Jump to content

Value Board 2010...........


Astrobot

Recommended Posts

Here is my Value Board for the first 5 Rounds for the Bills.

 

I have players ranked according to how much of a difference they would make within 2 years, and assuming no acquisitions or trades. I am doing this to stimulate talk about who you'd rank higher/lower, who you'd take off the list, or who you'd add. I have left off Suh, McCoy, Okung, etc. just because they won't be there when we draft. And no...I won't add any CB's or safeties, not even in RD7. Positions listed are ways different teams might employ them; I consider Derrick Morgan the only 4-3 player the Bills might take based on sheer athletic ability in any scheme. --Astro

 

ROUND 1

*Bryan Bulaga Iowa LT LG

Derrick Morgan Georgia Tech DE43

*Rolando McClain Alabama ILB OLB43

Brandon Graham Michigan DE43 OLB34

Trent Williams Oklahoma LT RT

Dan Williams Tennessee DT34 DT43

C.J. Spiller Clemson RBC KR

Jared Odrick Penn State DT43 DE34 DT34

*Jimmy Clausen Notre Dame QB

*Bruce Campbell Maryland OT

Mike Iupati Idaho OG OT

*Anthony Davis Rutgers OT

Sergio Kindle Texas OLB34 OLB43 DE43

 

ROUND 2

Terrence Cody Alabama DT34 DT43

Jerry Hughes TCU OLB34 DE43

Brandon Spikes Florida ILB OLB34

Charles Brown USC OT

John Jerry Mississippi OG OT

*Arrelious Benn Illinois WRF KR

Vladimir Ducasse Massachusetts OG

Rodger Saffold Indiana LT LG

Jared Veldheer Hillsdale OT

*Carlos Dunlap Florida DE43 DE34

 

ROUND 3

Dan LeFevour Central Michigan QB

Mardy Gilyard Cincinnati WRS KR

Taylor Price Ohio WRF

Jason Fox Miami OT

Cam Thomas North Carolina DT34 DT43

Matt Tennant Boston College OC OG

*Jason Worilds Virginia Tech DE43 OLB34

*Aaron Hernandez Florida TE

Tim Tebow Florida QB

Jon Asamoah Illinois OG OT

Jordan Shipley Texas WRS KR

*Demaryius Thomas Georgia Tech WRP

Eric Norwood South Carolina OLB43 ILB

Eric Decker Minnesota WRF

Mike Johnson Alabama OG

 

ROUND 4

*Linval Joseph East Carolina DT43 DE34

Ben Tate Auburn RBF

Dennis Pitta BYU TE

Mike Neal Purdue DT43 DE34

Tony Pike Cincinnati QB

Donald Butler Washington ILB

Selvish Capers West Virginia OT OG

Jermaine Cunningham Florida DE43 OLB34

Torrell Troup Central Florida DT43 DT34

J.D. Walton Baylor OC OG

Mitch Petrus Arkansas OG

Jeremy Williams Tulane WRF

Jarrett Brown West Virginia QB

Alex Carrington Arkansas State DE43 DE34

Andre Roberts Citadel WRS KR

Jamar Chaney Mississippi State ILB OLB43

Kyle Calloway Iowa OT

 

ROUND 5

Lindsey Witten Connecticut DE43 OLB34

Tony Washington Abilene Christian OT

Jeff Owens Georgia DT34 DT43

Riley Cooper Florida WRF

Arthur Jones Syracuse DT43 DE34

O'Brien Schofield Wisconsin OLB34 OLB43

Blair White Michigan State WRF

Ted Larsen North Carolina State OC OG

Clay Harbor Missouri State FB TE

Rahim Alem LSU DE43 OLB34

Shay Hodge Mississippi WRF

Garrett Graham Wisconsin TE

Pat Angerer Iowa ILB OLB43

Ciron Black LSU OT OG

Sergio Render Virginia Tech OG

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If any of these guys were left in Rd. 3 I would be the happiest Bills fan on earth. I think Norwood is going to be a very good pro and there is no doubt in my mind that he would beat out Maybin right now. I like Thomas but, is he a product of 9 in the box or is he always that wide open? I think Shipley is going to be great in the slot. Tebow is going to take time to develop (Captain obvious) but if a team can be patient and withstand the pressure of the fans and media to get him on the field, he might turn out to be a very good QB.

Norwood would be my pick, he's an OLB and worth 8-10 sacks in his first year.

ROUND 3

Tim Tebow Florida QB

Jordan Shipley Texas WRS KR

*Demaryius Thomas Georgia Tech WRP

Eric Norwood South Carolina OLB

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I know he had a down yr coming back from a knee injury but Corey Wootton (DE) out of NW could be a steal. I've seen him projected as a 3rd-4th. He's listed at 6'6" 280lb, and the dude has wheels.

 

Wootton is the enigma of this daft, IMHO. Somebody could grab him as early as RD2 (likely a team with fewer needs) because of his injuries. CBS lists him as 4th best DE and a probable 2nd round pick. WalterFootball has him as the 6th best DE. Other places have him in the 3rd round, Draft Countdown has him as the 7th best DE, and rated the #56 player in the draft, right after...Hughes and Norwood! We think he'll go to a 3-4 team as a DE rather than a LB. I have no memory why I deleted him from my spreadsheet. Tempted to put him in RD2.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I doubt these picks will be there in our picks but

 

1. *Bryan Bulaga Iowa LT LG

 

2. Charles Brown USC OT

 

3. Tim Tebow Florida QB

 

4. *Linval Joseph East Carolina DT43 DE34

 

5. Tony Washington Abilene Christian OT

 

I know that's a lot of OTs and a Boon bust type QB but a ten year fix on the OT position would be sweet, and as a 3rd rounder Tebow's upside far out weights the risk.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I doubt these picks will be there in our picks but

 

1. *Bryan Bulaga Iowa LT LG

 

2. Charles Brown USC OT

 

3. Tim Tebow Florida QB

 

4. *Linval Joseph East Carolina DT43 DE34

 

5. Tony Washington Abilene Christian OT

 

I know that's a lot of OTs and a Boon bust type QB but a ten year fix on the OT position would be sweet, and as a 3rd rounder Tebow's upside far out weights the risk.

 

3 are not that many when you need 2 ^^

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Here is my Value Board for the first 5 Rounds for the Bills.

 

I have players ranked according to how much of a difference they would make within 2 years,

 

 

 

It's interesting, Astro, but by ranking them by how much difference they would make within 2 years, you're shorting the QBs bigtime.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I doubt these picks will be there in our picks but

 

1. *Bryan Bulaga Iowa LT LG

 

2. Charles Brown USC OT

 

3. Tim Tebow Florida QB

 

4. *Linval Joseph East Carolina DT43 DE34

 

5. Tony Washington Abilene Christian OT

 

I know that's a lot of OTs and a Boon bust type QB but a ten year fix on the OT position would be sweet, and as a 3rd rounder Tebow's upside far out weights the risk.

 

:blink:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's interesting, Astro, but by ranking them by how much difference they would make within 2 years, you're shorting the QBs bigtime.

I have Clausen the 9th player I would pick in Round 1, and Bradford not on there because he's a false hope at #9. There ARE no other quarterbacks in this draft.

:blink:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...