manbeast Posted January 25, 2010 Posted January 25, 2010 You still haven't answered the question: which "real QB" do you take w/ the 9th overall pick? More than likely, neither Jimmy Clausen or Sam Bradford will be there. If they are not there that meens we have a shot at one of the top 2 OTs.
manbeast Posted January 25, 2010 Posted January 25, 2010 Lets really look at the Bills current situation. We need an offensive left tackle (pick 1) We need a right tackle (pick 2) we need a defensive tackle (pick 3) we need a defensive end if AS retires...and probably even if he doesn't retire (pick 4). These picks a must haves. Is Tebow going to drift down into the fifth round? I don't think so. We don't have the luxury to take a flyer on the guy. Some team in the late first or early to mid second will take him. I understand what your saying but did they cancel the free agency period.
cale Posted January 25, 2010 Posted January 25, 2010 I think you maybe right. But I would hate to use a #9 pick on a player who can't immediately contribute. But between the Gailey hire and Nix's Florida connections I wonder if they're putting things in place to design an offense around Tebow. When our pick comes around, I hope they survey the landscape and choose the best value lineman, preferably OL, at that position. If Bradford falls that far, I'd give it a long hard look. His injury history would give me pause. If not, I'd trade down for an extra 2nd. Pick a lineman. Then use both 2nds and trade back into the 1st for Tebow, if they're crazy about him. If not I'd go DL or LB next or hold for Pike or Tebow (if he falls that far). I personally don't think there's much to choose between the QBs after Bradford. I personally think the best value QB in this year's draft is Pike. If they friggin' pick McCoy I'll slit my wrists... I'd try and trade for McNabb for a 2nd or 3rd. Then use our first pick for a franchise LT. C
UpstateSwagger Posted January 25, 2010 Author Posted January 25, 2010 If tim tebeow was considered a first round draft pick he would not be playing in the senior bowl If he is playing in that game it means that who ever is advising him is being told that he has to do more than wht he did in college to get drafted early. Why wont you Tebow-holics let it go?!!! He does not have an NFL QB skillset. Hes a great kid and a tremendous competetor with a strong arm, but he is a project or a situational player at best. Sorry, but there are plenty of classy, athletic, competetive, strong armed guys in college football who didnt have the luxury of playing with "legitimate" NFL talent in front and behind him (see: Ken Dorsey, minus the strong arm). Look at Jake locker he is faster, bigger, plays in an pro-style offense but without the supporting cast he is on an average team, if Tebow played for U of Washington for the last four years no one is calling him the greatest college player of all time. I don't want Tebow at #9. I'll say it again: I could see it happening, and I presented why I think it could. But while we're on the subject, when will you Locker-holics shut it down? He's not even in the draft, and if he were, he would be drafted on pure speculation and potential because he hasn't done anything but lead a losing team in college. Gee whiz -- that sounds a heck of a lot like another west coast QB we've had starting on and off for a few years.
todzilla Posted January 25, 2010 Posted January 25, 2010 The entire landscape of the draft will start to clear up after the combine. We will find out about Bradford's shoulder and get a better idea about Tebow. I have to say the idea of Vick, Tebow, Jackson, and Lynch in the backfield with a run heavy offense and some timely passing is very intriguing.
