ajzepp Posted September 1, 2012 Posted September 1, 2012 Brady is the best of our time and definately in the discussion for all-time. Peyton has been knocked out in the first round 6 or 7 times in his career. To compare that to Bradys superbowl losses is a little ridiculous. I don't think it's ridiculous at all. We're not talking about overall team performance, we're talking about individual QBs and their impact. Peyton elevated a pretty mediocre team to one that was a perennial playoff participant and eventual SB champion. Brady took a 16-0 team to the SB against a 6-loss team and failed to even maintain the same level of production as his position, let alone elevate it. It wasn't the Pats defense that lost those last two SBs. Take Peyton off the list...Montana alone is at a level above Brady, IMO.
PushthePile Posted September 1, 2012 Posted September 1, 2012 I don't think it's ridiculous at all. We're not talking about overall team performance, we're talking about individual QBs and their impact. Peyton elevated a pretty mediocre team to one that was a perennial playoff participant and eventual SB champion. Brady took a 16-0 team to the SB against a 6-loss team and failed to even maintain the same level of production as his position, let alone elevate it. It wasn't the Pats defense that lost those last two SBs. Take Peyton off the list...Montana alone is at a level above Brady, IMO. I cant agree with the notion that Peyton's teams were mediocre. I actually think Peyton has had more talent on the field over his career. The losses to the Giants are nothing to hold against Brady. Those Giants teams had a ton of talent themselves and were playing their best football. Brady didnt play poorly considering the pressure he was under. Those games were close. I find it hard to believe Peyton or any other all-time QB does a whole lot more under that pressure. I love Peyton but his own personal playoff performances arent all-time great.
rickenbru Posted September 1, 2012 Posted September 1, 2012 I hate the bastard, but Brady's in the top 5. Still, I'd go with a healthy Peyton over a healthy Brady.
ajzepp Posted September 1, 2012 Posted September 1, 2012 I cant agree with the notion that Peyton's teams were mediocre. I actually think Peyton has had more talent on the field over his career. The losses to the Giants are nothing to hold against Brady. Those Giants teams had a ton of talent themselves and were playing their best football. Brady didnt play poorly considering the pressure he was under. Those games were close. I find it hard to believe Peyton or any other all-time QB does a whole lot more under that pressure. I love Peyton but his own personal playoff performances arent all-time great. A 16-0 team losing to a 10-6 team isn't a big deal? They were close games...point is, they shouldn't have been. Reference Brady's pre-SB interview when he scoffed at the notion that he would lead his team to only 17 points...he well expected to put up points and he failed to do that. If he had still won, it wouldn't really matter....but they lost...for the first time that season....and that is a huge blemish, IMO. I hate the bastard, but Brady's in the top 5. Still, I'd go with a healthy Peyton over a healthy Brady. If top 5 means "fifth", I could certainly put him in that sport...that sounds like a pretty good spot for him.
3rdnlng Posted September 1, 2012 Posted September 1, 2012 Can this guy ever be considered the best qb ever? http://sportsofboston.com/2011/05/22/photo-tom-brady-on-water-slide-at-mexican-vacation-with-gisele/
Reed83HOF Posted September 1, 2012 Posted September 1, 2012 I can't believe this is even a discussion. Peyton, Joe M, Johnny U are 3 that are clearly better than Brady. All you have to do is compare the 2010 Colts to the 2011 Colts for Peyton. Joe M never lost a super bowl and earned the name Joe Cool for a reason. Danny boy and Elway deserve some conversation as well. Brady can't even enter this equation until after them. Besides, it is easy to be Brady* when your coach steals the D's signals and knows what is coming
ajzepp Posted September 1, 2012 Posted September 1, 2012 Can this guy ever be considered the best qb ever? http://sportsofbosto...on-with-gisele/ lmao.... I can't believe this is even a discussion. Peyton, Joe M, Johnny U are 3 that are clearly better than Brady. All you have to do is compare the 2010 Colts to the 2011 Colts for Peyton. Joe M never lost a super bowl and earned the name Joe Cool for a reason. Danny boy and Elway deserve some conversation as well. Brady can't even enter this equation until after them. Besides, it is easy to be Brady* when your coach steals the D's signals and knows what is coming LOL, I was hoping someone else would throw in that last part so I didn't have to take the heat for it
Reed83HOF Posted September 1, 2012 Posted September 1, 2012 LOL, I was hoping someone else would throw in that last part so I didn't have to take the heat for it I'm surprised it took this long. I was waiting as well, figured I toss it out. On a serious note, no doubt the guy is a great qb, but the best ever? No way.
