Ramius Posted August 24, 2012 Posted August 24, 2012 Missing on rounds 5-7 does not count as a bust. League wide, most of those guys wash out after a year or 2.
bowery4 Posted August 24, 2012 Posted August 24, 2012 The season is not coming soon enough for me. How many threads like this can ppl on here actually generate?
BuffBill Posted August 24, 2012 Posted August 24, 2012 I have read in a few places how this current front office was such an improvement, and I am not slamming the front office, but we still have 3 starters from the 2009 class, and 3 of the teams better players too (Byrd, Wood & Levitre).
John from Riverside Posted August 24, 2012 Posted August 24, 2012 You say that - but then you start looking back at the 2011 draft and the concerns spread out a bit. Dareus is a stud, no question - but after that, you have Aaron Williams and Kelvin Sheppard, both of whom have had awful preseasons and may be in danger of losing their jobs. Chris White and Johnny White likely both will be cut. Hairston is a decent swing tackle but that appears to be his ceiling. Jasper is gone. Searcy is a backup (so far)... I look at Nix's first two drafts and I really have to question whether the guy knows what he's doing as a GM. I love his coaches (now, although it took a re-boot on the defensive side) and he's done a good job with UDFAs and free agents. But the good teams win on draft day - Nix has not come close to doing that yet. These guys are all still young....and you guage successful drafts by how many starters you are able to put out on the field - There has been no indication that Aaron Williams is losing his job.....only that he might be getting pushed by even better draft selections. To take a 6' 200 pound plus corner is was rated as a 1st round pick int the 2nd is not a bad selection. To be faire to Willaims he started off bad but got better as training camp went on. - There has been no indication that Shep has lost his starting MLB job yet with the exception that Morrison is getting reps at MLB.....Morrison could frankly be on the bubble and they are trying to see if his versitility will allow him to stay on the team. Its way too early for this. - The ONLY reason way Searcy is not starting is because we have two of the best safeties in the league....PERIOD. The bills love this guy.....and keep in mind that your going to be seeing more then 2 safeties on the field at a time due to defensive packages. Searcy is gonna play a lot this year......we also have Byrd (who I hope we resign) coming up as a free agent. Searcy was an excellent pick. Once again going with a large player at his position who loves to hit just like Williams. - Jasper was a project....at that time in the draft your not going to find a lot of Demitrous Bell's.......and Stevie Johnson's......its no big deal. - Chris White and Johnny White....same same..... I will say this again......if you can get 3-4 starting players/Impact players out of a draft then you have had a successful draft. There is NO QUESTION that this roster from top to bottom is far more talented for Nix coming in then pre Nix. Anybody who says other then that is full of ****
Miyagi-Do Karate Posted August 24, 2012 Posted August 24, 2012 I am not seeing where he says or implies that Spiller was a good pick. You're right--I misread the last line of his post. I would argue that, at a minimum, Spiller is good enough to consider "not a bust." A different issue is whether it ever makes sense to draft a RB in the 1st round, especially when you already had two good ones on the team.
Ed_Formerly_of_Roch Posted August 24, 2012 Posted August 24, 2012 Biggest problem with Modrak seems to have been his love of small college players, or maybe I should say not taken into account a guy wh's a stud at South Dakota St doesn't mean he can play that level in the NFL
DrDawkinstein Posted August 24, 2012 Posted August 24, 2012 .__________>/^\< | ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' '|__\ | WAMBULANCE - | i<< I_______________|I ..""(@)"""""""""(@)"............
Coach Tuesday Posted August 24, 2012 Posted August 24, 2012 These guys are all still young....and you guage successful drafts by how many starters you are able to put out on the field - There has been no indication that Aaron Williams is losing his job.....only that he might be getting pushed by even better draft selections. To take a 6' 200 pound plus corner is was rated as a 1st round pick int the 2nd is not a bad selection. To be faire to Willaims he started off bad but got better as training camp went on. - There has been no indication that Shep has lost his starting MLB job yet with the exception that Morrison is getting reps at MLB.....Morrison could frankly be on the bubble and they are trying to see if his versitility will allow him to stay on the team. Its way too early for this. - The ONLY reason way Searcy is not starting is because we have two of the best safeties in the league....PERIOD. The bills love this guy.....and keep in mind that your going to be seeing more then 2 safeties on the field at a time due to defensive packages. Searcy is gonna play a lot this year......we also have Byrd (who I hope we resign) coming up as a free agent. Searcy was an excellent pick. Once again going with a large player at his position who loves to hit just like Williams. - Jasper was a project....at that time in the draft your not going to find a lot of Demitrous Bell's.......and Stevie Johnson's......its no big deal. - Chris White and Johnny White....same same..... I will say this again......if you can get 3-4 starting players/Impact players out of a draft then you have had a successful draft. There is NO QUESTION that this roster from top to bottom is far more talented for Nix coming in then pre Nix. Anybody who says other then that is full of **** I agree with your concluson - but I continue not to be sold on Nix's drafting abilities. Not saying he's terrible, just that the jury is still out.
