Manti Teo vs. best QB in this draft

[FireChan]

 

 

What kind of stupid strawman is that supposed to be? Because Alabama is better than UB doesn't make the UB players "overrated".

 

Keep trying to dig out of your hole.

 

If you think a ND player is the same NFL prospect as a Alabama player, solely based on their records this year, then you don't understand football. There's no other way to put it besides knee-jerk idiocy.

 

I can't wait for next season, and all you ND praisers can see how stupid you sounded.

[KD in CA]

If you think a ND player is the same NFL prospect as a Alabama player, solely based on their records this year, then you don't understand football. There's no other way to put it besides knee-jerk idiocy.

 

I can't wait for next season, and all you ND praisers can see how stupid you sounded.

The only knee jerk idiocy here is your laughable attempts at posting "I bet you think...." strawmen that don't address your ridiculous assertion about identifying overrated college players (much less assigning that label to every player on a team) based on the careers of current NFL players. And it doesn't matter if it's Notre Dame, UB or Alabama.

[agardin]

'Don't draft another californian QB' was a popular and equally silly sentiment on these boards over the years.

 

Sure ND is a highly exposed program but so is Alabama and lots of other tier 1 NCAA program. Is there a big school bias? Sure there is but to place a higher draft grade to a prospect from Alabama over ND because Brady Quinn and Jimmy Clausen haven't panned out isn't prudent.

 

To answer the original question. I am BPA kinda guy but I also subscribe to the theory that franchise QB trumps all. So QB if there is one there and if the Bills end up with Teo I would be OK with that as well.

 

The QB could come from the historically fertile QB schools such as Miami (OH), Purdue, Vanderbilt, Delaware, Baylor, Cal and Auburn.

 

As I said, using a schools history of producing impact NFL players as a draft screen is just plain silly.

Edited November 18, 2012 by agardin

[ShipOffToBuffalo]

If you think a ND player is the same NFL prospect as a Alabama player, solely based on their records this year, then you don't understand football. There's no other way to put it besides knee-jerk idiocy.

 

I can't wait for next season, and all you ND praisers can see how stupid you sounded.

 

Your posts are giving me cancer, please stop before I die.

[Alaska Darin]

Manti may be that once in a generation Ray Lewis or Brian Urlacher type leader that an entire defense rallies around to elevate their play. ND is going to have every defensive senior drafted and that's not something I would have thought going into the season. Bob Diaco deserves a ton of credit but Teo is a special player.

[Wayne Cubed]

Manti may be that once in a generation Ray Lewis or Brian Urlacher type leader that an entire defense rallies around to elevate their play. ND is going to have every defensive senior drafted and that's not something I would have thought going into the season. Bob Diaco deserves a ton of credit but Teo is a special player.

 

Or he could be the next Aaron Curry, Rolando McClain, AJ Hawk, Keith Rivers... Just sayin'.

[Hater]

Or he could be the next Aaron Curry, Rolando McClain, AJ Hawk, Keith Rivers... Just sayin'.

 

Manti Te'o is going to be a solid player but unless Te'o is going to play QB for the Bills he is not going to make a huge Impact

[Rockinon]

I'm not happy with any of the QBs in this next draft. I personally don't think any of them are 1st round worthy.

[Bronc24]

 

 

If you think a ND player is the same NFL prospect as a Alabama player, solely based on their records this year, then you don't understand football. There's no other way to put it besides knee-jerk idiocy.

 

I can't wait for next season, and all you ND praisers can see how stupid you sounded.

 

I hate ND with a passion, but I would take Te'o in a second if he were available. If you actually watched football with an objective eye, you'd "see how stupid you sounded".

[DrDawkinstein]

It's no secret that Im a SEC homer, but Te'o is just as good as anything you'll find at Bama, UGA, or anywhere else.

 

This is a tough question because we desperately need to add some up and coming talent to the QB position.

 

I guess it comes down to: Can Te'o play OLB?

 

I know it was trendy to bash Sheppard earlier this year, but he is not the problem with our LB corp. The real weak link in that group is Barnett.

 

I actually believe Te'o could do well at Barnett's position in both the base D, and (more importantly) the Nickel. I wouldn't mind if it ended up Bradham/Sheppard/Te'o as our starting LBs.