Endless Ike Posted January 25, 2010 Posted January 25, 2010 The closer we get to the combine and draft, the more I sense momentum building amongst league personnel guys behind one Tim Tebow. I'm not even sure how this could be happening at this phase in the game because he hasn't done anything but train privately since the end of the season, so what gives? I believe what's going on is that people have had time to step back and really digest his college career, which in turn is causing them to see the sum of his parts (leadership, maturity, unique physical tools, production, etc.) instead of regurgitating Brian Billick's arm-slot, slow-motion breakdown from the Sugar Bowl. A strong Senior Bowl week, dozens of impressive one-on-one interviews, and the insane combine numbers this guy is inevitably going to put up will absolutely rocket the kid up some draft boards. Maybe not everyone's, but all it takes is one. Now, let's focus on the Bills current situation: We've got an ancient, set-in-his-ways, old school owner. An ancient, good ol' boy GM, who as a scout, valued QBs with over-the-top competitive drives (Brees, Rivers) and was willing to think outside the box and draft players who didn't fit the "prototypical NFL QB" (Brees because of his height and even Rivers to a certain extent because he had a bit of an unorthodox release point coming out of college). When you throw in our good ol' boy, southern HC who believes supremely in his ability to develop QB talent, I think we are looking at a recipe for Tebow to the Bills. Also, if you've watched ESPN today, I'm sure you've seen the numerous "Tebow updates." And that's just been for the Senior Bowl weigh-ins! He will obviously be a marketing department's dream no matter where he goes, but I think he would be particularly effective in a blue-collar region such as Western NY. Just a hunch and my two cents. That growing feeling must be a !@#$ing brain tumor, because you're hallucinating. Tebow sucks ass. Mark it down. His combine numbers are going to be pedestrian, and his skill-based workouts are going to show what we all know, a non-NFL calibre arm
Mickey Posted January 25, 2010 Posted January 25, 2010 Yeah God forbid we get a real QB behind center. I mean its been almost 15 years since we had one.... Tebow is not a real NFL QB. The NFL is littered with the wreckage of exceptional college QB's from top programs that were all hype and stats and no talent. Jerry Tagge, Gino Torretta, Eric Crouch, etc. Tebow is just the latest edition of the species. The Bills can't afford to gamble at this point. No pick is a sure thing but this guy comes with waaaaaaay more risk than any number of players we badly need.
nemhoff Posted January 25, 2010 Posted January 25, 2010 I have a feeling that whatever pick the raiders have in the first round will be spent on Tebow...cause Al Davis is that crazy
It's in My Blood Posted January 25, 2010 Posted January 25, 2010 Tebow is not a real NFL QB. The NFL is littered with the wreckage of exceptional college QB's from top programs that were all hype and stats and no talent. Jerry Tagge, Gino Torretta, Eric Crouch, etc. Tebow is just the latest edition of the species. The Bills can't afford to gamble at this point. No pick is a sure thing but this guy comes with waaaaaaay more risk than any number of players we badly need. Don't you guys know? Tim Tebow is DIVINE!
tonyjustbcuz Posted January 26, 2010 Posted January 26, 2010 The closer we get to the combine and draft, the more I sense momentum building amongst league personnel guys behind one Tim Tebow. I'm not even sure how this could be happening at this phase in the game because he hasn't done anything but train privately since the end of the season, so what gives? I believe what's going on is that people have had time to step back and really digest his college career, which in turn is causing them to see the sum of his parts (leadership, maturity, unique physical tools, production, etc.) instead of regurgitating Brian Billick's arm-slot, slow-motion breakdown from the Sugar Bowl. A strong Senior Bowl week, dozens of impressive one-on-one interviews, and the insane combine numbers this guy is inevitably going to put up will absolutely rocket the kid up some draft boards. Maybe not everyone's, but all it takes is one. Now, let's focus on the Bills current situation: We've got an ancient, set-in-his-ways, old school owner. An ancient, good ol' boy GM, who as a scout, valued QBs with over-the-top competitive drives (Brees, Rivers) and was willing to think outside the box and draft players who didn't fit the "prototypical NFL QB" (Brees because of his height and even Rivers to a certain extent because he had a bit of an unorthodox release point coming out of college). When you throw in our good ol' boy, southern HC who believes supremely in his ability to develop QB talent, I think we are looking at a recipe for Tebow to the Bills. Also, if you've watched ESPN today, I'm sure you've seen the numerous "Tebow updates." And that's just been for the Senior Bowl weigh-ins! He will obviously be a marketing department's dream no matter where he goes, but I think he would be particularly effective in a blue-collar region such as Western NY. Just a hunch and my two cents. Can he play in the snow, and cold Buffalo temperatures? I wouldn't think he was exposed to too much of that even though I know they play road games. I know Trent Edwards is always far less productive in poor weather conditions and wondered what conditions Tim Tebow may have played in and how he fared???
