jtl3302 Posted December 22, 2009 Posted December 22, 2009 If they ever brought Jason Campbell to Buffalo, I might burn all my Bills memorabilia and finally give up on them after over 35 years of being a die hard fan. He sucks-plain and simple. Giving up a 1st round pick to get Rob Johnson after one start or trading back into 1st round to get JP didn't do it? wow!!
billsfreak Posted December 22, 2009 Posted December 22, 2009 Giving up a 1st round pick to get Rob Johnson after one start or trading back into 1st round to get JP didn't do it? wow!! The difference in those two deals, we didn't know how terrible they were when we signed them (there was actually hope), we already know that Campbell is pathetic and they still make the deal? Wow, so obvious.
jtl3302 Posted December 22, 2009 Posted December 22, 2009 The difference in those two deals, we didn't know how terrible they were when we signed them (there was actually hope), we already know that Campbell is pathetic and they still make the deal? Wow, so obvious. I guess i wouldn't give up a 1st on hope after one start. Also, doubt we would have to give up anything for Campbell. If he's as bad as you say, he'll be released and we get him for free. More hope in Campbell continuing to progress and possibly becoming a good QB than any other vets out there.
Thirty Year Fan Posted December 22, 2009 Posted December 22, 2009 Campbell is terrible. Just another Rob Johnson or Kyle Boller who has a good strong arm but nothing else. Sorry, but no thanks.Total agreement!
billieve420 Posted December 22, 2009 Posted December 22, 2009 I'd give Tavaris Jackson a shot too. .....again not many options.  Campbell is the Trent Edwards of the NFC. I don't want him on the team but Tavaris Jackson is interesting. Now I don't view him as the long term solution but with an O-line in flux he could fit in well as a stop gap. He is able to make plays with his feet and if we can design an offense that fits his skill set instead of trying to fit players into our rigid system it might work out.
peanuts Posted December 22, 2009 Posted December 22, 2009 The Bills should try to get David Carr. He has 8 years in the league and played behind a terrible line early in his career, now he has sat behind Eli for about 4 years and can make all the throws. I think if he has the protection he could be the comeback player and the QB who was drafted #1 for a reason. We really don't have much to lose, sign him cheap...
Red Posted December 22, 2009 Posted December 22, 2009 No thanks, thats like patching a compound fracture with an ace bandage. He may be better than the guys we have now, but he is so inconsistent, he makes some terrible throws and looks lost at times. Â Could not agree more. Â Campbell has not yet demonstrated any qualities that would warrant him being a franchise-type of guy. He is the same as what we currently have on our roster. Â Now that Washington has a real GM, the offseason and what Campbell's role will be next year with the 'Skins (if he even has one) will be telling of how talented he truly is. Allen has been behind the construction of 2 different Super Bowl teams (Raiders and Bucs) and I was sincerely hoping that the Bills would have gotten him. Â Now that Cleveland has Holmgren, what the heck is Brandon doing? Â I will say, if we are talking about ridiculous extremes, I would rather have Campbell than Vick.
PromoTheRobot Posted December 22, 2009 Posted December 22, 2009 The Bills should try to get David Carr. He has 8 years in the league and played behind a terrible line early in his career, now he has sat behind Eli for about 4 years and can make all the throws. I think if he has the protection he could be the comeback player and the QB who was drafted #1 for a reason. We really don't have much to lose, sign him cheap... Yeah! Let's get a QB who sucked for 8 years. He's bound to snap out of his funk in Buffalo. For cripes sake can't we talk about actual good QBs??? Â PTR
Beebe's Kid Posted December 22, 2009 Posted December 22, 2009 The Bills should try to get David Carr. He has 8 years in the league and played behind a terrible line early in his career, now he has sat behind Eli for about 4 years and can make all the throws. I think if he has the protection he could be the comeback player and the QB who was drafted #1 for a reason. We really don't have much to lose, sign him cheap... Yes! I agree with this pick up. Carr and Brohm in camp for the spot. Â I wouldn't mind Jackson either, but Minnesota might be reluctant to let him go when Favre starts doing the annual "Should I stay or should I go?" routine....which is closely followed by "I'm going," and all of the highlight reals and tears shed, then "I'm back," followed by a bunch of jersey sales and an impeccable first half of the season....and so it goes. For what it's worth, Jackson had 9 TD to 1 INT last year. Â Campbell, while I am intrigued at a QB not named Fitzy or Edwards, I think I would look elsewhere. Â If posters are correct, and Cleveland actually lets Quinn go, that would be another interesting pick up.
Phlegm Alley Posted December 22, 2009 Posted December 22, 2009 Yeah! Let's get a QB who sucked for 8 years. He's bound to snap out of his funk in Buffalo. For cripes sake can't we talk about actual good QBs??? PTR   People are just trying to throw a bunch of sh*t up against the wall, just to see what sticks.
