mrags Posted April 4, 2012 Posted April 4, 2012 Your 100% correct bud Like I said. I don't disagree with anything you guys are saying. All I'm saying is if I had to pick between the number one and number two and two didn't have these issues, I'm going with two all day and twice on Sundays. If another team wants to take the risk and possibly reap the huge reward, congrats in them. I wouldn't fault them for doing it. I just wouldn't. And it's not like this kid WONT be drafted because of this. He won't be looking for a job come august that's for sure. He'll get what he deserves I'm sure. It just wouldn't be from me if I had to chose. That's all. Going to bed now. Nite
hamtenp Posted April 4, 2012 Posted April 4, 2012 Yeah, but c'mon...a 4 !! That eventually has to blossom into something not so pretty...wouldn't ya think? [/quote Look at the bright side. He can only move up from here
AllenToBrown2020 Posted April 4, 2012 Posted April 4, 2012 Is this score bad enough for him to fall to #10? dis make me go Bills? (edited so the honey-badger could read it) The honey badger is Tyrann Mathieu. lol how is YOUR reading comprehension?
AllenToBrown2020 Posted April 4, 2012 Posted April 4, 2012 I believe Honey Badger is the title given to the best DB at LSU. No offense but I think Claiborne earned that this year. I am sure Mathieu will be the Honey Badger next year. Who knows, maybe we'll end up with two on our roster. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tyrann_Mathieu Keep eating those crayons.
Ramius Posted April 4, 2012 Posted April 4, 2012 Even Fitzy agrees the wonderlic is a BS test of intelligence. And he basically aced it. http://msn.foxsports.com/nfl/story/Morris-Claiborne-NFL-draft-LSU-Wonderlic-score-040312
CSBill Posted April 4, 2012 Posted April 4, 2012 http://espn.go.com/page2/s/closer/020228test.html for example questions http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2012/04/03/claiborne-gives-birth-to-a-four-on-the-wonderlic/ for the report on this Ohhhhhkayyyy He can STILL tie his own shoes....right? Jets will take him, a perfect match with Cromartie
Turbosrrgood Posted April 4, 2012 Posted April 4, 2012 A 10 or a 13 is one thing, but a 4? Come on, I think most of us have taken a sample wonderlic, or at least seen the questions. A 4 indicates not just low intelligence, but some SEVERE mental shortcomings. Possibly even retardation. Maybe this was masked in a top ranked college program loaded with talent and good coaching, but in the NFL where the playbooks are far more complex, and the talent far and away above what he is used to seeing every week, I have to question how he can succeed. At the very least GM's should be very concerned about what they are getting in this guy. Vince Young and his limited brainpower couldn't handle being an NFL starter, and Claiborne makes him look like a genius.
NoSaint Posted April 4, 2012 Posted April 4, 2012 A 10 or a 13 is one thing, but a 4? Come on, I think most of us have taken a sample wonderlic, or at least seen the questions. A 4 indicates not just low intelligence, but some SEVERE mental shortcomings. Possibly even retardation. Maybe this was masked in a top ranked college program loaded with talent and good coaching, but in the NFL where the playbooks are far more complex, and the talent far and away above what he is used to seeing every week, I have to question how he can succeed. At the very least GM's should be very concerned about what they are getting in this guy. Vince Young and his limited brainpower couldn't handle being an NFL starter, and Claiborne makes him look like a genius. The assertion is he can't read. If true, it's totally luck of the draw.
Mr. WEO Posted April 4, 2012 Posted April 4, 2012 (edited) I don't understand why the Nfl, unlike the NCAA, doesn't allow others to take this test for these guys. Anyway, it's obvious you don't have to be a genius to succeed in the NFL--idiot savant will do. Edited April 4, 2012 by Mr. WEO
Zulu Cthulhu Posted April 4, 2012 Posted April 4, 2012 A timed test like the Wonderlic (12 minutes) for someone with a reading disability would be incredibly difficult and frustrating. His score doesn't suggest he's "retarded" Turbo. It may suggest the kid has some literacy issues. Wonderlic Inc. sets a score of 10 as indicating normal adult literacy. Or Claiborne is just an immature hot-shot and didn't even try to successfully complete the test? I have no idea, but it wouldn't be unprecedented.
