Who would you rather have as GM.

[PIZ]

I have been disappointed in Donahoe for awhile. I have to admit, though, I was extremely excited to get him in Buffalo, as I thought he was the reason the Steelers were so successful. But, this guy in New England, seems to be special, and he knows how a Championship Team is built. Would he keep Mularkey or bring Weiss or Crennel with him?

 

Scott Pioli---future GM?

[Rico]

I miss Bill Polian.

[PIZ]

I miss Bill Polian.

120466[/snapback]

 

Dwight Smith (I think that's his name) is doing pretty well in San Diego, though I have no idea what he's going to do with Rivers/Brees.

[Toledo Bill]

Dwight Smith (I think that's his name) is doing pretty well in San Diego, though I have no idea what he's going to do with Rivers/Brees.

120471[/snapback]

 

Bill Polian mentored John Butler who mentored A.J. Smith

 

Tom Donahoe mentored himself to be a politician and not a strong GM/President

[Guest Guest]

I miss Bill Polian.

120466[/snapback]

 

 

Yes because the Colts have been to way more Super Bowls then the Bills....Oh wait he overspent on his offense for so long that they did not have a defense..

 

 

 

 

 

Geesh

[Toledo Bill]

Yes because the Colts have been to way more Super Bowls then the Bills....Oh wait he overspent on his offense for so long that they did not have a defense..

Geesh

120496[/snapback]

 

Yeah, well I miss Polian too. They are contenders even with a crappy defense. He is a proven top flight GM.

[R. Rich]

Given the choice of Polian or Donahoe, I'm sure many would rather have Polian. I know I would. At least he'd address the offensive line with a bit more effort than Donahoe.

[Steven in MD]

Can anyone give me a GM (not a coach/GM) who is worse than Donahoe? I would take Polian, Pioli, Smith, Millen or Casserly over Donahoe.