Birch Bigsley Posted August 15, 2012 Posted August 15, 2012 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l2xU_n2kWh0&feature=youtu.be Check out my top 10 list of Bills QBs. The list gets ugly. You try to make a better one.
IslandBillsFan Posted August 15, 2012 Posted August 15, 2012 Birch, Loe your videos. Hate this list. Makes me want a Zoloft perscription.
Lord Chinfist Posted August 15, 2012 Posted August 15, 2012 Maybe Dennis Shaw fits in somewhere near the bottom? He threw a lot of ints., but he did get the NFL offensive rookie of the year in 1970.
BRAWNDO Posted August 15, 2012 Posted August 15, 2012 Great stuff Birch, I look forward to your videos!!
Birch Bigsley Posted August 15, 2012 Author Posted August 15, 2012 Maybe Dennis Shaw fits in somewhere near the bottom? He threw a lot of ints., but he did get the NFL offensive rookie of the year in 1970. Yeah, Shaw would of been a good guy to add somewhere up there.
Steve O Posted August 15, 2012 Posted August 15, 2012 Great video. I'm switching 2 and 3, Kemp did get us 2 AFL championships as well as to the AFL championship game the year of super bowl 1. Agree with Flutie at number 4. Reich comes in at number 5 - He always played well in relief of Kelly, and followed "the comeback" by defeating the top seeded Steelers in Pittsburgh a week later. I have Lamonica goes at 6 but would be 2 or 3 had he stayed a Bill. As you say, had a pretty good Raider career. My list has Bledsoe at number 7. Who's left? Shaw, Mathison, Dufek, Ferragomo, Mangini, Holcomb, Collins, Van Pelt , Johnson, the idiot that didn't study the playbook before the game because he didn't think he'd play - Pick any 3 to get Edwards and Losman off the list. Like you say, does it really matter?
Birch Bigsley Posted August 15, 2012 Author Posted August 15, 2012 Great video. I'm switching 2 and 3, Kemp did get us 2 AFL championships as well as to the AFL championship game the year of super bowl 1. Agree with Flutie at number 4. Reich comes in at number 5 - He always played well in relief of Kelly, and followed "the comeback" by defeating the top seeded Steelers in Pittsburgh a week later. I have Lamonica goes at 6 but would be 2 or 3 had he stayed a Bill. As you say, had a pretty good Raider career. My list has Bledsoe at number 7. Who's left? Shaw, Mathison, Dufek, Ferragomo, Mangini, Holcomb, Collins, Van Pelt , Johnson, the idiot that didn't study the playbook before the game because he didn't think he'd play - Pick any 3 to get Edwards and Losman off the list. Like you say, does it really matter? Yeah man. As I was compiling my list I was going to keep Edwards and Losman off the list but figured it didn't matter and it would be funnier to have them on there. Although I regret leaving out Shaw.
Chandemonium Posted August 15, 2012 Posted August 15, 2012 While it is indeed ugly that some of those guys make the top 10 list of BIlls QB's, I would imagine that the list would be similarly ugly for most teams in the league. After all, when a team has a good QB they usually try to hold on to him for a while. Look at the top 2 guys on this list for the Bills. Kelly played 11 seasons for them, and Ferguson played 12. that's almost half the team's history between 2 guys. Doesn't leave room for much else besides a couple more long-tenured quality starters, or a whole bunch of average joes who maybe had one or two good seasons.
paintmyhouse Posted August 15, 2012 Posted August 15, 2012 (edited) Kelly Kemp Ferguson Shaw Bledsoe Reich Flutie Johnson Edwards Fitzpatrick Edited August 15, 2012 by paintmyhouse
tennesseeboy Posted August 15, 2012 Posted August 15, 2012 I gotta throw Shaw and Fitzpatrick into the mix to get rid of Edwards and Losman. I would rank Kemp number two. I'm glad to see Reich and LaMonica on the list as they were pretty remarkable guys even though in a limited role.
PromoTheRobot Posted August 15, 2012 Posted August 15, 2012 Oh if only Flutie started the Music City Miracle game! OH WAIT! Dougie started the Miami playoff game one year earlier. Oh, you don't remember how Doug "Flumble" lost the ball at the Miami 1yd line with seconds left in the game? It's amazing how NO ONE ever brings that game up!! And I'm no RJ fan but we were winning when he left the field. All we had to do is cover the kickoff. PTR
kasper13 Posted August 15, 2012 Posted August 15, 2012 1. Kelly 2. Ferguson 3. Kemp 4. Reich 5. Lamonica 6. Bledsoe 7. Flutie 8. Fitzpatrick 9. Van Pelt 10. Shaw How about the Ten Worst as well? 1. Losman 2. Edwards 3. Johnson 4. Marangi 5. Ferragamo 6. Mathison 7. Hobert 8. Collins 9. Darragh 10. Stephenson
Recommended Posts