Jump to content

The great debate  

19 members have voted

  1. 1. Which would you like to see assuming we ARE taking a QB

    • Trade our 1, 2 and 3 to move up for Luck
      11
    • Settle for Newton (opr even trade back and still get him) and use our 2 and 3 to draft other positions
      8


Recommended Posts

Posted

…which would you prefer

 

Ok this is pure speculation and I would like to get everyone’s opinion on what would be the best way to go *IF* we take a QB in the 1st. According to the Draft Value trade chart it would take our 1st, second, and third to move up to #1.

 

Now I realize Carolina will likely not trade their pick, but a lot of posters use the logic of “We need OL/DL/LB and have Fitz for now so improve those positions don’t draft a QB” and I have to assume some Carolina fans have the same opinion. Luck is clearly the #1 player but if there is a somewhat close second that Carolina thinks they could land at 3 they may be ok with trading down.

 

So what would you rather see if you knew we were going to land a QB like Ralph said we were.

Posted

If we can't draft Luck at #3 (and we won't be able to -- not even sure he will come out) there is no way we should draft a QB at #3. We need to shore up our defense big time. I saw some posts about us taking the WR from Georgia. If we do that it will be more stupid that the Spiller pick of last year and that's saying something. Fix what is really broken and our defense is shattered into 1000 pieces. WR is not broken nearly as bad.

×
×
  • Create New...