Rob's House Posted September 1, 2012 Posted September 1, 2012 I must have missed all those years of stacked Indy teams & scrub NE teams. The only year I remember the Colts having a defense they won the SB.
ganesh Posted September 1, 2012 Posted September 1, 2012 You don’t have to be a football fan to be a Bills fan. I, however, am a football fan. The energy and excitement of the game thrills me. The strategy of every play, every position and every inch energizes me. The dedication of the players to live an unlivable dream intrigues me. The story of the players motivates me and makes me feel a parallel in my life. Every single one of these kids has a story and a dream. Respect to the players that fuel my love for the game of football. Tom Brady included. http://www.nfl.com/q...HP11_hot_topics All that being said...... I still hate the SOB! Oh yeah, I almost forgot. I hope we kick his A** this year! GO BILLS! I would definitely have to give the nod to Tom Brady. Montana stunk up 3 qtrs of the game and then did magic in the 4th qtr to bail them out....On the other hand Brady and his offense has dominated the league for the decade with some outstanding quarter backing. Brady put fear into the opponents...
Dragonborn10 Posted September 1, 2012 Posted September 1, 2012 (edited) 1. Brady 2. Montana 3. Graham 4. Manning 5. Unitas 6. Youngh 7. Marino 8. Elway 9. Favre 10. Tarkenton, Stauhbach, Aikman, Kelly, Starr, Bradshaw, Namath, Stabler, Edited September 1, 2012 by Dadonkadonk
LiterateStylish Posted September 1, 2012 Posted September 1, 2012 1. Brady 2. Montana 3. Graham 4. Manning 5. Unitas 6. Youngh 7. Marino 8. Elway 9. Tarkenton, Stauhbach, Aikman, Kelly, Starr, Bradshaw 9.Namath, Stabler, Aikman??? Bahahahaha.
Formerly Allan in MD Posted September 1, 2012 Posted September 1, 2012 Johnny Unitas, week in and week out, was the ultimate in a quarterback.
truth on hold Posted September 1, 2012 Posted September 1, 2012 (edited) Few years ago I would have said yes he is. Great arm can make all throws, super quick decision maker, has all the subtleties down like looking off the DBs, been successful in different schemes and with different personnel, 3 rings etc etc. Only knock was not a great scrambler, but so what when you can do all that other stuff. But 2 SB losses later when the O didn't put up a lot points, and I see him losing his edge a bit, I'd put him in with a group of legends like staubach montana and elway. But during his era at least he's clearly #1 to me, well ahead of Manning Edited September 1, 2012 by Joe_the_6_pack
kasper13 Posted September 1, 2012 Posted September 1, 2012 Super Bowl. 2 minutes left. No timeouts. 80 yards. Need a TD to win. Who do you want at QB? I'd take Montana every time.
Tcali Posted September 1, 2012 Posted September 1, 2012 bunch of young guys saying peyton peyton peyton. i put brady at around #8.--which is no insult. peyton around 7. montana 1. elway 2(he carried --and i mean really carried some mediocre denver teams to deep in the playoffs).Marino 3. Steve Young 4. Fran Tarkenton 5. favre 6(only equalled by elway,marino in sheer talent dept--woulda been no 1 exc for occas brain farts) Danny Fouts and Kenny anderson round out the top 10. apologies to the pre 1960s guys like sammy baugh, johnny U ,Otto Graham didnt really see ya cant judge you
ajzepp Posted September 1, 2012 Posted September 1, 2012 (edited) bunch of young guys saying peyton peyton peyton. i put brady at around #8.--which is no insult. peyton around 7. montana 1. elway 2(he carried --and i mean really carried some mediocre denver teams to deep in the playoffs).Marino 3. Steve Young 4. Fran Tarkenton 5. favre 6(only equalled by elway,marino in sheer talent dept--woulda been no 1 exc for occas brain farts) Danny Fouts and Kenny anderson round out the top 10. apologies to the pre 1960s guys like sammy baugh, johnny U ,Otto Graham didnt really see ya cant judge you This is more along the lines of how I feel...not just cause I grew up watching them play, but because it just hit me that the competition they played against was like much better back then since we had fewer teams and less parity. Definitely agree about Elway...both he and Mario were one man armies at times...each of them often had no defense and no RB worth a damn...they had some nice wideouts at times, but as far as a complete team? Nah.... And I rank Peyton up there because I see him doing the very same thing that Elway and Marino had to do during the 80s...take mediocre teams and turn them into playoff/SB teams pretty much by themselves. Edited September 1, 2012 by ajzepp
Jeffery Lester Posted September 1, 2012 Posted September 1, 2012 Tom Brady was the best football player I have ever seen over a 5 year period in the early 2000's. I do not like him either. But I do respect him. People give credit to Beilcheat. Look it up he had a loosing record as a headcoach prior to Tammy becoming his QB. I give all props to Brady
Offside Number 76 Posted September 1, 2012 Posted September 1, 2012 I don't think he's the best quarterback currently, much less ever.
Maury Ballstein Posted September 1, 2012 Posted September 1, 2012 Tom over Peyton x10 IMO. Toms 7-4 against the media darling known as Peyton Some of these posts blow my mind. Peyton had plenty of talent over the years. The colts got old and they declined lately. Peyton was toms whipping boy until much like Lebron James one time Peyton/Lebron finally won the big one I'm all about my bills. But Brady's a golden god if they score another td or two and beat the giants.. No tyree helmet catch things change quick.
Recommended Posts