today because so much about the game has changed. Not only are the skills required to succeed at QB vastly different today from what they were at that time, but the level of competition has increased exponentially. Johnny Unitis may have been the greatest QB ever relative to the competition in his day and time, but can you really say definitively that he'd dominate in today's game? And by contrast, would the top QBs today thrive under the old rules?

 

That's why I think Marino and Favre are vastly underrated. Their stats from the the previous century would still be respectable by todays standards and they were the only ones putting up those numbers back then. And in the case of Favre, by putting up his best statistical season ever at the age of 39 he proved that his game translates. I don't think any top 5 list is complete without these guys.

 

I agree with your point about Kelly, but no, that is not how I judge the great ones. I try to base that on a totality of the circumstances analysis as best I can.

 

Johnny Unitas was a 10 time Pro Bowler, won 4 championships, 4 MVP awards, and was one of the toughest QBs the NFL has ever had over THREE decades. He only lost 1 title game as a starter, being screwed out of Super Bowl III and thus Shula gets fired.

 

The rules changed making it EASIER to score points and to protect your QB, not harder. What Johnny U did is simply amazing.

Edited by BmoreBills
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 167
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Johnny Unitas was a 10 time Pro Bowler, won 4 championships, 4 MVP awards, and was one of the toughest QBs the NFL has ever had over THREE decades. He only lost 1 title game as a starter, being screwed out of Super Bowl III and thus Shula gets fired.

 

Did Shula get fired?!? I always assumed he just wanted to go to Miami.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I find it hard to compare guys from the 60s to guys from today because so much about the game has changed. Not only are the skills required to succeed at QB vastly different today from what they were at that time, but the level of competition has increased exponentially. Johnny Unitis may have been the greatest QB ever relative to the competition in his day and time, but can you really say definitively that he'd dominate in today's game? And by contrast, would the top QBs today thrive under the old rules?

 

That's why I think Marino and Favre are vastly underrated. Their stats from the the previous century would still be respectable by todays standards and they were the only ones putting up those numbers back then. And in the case of Favre, by putting up his best statistical season ever at the age of 39 he proved that his game translates. I don't think any top 5 list is complete without these guys.

 

I agree with your point about Kelly, but no, that is not how I judge the great ones. I try to base that on a totality of the circumstances analysis as best I can.

I agree with you about Favre. Perhaps it's just the hater in me speaking, but I think Marino crumbled in the big games as he showed over and over against the Bills. He was absolutely great, but he could be beaten.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I agree that these things have to be considered. But for instance with Graham how much of his success had to do with the fact that pass defending wasn't really developed or understood at that time? Yes, it was revolutionary, but are we talking about great QB's or great strategists?

 

I think all kinds of factors have to be considered, but it's silly to compare guys from completely different eras.

 

If we cannot compare players from different eras, than the topic should not contain the words "all time".

 

Modern era quarterbacks might not even survive if they played by the rules from the 50's and 60's.

 

You make a good point. :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Favre is junk and has zero business on any such list. All-time TD pass leader - true - and the all-time INTERCEPTION thrower too. He doesn't even remotely compare.

 

Peyton's problem is that he has generally not been good in the playoffs - and specifically he was carried by his team to his one Super Bowl win. Marino had little playoff success, but his teams weren't that good.

 

I think the OP was pretty close - but I'd put Sammy Baugh up there for:

 

Johnny Unitas

Joe Montana

Sammy Baugh

Otto Graham

Tom Brady

 

John Elway/Dan Marino both just miss.

 

 

Looking at a "Wiki" list of qb's with the most career wins, Favre is #1. He could not have sucked!

Like it or not this is more of an opinion list, since stats do not mean a lot when comparing the old NFL to today.

 

Interesting thread though.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

 

Looking at a "Wiki" list of qb's with the most career wins, Favre is #1. He could not have sucked!

Like it or not this is more of an opinion list, since stats do not mean a lot when comparing the old NFL to today.

 

Interesting thread though.

 

The reason Favre had the most wins is because he also played the most games.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The reason Favre had the most wins is because he also played the most games.