mannc Posted August 24, 2012 Posted August 24, 2012 (edited) I can't blame Buddy for 2010. Why not? Wasn't he the general manager? Let's face it, 2010 was a very poor draft and it started with picking a scatback early in the 1st round. Regardless whether Spiller becomes a decent RB in this league (and after two years, that's far from certain), he was taken way too high. It's exactly the kind of decision that has put this franchise where it is today. Any GM who picks a RB in the top 30 should be fired on the spot. It is just too easy to find good running backs lower in the draft or in FA (see Fred Jackson). Cleveland, for example, was insane to use the third pick in the draft on a RB this year; I was praying that Richardson would be off the board when the Bills picked. And as someone else pointed out, the 2011 draft is not really looking all that great, especially when one considers that pretty much anyone with half a brain could have selected Dareus with the first pick. And even that pick could be questioned when one considers that the two players selected after Dareus have already made the Pro Bowl, especially when one of them was at a major position of need (WR). Edited August 24, 2012 by mannc
CodeMonkey Posted August 24, 2012 Posted August 24, 2012 spiller was a great pick, he was a little raw his rookie year but could be really special... hes proven that... i always scratch my head when I see stuff like this. He sucked complete and total ass his rookie year in every way that it is possible for a RB to suck ass. The last half of last year (his 2nd) he ran a bit better. Tried on occasion to go north instead of east/west which was great to see. Both years, and so far in this preseason, he still cannot pick up a blitzer to save his (or Fitz's) life. By all accounts he is a nice kid with a great work ethic and has great speed. But so far that has not translated into anything even remotely "special". But you are right to say he still could. I'm pulling for the kid to have a breakout season this year, which a RB sure as hell should be able to have by year 3 if he is ever going to, But no freaking way, in my opinion, can anyone say picking Spiller as his first pick as the Bills GM was great so far anyway.
DanInUticaTampa Posted August 24, 2012 Posted August 24, 2012 (edited) You say that - but then you start looking back at the 2011 draft and the concerns spread out a bit. Dareus is a stud, no question - but after that, you have Aaron Williams and Kelvin Sheppard, both of whom have had awful preseasons and may be in danger of losing their jobs. Chris White and Johnny White likely both will be cut. Hairston is a decent swing tackle but that appears to be his ceiling. Jasper is gone. Searcy is a backup (so far)... I look at Nix's first two drafts and I really have to question whether the guy knows what he's doing as a GM. I love his coaches (now, although it took a re-boot on the defensive side) and he's done a good job with UDFAs and free agents. But the good teams win on draft day - Nix has not come close to doing that yet. Agreed. The drafts seem to not work out as time goes on. I liked the last two drafts, but it makes you wonder how good the Glenn and graham picks are when you see shep and Aaron Williams struggling in preseason Edited August 24, 2012 by DanInUticaTampa
FleaMoulds80 Posted August 24, 2012 Posted August 24, 2012 Wish people would stop saying "Spiller was BPA." Sorry but he was not.
....lybob Posted August 24, 2012 Posted August 24, 2012 It makes me sick we could have had Gronkowski. What a bunch of dopes... The guy is a stud but I don't blame Nix for not taking him- I remember thinking this guy is pretty good if he stays healthy he'll probably be a 50 catch 500yd guy - so he's about three times better than what I thought- the guy I had pegged in the second round was Linval Joseph who was taken by the Giants.
Punch Posted August 24, 2012 Posted August 24, 2012 Every draft can't be a home run--- the only consolation with the 2010 draft is that it is the odd man out of our recent draft history: 2009, 2011 and 2012 have produced numerous starters and/or valuable contributers. The track record has improved dramatically from where it was in the previous 6 years or so. And has been said, many of those defensive players that haven't panned could be considered 'tweeners that were too small for the 4-3 and ultimately not good enough for the failed 3-4 shift. If Easley makes the team and Troup returns healthy in 2013 and replaces Dwan Edwards or Spencer Johnson (both of their contracts are up) then it improves somewhat. But it's failure is still the outlier over the past 4 seasons.