Turbosrrgood Posted April 4, 2012 Posted April 4, 2012 The assertion is he can't read. If true, it's totally luck of the draw. That logic makes sense...If true though, LSU should be investigated. How can you have guys making that far through high school, let alone college that can't read? Who is taking his tests for him?
DefenseWinzChampionshipz Posted April 4, 2012 Posted April 4, 2012 Damn... 9 pages on Wonderlic... Pretty cool...
Turbosrrgood Posted April 4, 2012 Posted April 4, 2012 A timed test like the Wonderlic (12 minutes) for someone with a reading disability would be incredibly difficult and frustrating. His score doesn't suggest he's "retarded" Turbo. It may suggest the kid has some literacy issues. Wonderlic Inc. sets a score of 10 as indicating normal adult literacy. Or Claiborne is just an immature hot-shot and didn't even try to successfully complete the test? I have no idea, but it wouldn't be unprecedented. Ok, let's say he can't read. He supposedly made it through high school and college, yet he can't read? Doesn't that still suggest he has some sort of major learning disability at the very least, if not full fledged mental slowness? It also obviously suggests LSU was doing something less than legit to keep him in good academic standing.
D521646 Posted April 4, 2012 Posted April 4, 2012 Morris will still be the first corner off the board, and it's happenin before the 10th pick.. Good thing CB isn't our biggest need.. Tim-
CBD Posted April 4, 2012 Posted April 4, 2012 That logic makes sense...If true though, LSU should be investigated. How can you have guys making that far through high school, let alone college that can't read? Who is taking his tests for him? There's a difference between being so uneducated that you can't read, and having a learning disability that impairs your abilty to read well.
CSBill Posted April 4, 2012 Posted April 4, 2012 Damn... 9 pages on Wonderlic... Pretty cool... Its the annual Wonderlick thread that pops up this time a year. .... everyone jump on and report their scores. I did two short versions: 37 & 40 .... feeling good about myself.
Turbosrrgood Posted April 4, 2012 Posted April 4, 2012 There's a difference between being so uneducated that you can't read, and having a learning disability that impairs your abilty to read well. You're going a little over the top defending him. For someone to make it to this point in college and score a 4 on this test, points to a serious problem in this kid's noggin, whatever the cause. If he can't read, how will he learn a complicated NFL playbook.
Kelly the Dog Posted April 4, 2012 Posted April 4, 2012 You're going a little over the top defending him. For someone to make it to this point in college and score a 4 on this test, points to a serious problem in this kid's noggin, whatever the cause. If he can't read, how will he learn a complicated NFL playbook. If you cannot answer that question yourself, you're seriously retarded.
NoSaint Posted April 4, 2012 Posted April 4, 2012 Ok, let's say he can't read. He supposedly made it through high school and college, yet he can't read? Doesn't that still suggest he has some sort of major learning disability at the very least, if not full fledged mental slowness? It also obviously suggests LSU was doing something less than legit to keep him in good academic standing. Well, if you go with the story released after the score, this was a learning disability diagnosed in highschool. I dont know specifically what it was, but depending on what it effects - it could be very specific to certain skills, like reading. im no expert, so im not going to diagnose anything on TBD. If its effects are primarily written language, its very possible that he is an absolute genius in other respects, but sitting down to try and fly through this test the page just looked liked scrambled letters, but when you hand him a playbook, the diagrams make absolute sense. From some very brief interviews with those close to him, it seems they all echo that he is bright, but handing him a book is not how you teach him. Hes very visual, so a lecture with diagrams would teach him material. As far as testing, depending on the coursework, you could do oral style exams for instance. there are all kinds of accomodations out there for disability - someone that cant see for instance would have some sort of testing accomodation that might be similar. I would understand any skepticism with athletes today and big football programs, so it could be a load of bull but who knows.
hondo in seattle Posted April 4, 2012 Posted April 4, 2012 This would be useful if thw wonderlic actually meant anything. But it doesnt. It's not a test of intelligence or smarts. It does nothing but test how well you take the wonderlic. Have you ever taken a Wonderlic? You are right when you say it only measures what it measure. Just like combine results. A 40 time doesn't tell you how well someone plays football. It only tells you how fast someone runs the 40. But I wouldn't sign a CB who runs a 5.5. I have taken a Wonderlic, btw, and I would be seriously concerned about any player scoring a 4. Did he even bother to try? Can he read? NFL playbooks aren't that simple (some old one are available online). You have to at least be able to read.
Recommended Posts