 

Addressing QB is a major priority, but I dont know if I would take one over Te'o if he was there. I was hot on Geno Smith, and he is still my favorite QB in this draft, but it's a tough call. I definitely take Te'o over Barkley, Jones, Murray, Wilson, or any of the other QBs.

[ProbablyWrong]

I hate ND with a passion, but I would take Te'o in a second if he were available. If you actually watched football with an objective eye, you'd "see how stupid you sounded".

 

I feel the same way. ND may be my least favorite college team (Trumping Ohio State, despite my being a Michigan fan) but Te'o is incredible. He has all the tangibles and intangibles that a star defensive player needs, and that Buffalo currently lacks.

[Orton's Arm]

Some of us old folks might argue that point! Kelly was the only HoF QB, but Jack Kemp and Joe Ferguson were definitely "franchise" guys who led the team for a lot of years and to a fair bit of success!

 

Your standards were too low!

 

Over the course of his career, Johnny Unitas averaged 7.8 yards per attempt. That's a higher career average than Tom Brady or Peyton Manning. If the best QB from Kemp's era could achieve a better yards per attempt than many of the best QBs of today, it suggests that yards per attempt may be a reasonably good way of comparing QBs across eras.

 

Jack Kemp achieved a career yards per attempt of 6.9. Typically, a QB has to achieve a career yards per attempt of 7.2 - 7.4 to be considered franchise.

 

In addition, Kemp was intercepted on 6.0% of his pass attempts. Compare that to Alex van Pelt's 5.0% interception rate; or JP Losman's 3.6% interception rate. (Incidentally, Kemp's career yards per attempt of 6.9 is in the same general neighborhood as Losman's career yards per attempt of 6.6.)

 

Like Losman, Ferguson also averaged 6.6 yards per attempt over the course of his career. Ferguson was intercepted on 4.6% of his throws. Nothing about those stats remotely suggests "franchise" to me.

 

I'd argue that Jack Kemp was another Alex Smith/Joe Flacco. Neither Smith nor Flacco are franchise QBs, but they're a step down from that. I'd argue that Ferguson was two steps down from being a franchise QB, and was probably no better than Fitz.

Edited November 18, 2012 by Edwards' Arm

[Bronc24]

 

 

I feel the same way. ND may be my least favorite college team (Trumping Ohio State, despite my being a Michigan fan) but Te'o is incredible. He has all the tangibles and intangibles that a star defensive player needs, and that Buffalo currently lacks.

 

Also a Maize and Blue fan. Ohio State blows.

[Astrobot]

Just did a DraftTek Simulation where I Grabbed Manti Te'O with my first pick. Here is the simulation after making that pick:

 

1 9 Manti Te'o ILB Notre Dame

2 40 Landry Jones QB Oklahoma

3 72 Cordarrelle Patterson WRF Tennessee

4 104 Jonathan Brown OLB43 Illinois

5 136 Denard Robinson WRS Michigan

 

That's as far as the DraftTek Simulator goes for right now, but I used my own Big Board to flesh out RD6-7 and UDFA depth:

6 168 Malliciah Goodman DE43 97 Clemson 6'4" 280

7 209 Cassius Marsh (Jr.) DT/TE 99 UCLA 6'3" 290

 

UDFA:

Hakeem Smith SS 29 Louisville 6'1"

188 Denicos Allen OLB43 28 Michigan State 5'11 232

D.J. Harper RB 7 Boise State 5'9" 205 Brad Sorensen QB 4 Southern Utah 6'4" 235 Kyle Van Noy OLB 3 BYU 6'3" 235 Sean Renfree QB 19 Duke 6'4" 225 LaDarius Perkins RBF 27 Mississippi State 5'10" 190 Ryan Griffin TE 94 Connecticut 6'5" 248 Ivory Wade OC 78 Baylor 6'4"

310

John Goodman WR 81 Notre Dame 6'3"

215

 

This taught me a few things.

One, the sky won't fall if we take Te'O with the first pick.

Two, guys like Landry Jones, EJ Manuel, Tyler Bray, and Aaron Murray might be in the mix for a RD2 pick. There will also be QB depth later (Renfree, Sorenson, Glennon, McCarron)

Three, we can wait at positions like WR and D-Line in this draft and get quality.