Sisyphean Bills Posted December 22, 2009 Posted December 22, 2009 Gag. Â Campbell makes Fitzpatrick look like a sharpshooter.
todzilla Posted December 22, 2009 Posted December 22, 2009 Yes! I agree with this pick up. Carr and Brohm in camp for the spot. Â I wouldn't mind Jackson either, but Minnesota might be reluctant to let him go when Favre starts doing the annual "Should I stay or should I go?" routine....which is closely followed by "I'm going," and all of the highlight reals and tears shed, then "I'm back," followed by a bunch of jersey sales and an impeccable first half of the season....and so it goes. For what it's worth, Jackson had 9 TD to 1 INT last year. Â Campbell, while I am intrigued at a QB not named Fitzy or Edwards, I think I would look elsewhere. Â If posters are correct, and Cleveland actually lets Quinn go, that would be another interesting pick up. Â Seems like Quinn has been playing pretty well lately. Anderson is more likely to be available. If the Jags draft Tebow like everyone seems to think they will, I'd like to give Garrard a shot. Not a pro bowl guy, but he's played pretty well without a ton of receiving talent.
VADC Bills Posted December 22, 2009 Posted December 22, 2009 You have lost your mind. Have you seen Campbell play at all over the last 4 years? I live in VA and the Skins are on TV EVERY week. I have watched them play countless times, even though I didn't really want to. He is erratic at best. He does have a strong arm, but is very inaccurate on deep passes. I have seen him consistently overthrow wide open WR's. Santana Moss has great speed and Randle El is pretty fast as well, but he couldn't hit them on the fly. The line in Washington this year is horrible, but it hasn't always been that way. He still hasn't ever been able to get it done. He was benched in favor of Todd Collins two years ago when they actually made a playoff run. He has done nothing and is no better than a journeyman backup in this league. Sadly, he's likely better than anyone we have though. We need a QB who is consistently accurate on every level of throws from the short, to the intermediate, and the deep. We need a leader who can get it done on the field and rally the troops. Campbell is not that guy. Total agreement. Looking at last nights game against the Giants you can easily say he has a bad line in front of him...and he does. This is his 4th year and his first 3 years his line was pretty good. He is slow to read the defense and doesn't have good pocket presence. Collins is actually the better qb but is not considered the future. I think Campbell is a solid second string qb. In practice he can do it all...he tends to get stumped when another team lines up opposite him. I have seasons ticket to the Redskins games and what you can't see on tv is the missed opportunities because he doesn't see the field well. The skins burned a draft pick moving up to get him and he has yet to deliver.
Mr. WEO Posted December 22, 2009 Posted December 22, 2009 Shocking. Who would you go after in FA? Garcia. Absolutley. The guy is smart and tough. He's been around a long time and can teach a young QB something. He's unemployed and will come cheap. Â Easy decision.
NobesBLO13 Posted December 22, 2009 Posted December 22, 2009 Seems like Quinn has been playing pretty well lately. Anderson is more likely to be available. If the Jags draft Tebow like everyone seems to think they will, I'd like to give Garrard a shot. Not a pro bowl guy, but he's played pretty well without a ton of receiving talent. Totally agree, Garrard isn't a world beater but he's a solid starter who doesn't turn over the ball. He'd be a very good stop gap option who's taken a team to the playoffs.
Fingon Posted December 22, 2009 Posted December 22, 2009 Seems like Quinn has been playing pretty well lately. Anderson is more likely to be available. If the Jags draft Tebow like everyone seems to think they will, I'd like to give Garrard a shot. Not a pro bowl guy, but he's played pretty well without a ton of receiving talent. If the Jags draft Tebow, there is no way they cut Garrard. Tebow is no where near ready to be an NFL QB.
Magox Posted December 22, 2009 Posted December 22, 2009 If the Jags draft Tebow, there is no way they cut Garrard. Tebow is no where near ready to be an NFL QB. If he was available in the second round, I'd seriously consider him. Guys like Vick and Young were criticized for not having good throwing mechanics, but they were leaders and winners in college and they translated that success into the NFL, and I believe Tebow fits in that same mold.
Fingon Posted December 22, 2009 Posted December 22, 2009 If he was available in the second round, I'd seriously consider him. Guys like Vick and Young were criticized for not having good throwing mechanics, but they were leaders and winners in college and they translated that success into the NFL, and I believe Tebow fits in that same mold. How many years did it take Young to become a decent QB though? He should never have seen the field until his 4th year. However, to say that Tebow and VY/MV are in the same mold is stupid. These guys are elusive runners, which helps them avoid big hits... while Tebow runs like a fullback. That is a recipe for being injured.
evilcape Posted December 22, 2009 Posted December 22, 2009 If Philly does want some people expect and start the Kolb era, i think giving philly marshawn and a 2nd for McNabb would be a great move. I want the bills to draft Pike or someone of high playing caliber. McNabb would start for 2 years for us and train the rookie. Groom him to be the Franchise QB. If we can't get McNabb and Campbell is available i would deffenently target him in FA. Fitzpatrick can stick around for our third stringer. Edwards bye bye.
Recommended Posts