 

Most games played by QBs:

Brett Favre 302

Earl Morrall 255

Fran Tarkenton 246

Dan Marino 242

Peyton Manning 240

John Elway 234

Vinny Testaverde 233

John Hadl 224

Sonny Jurgensen 218

Dave Krieg 213

Johnny Unitas 211

Len Dawson 211

Warren Moon 208

Steve DeBerg 206

Y. A. Tittle 203

Craig Morton 203

John Brodie 201

Jim Hart 201

Edited by Gugny
Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

Thanks. Very interesting read.

 

I do remember him turning around the Dolphins immediately. I was 8 years old and couldn't understand it. What?!? The Dolphins always stink. They, the Bills and the Patriots all did in my first few years of knowing football.

 

My father said it's because of the coach. He really knows what he's doing and got the players he wanted.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

Thanks. Very interesting read.

 

I do remember him turning around the Dolphins immediately. I was 8 years old and couldn't understand it. What?!? The Dolphins always stink. They, the Bills and the Patriots all did in my first few years of knowing football.

 

My father said it's because of the coach. He really knows what he's doing and got the players he wanted.

 

I often wonder if Tony Dungy was an overrated coach. Even a Caldwell-led team went 14-2 with P. Manning. I don't blame the Colts' collapse sans Manning on Caldwell. He was set up to fail. There's a difference between "not having Manning," and "having Curtis Painter."

 

But I wonder how, with a QB like Manning, could the Colts only win one Super Bowl.

 

I think it takes a great coach AND a great QB in order to create a dynasty.

 

Teams win the Super Bowl without both on occasion. But most winning teams have both, IMO.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 Jerry Rice* WR ^ 1985–2004 303 32 Irving Fryar WR 1984–2000 255 32 Tim Brown WR 1988–2004 255 45 Ricky Proehl WR 1990–2006 244 59 Charlie Joiner* WR 1969–1986 239 74 Andre Reed WR 1985–2000 234 74 Cris Carter* WR 1987–2002 234 82 James Lofton* WR 1978–1993 233 90 Derrick Mason WR 1997-2011 230 94 Henry Ellard WR 1983–1998 228 109 Art Monk* WR 1980–1995 224 120 Isaac Bruce WR 1994–2009 223 131 Terrell Owens WR 1996–2010 219

 

The reason Favre had the most wins is because he also played the most games.

Jerry Rice played 50 more games than the next closest WR.

Edited by Jauronimo
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I would say Kelly gets unfairly downgraded here because of fears that we are "homers," and elsewhere because he never won a Super Bowl. But because he started the "hurry up" offense that is used by everyone now, I think he belongs in the conversation. Also, any other QB get to 4 straight Super Bowls. NOPE. Winning a conference is very hard to do, I think that gets overlooked when discussing Kelly.

 

Kelly: Inventor of the hurry-up offense. Great under pressure. Perhaps the toughest QB to ever play the game. He often blocked for the RB's. And clutch at the end of the game.

 

 

This not true.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The reason Favre had the most wins is because he also played the most games.

 

In a way, that makes it more impressive. The guy rarely got hurt and was able to play for a long time. That's very impressive on his part.

 

I am not saying he should be on the list, just pointing out he was not "junk". :D

 

Are you talking about Farve in his crocs?

Edited by C.Biscuit97
Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

 

Johnny Unitas was a 10 time Pro Bowler, won 4 championships, 4 MVP awards, and was one of the toughest QBs the NFL has ever had over THREE decades. He only lost 1 title game as a starter, being screwed out of Super Bowl III and thus Shula gets fired.

 

The rules changed making it EASIER to score points and to protect your QB, not harder. What Johnny U did is simply amazing.

 

I'm not disputing any of that. None of this, however, takes into account the fact that the game is faster, players are bigger & more athletic, and the competition to play NFL football is far greater than it has ever been making the talent level considerably higher than it was in the olden days.

 

I don't claim Unitis couldn't dominate the league now, it's just hard to quantify & compare guys who played in vastly different eras.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...