[Buffalo Barbarian]

Just did a DraftTek Simulation where I Grabbed Manti Te'O with my first pick. Here is the simulation after making that pick:

 

1 9 Manti Te'o ILB Notre Dame

2 40 Landry Jones QB Oklahoma

3 72 Cordarrelle Patterson WRF Tennessee

4 104 Jonathan Brown OLB43 Illinois

5 136 Denard Robinson WRS Michigan

 

That's as far as the DraftTek Simulator goes for right now, but I used my own Big Board to flesh out RD6-7 and UDFA depth:

6 168 Malliciah Goodman DE43 97 Clemson 6'4" 280

7 209 Cassius Marsh (Jr.) DT/TE 99 UCLA 6'3" 290

 

UDFA:

Hakeem Smith SS 29 Louisville 6'1"

188 Denicos Allen OLB43 28 Michigan State 5'11 232

D.J. Harper RB 7 Boise State 5'9" 205 Brad Sorensen QB 4 Southern Utah 6'4" 235 Kyle Van Noy OLB 3 BYU 6'3" 235 Sean Renfree QB 19 Duke 6'4" 225 LaDarius Perkins RBF 27 Mississippi State 5'10" 190 Ryan Griffin TE 94 Connecticut 6'5" 248 Ivory Wade OC 78 Baylor 6'4"

310

John Goodman WR 81 Notre Dame 6'3"

215

 

This taught me a few things.

One, the sky won't fall if we take Te'O with the first pick.

Two, guys like Landry Jones, EJ Manuel, Tyler Bray, and Aaron Murray might be in the mix for a RD2 pick. There will also be QB depth later (Renfree, Sorenson, Glennon, McCarron)

Three, we can wait at positions like WR and D-Line in this draft and get quality.

 

Can't beat that draft as it's almost as good as mine

[Sisyphean Bills]

Just did a DraftTek Simulation where I Grabbed Manti Te'O with my first pick. Here is the simulation after making that pick:

 

1 9 Manti Te'o ILB Notre Dame

2 40 Landry Jones QB Oklahoma

3 72 Cordarrelle Patterson WRF Tennessee

4 104 Jonathan Brown OLB43 Illinois

5 136 Denard Robinson WRS Michigan

 

That's as far as the DraftTek Simulator goes for right now, but I used my own Big Board to flesh out RD6-7 and UDFA depth:

6 168 Malliciah Goodman DE43 97 Clemson 6'4" 280

7 209 Cassius Marsh (Jr.) DT/TE 99 UCLA 6'3" 290

 

UDFA:

Hakeem Smith SS 29 Louisville 6'1"

188 Denicos Allen OLB43 28 Michigan State 5'11 232

D.J. Harper RB 7 Boise State 5'9" 205 Brad Sorensen QB 4 Southern Utah 6'4" 235 Kyle Van Noy OLB 3 BYU 6'3" 235 Sean Renfree QB 19 Duke 6'4" 225 LaDarius Perkins RBF 27 Mississippi State 5'10" 190 Ryan Griffin TE 94 Connecticut 6'5" 248 Ivory Wade OC 78 Baylor 6'4"

310

John Goodman WR 81 Notre Dame 6'3"

215

 

This taught me a few things.

One, the sky won't fall if we take Te'O with the first pick.

Two, guys like Landry Jones, EJ Manuel, Tyler Bray, and Aaron Murray might be in the mix for a RD2 pick. There will also be QB depth later (Renfree, Sorenson, Glennon, McCarron)

Three, we can wait at positions like WR and D-Line in this draft and get quality.

 

Seriously flawed. Landry Jones isn't as hyped as Andrew Luck.

[KD in CA]

5 136 Denard Robinson WRS Michigan

 

What's the conventional wisdom on him? Is there a reasonable chance he can play WR or elsewhere in the NFL? Obviously he can't play QB but is super fast.

[H2o]

1. Manti Te'o / ILB / Notre Dame

2. Shane Skov / OLB / Stanford

3. Mike Glennon / QB / NC State

4. Jake Knott / OLB / Iowa St.

 

This is what I want the first 4 Rounds to look like and then BPA the rest of the way.

[ALF]

After watching Teo play against USC , the Bills will have to trade up to get him. I would do it

[Alaska Darin]

I know it was trendy to bash Sheppard earlier this year, but he is not the problem with our LB corp. The real weak link in that group is Barnett.

It's not only trendy to bash Sheppard, it's correct. He is the worst MLB in the NFL and it's not close. He doesn't fill his gap, can't shed, and misses the tackles he can get to with shocking regularity. On top of that he can't cover or recover. Terrible, terrible football player.