Ramius Posted August 24, 2012 Posted August 24, 2012 Wish people would stop saying "Spiller was BPA." Sorry but he was not. Revisionist history at its finest. Spiller was almost the consensus BPA on the board at that spot. Everyone haf him a top 10-12 pick. JPP was a one year wonder from a small school who had lots of questions around him.
thebandit27 Posted August 24, 2012 Posted August 24, 2012 i always scratch my head when I see stuff like this. He sucked complete and total ass his rookie year in every way that it is possible for a RB to suck ass. The last half of last year (his 2nd) he ran a bit better. Tried on occasion to go north instead of east/west which was great to see. Both years, and so far in this preseason, he still cannot pick up a blitzer to save his (or Fitz's) life. By all accounts he is a nice kid with a great work ethic and has great speed. But so far that has not translated into anything even remotely "special". But you are right to say he still could. I'm pulling for the kid to have a breakout season this year, which a RB sure as hell should be able to have by year 3 if he is ever going to, But no freaking way, in my opinion, can anyone say picking Spiller as his first pick as the Bills GM was great so far anyway. Pretty massive understatement there. The guy averaged over 5 yards/carry last year (good for 7th in the NFL among running backs with at least 100 carries), had 7 runs of over 20 yards (there were only 12 backs in the league with more; 9 of whom had at least 100 more carries than Spiller), and averaged 5.75 yards/touch over his 6 starts (just for fun, go check out LeSean McCoy's stats for his last 6 starts, but don't stop there, compare the defenses they faced too). Wish people would stop saying "Spiller was BPA." Sorry but he was not. Who was? No revisionist history please, just a simple answer to the question: what player--still on the board--was a better college football player than C.J. Spiller?
Coach Tuesday Posted August 24, 2012 Posted August 24, 2012 Wish people would stop saying "Spiller was BPA." Sorry but he was not. Correct. JPP was the BPA, and not picking him cost Ralph $100 million this offseason (I'm dead serious). Then Troup, Carrington and Easley were need picks and proved why you don't draft for need over value. The 2010 draft was pretty much a textbook case of what NOT to do on draft day.
FitzShowUsYourTitz Posted August 24, 2012 Posted August 24, 2012 (edited) For what it's worth, her are the Pats and Jests 2010 picks. I figure it's easy enough for anyone to say....'Hey we coulda woulda shoulda picked this guy...'. But lets look at 2 respectable (uh,hem) franchises and see how they did. I would much prefer someone gives examples of teams actual drafts to really get a true comparison. With that said, my guess is 50% of every teams drafts are bad or mediocre. With the Pats you really have to look at how many they hit on b/c they had A Lot of picks: JESTS: 1. Kyle Wilson 2. Vladimir Ducasse 4. Joe McKnight 5. John Connor *Jests traded a bunch of picks. Major trade was for Braylon Edwards. PATS: 1. (27th Overall) – Devin McCourty, CB, Rutgers 2. Rob Gronkowski, TE, Arizona 2. Jermaine Cunningham, OLB, Florida 2. Brandon Spikes, LB, Florida 3. Taylor Price, WR, Ohio 4. Aaron Hernandez, TE, Florida 5. Zoltan Mesko, P, Michigan 6. Ted Larsen, C, NC State 7. Thomas Welch, OT, Vanderbilt 7. Brandon Deaderick, DL, Alabama 7. Kade Weston, DL, Georgia 7. Zac Robinson, QB, Oklahoma State Edited August 24, 2012 by Cville Bills
Punch Posted August 24, 2012 Posted August 24, 2012 (edited) Revisionist history at its finest. Spiller was almost the consensus BPA on the board at that spot. Everyone haf him a top 10-12 pick. JPP was a one year wonder from a small school who had lots of questions around him. Who was? No revisionist history please, just a simple answer to the question: what player--still on the board--was a better college football player than C.J. Spiller? He wasn't just considered the BPA at the Bills pick--- in fact, Spiller was considered by many pundits and scouts to be the best player in the entire draft. JESTS: 1. Kyle Wilson 2. Vladimir Ducasse 4. Joe McKnight 5. John Connor *Jests traded a bunch of picks. Major trade was for Braylon Edwards. PATS: I've always liked the "Jests" moniker--- I'm calling it now, if the Bills win the division, then NE officially becomes the Past. It's our time. Edited August 24, 2012 by Punch
Recommended Posts