CarolinaBill Posted January 26, 2010 Posted January 26, 2010 as reported by witnesses at the senior bowl, tebow fumbled 7 of his first 10 snaps from under center, and scouts on hand believe his throwing motion cannot be fixed, compared to byron leftwich's throwing motion.
iinii Posted January 26, 2010 Posted January 26, 2010 I'm a fan of Tebow and his college career however I never thought much of him on the NFL level. That being said I've started to warm up to the idea of the Bills drafting him and this post is precisely why. The kid knows how to win, most Bills fans forget what that looks like on a player. He reminds me of Doug Flutie in Donovan McNabbs body and who wouldn't want that monster starting for their team? Interesting
Big Turk Posted January 26, 2010 Posted January 26, 2010 I hope that 9th pick goes toward the much needed pick of a offensive tackle QB Had to correct that one...
aristocrat Posted January 26, 2010 Posted January 26, 2010 i dont think the bills are in a position to take a risk on a guy like tebow. we need to fix the line with a tackle and a playmaking mlb to solidify our defense...then next year we take the move and get the qb
zazie Posted January 26, 2010 Posted January 26, 2010 Just my opinion, but if I were the Bills' GM and inclined to trade up, it would be for someone like OT Russell Okung or DT Ndamukong Suh. I would get stronger up front FIRST before I did anything. The Jets took this approach, drafting D'Brickashaw Ferguson, then Nick Mangold and adding Alan Faneca in free agency. They did not keep using high pick after high pick on skill players and leave the lines to the wolves. Then again, maybe there's some great second round gems to be had for the lines, after we get a QB first. Oops, we said trade up for a QB, right? There goes that 2nd rounder and, depending on the target and how far you have to move to get 'em, there may go a future high pick as well. Well, there's always the 4th round and beyond. The Bills will never trade up in the draft because they don't want to pay more to the rookie they would get. If anything look for the Bills to trade down this year pick up a couple extra picks.
CarolinaBill Posted January 26, 2010 Posted January 26, 2010 The Bills will never trade up in the draft because they don't want to pay more to the rookie they would get. If anything look for the Bills to trade down this year pick up a couple extra picks. agreed, plus we need to get more "bang for the buck" so to speak, and have a few holes to fill
billsfan714 Posted January 26, 2010 Posted January 26, 2010 Yeah looks like he struggled pretty bad, KFFL also said he had a lot of wild throws: http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2010/...at-senior-bowl/
Bufcomments Posted January 26, 2010 Posted January 26, 2010 You forgot one point in your analysis. Ticket sales. Good or bad, Tebow will sell tickets....ooodles of them. I believe the "noise" around Tebow this week will be deafening. If you add in outstanding combine scores this kids is going to ROCKET up the draft charts. I'd still rather have McClain but I don't get to make the pick. Tebow is going to Jacksonville to sell tickets for the franchise. End of story, lets move on.
Thurman#1 Posted January 26, 2010 Posted January 26, 2010 One of them will be there and if not, trade up for once. One of them will be there? It's possible, but highly unlikely (unless Bradford isn't recovered from his injury ... would you take him then?) Trade up? Yeah, because we don't have lots of needs. We can afford to give up the high draft picks it would take to move up. This isn't going to be easy. I like both QBs and wouldn't oppose trading up, but that would essentially mean at least another year of being really really bad.
Thurman#1 Posted January 26, 2010 Posted January 26, 2010 Trust me... there ain't a franchise QB in this draft. Aside from Braford (who is as brittle as fine chrystal), the talent out there isn't any better than what's on the Bills roster now. Besides... If Bills bring in another young QB and his blind side isn't protected they've just screwed their investment at QB. Bills need a lot more man at both tackles than they have now. But their greatest need is left tackle. No matter how many great skill position players they have, without competence up front, they are toast. Clausen and Bradford both look legit. But because of that, they're unlikely to be available at #9.
Recommended Posts