BrooklynBills

Remember when Brian Brohm was the surefire 1st overall pick. Or Matt Leinhart. Or Matt Barkley. Can't plan for two years from now.

And this is exactly why Rex was fired. They were paying him 5.5 million for his defense and for him to run it. Not for him to just be the HC and let someone else run the defense. I think Rob is probably still a good position coach but as a game day play caller and strategist, his record speaks for itself.

You do realize that none of the QBs that you mentioned played on the same respective teams, right? It kind of buries the point that you were trying to make.

HC: Lynn OC possibilities: Matt Nagy(Chiefs); Alex Van Pelt(Packers); Matt LaFleur(Falcons)-my fav vet QB: Nick Foles rookie QB: DeShone Kizer in 1st or Brad Kaaya in 2nd

I agree. I think they decided on both Rex and Lynn at the beginning of the season or at least had this scenario in mind after game 2. I think it should be obvious now that Rex and Tyrod were connected together. These are all of the offensive influences in Anthony Lynn's career before Greg Roman: Mike Shanahan Marc Trestman Gary Kubiak Bill Musgrave Sean Payton Todd Haley Rob Chudzinski Brian Schottenheimer Marty Morningweg They all believe in a precision timing offense. I would guess that Lynn also does. I would guess that he doesn't think Taylor could run an offense like that. But there is a guy in the draft who is perfectly suited to: Brad Kaaya. Him plus a vet UFA like Nick Foles are probably in the plans if Lynn takes over.

Except no one questioned Russell Wilson's ability to read defenses, anticipate throws, or run an offense in college. They literally just questioned his height and if a player of his size could play QB in the NFL.

By all accounts, Whaley is under contract for the next 3 years. I think details of expectations and Whaley's job security would be ironed out during interview process. Retaining Whaley means that they like the roster at this time. But I think what Polian means is that taking this job means that you need to hit the ground running with this team or it could mean everyone is fired and you are a 1-and-done coach. There is a very real similar scenario that coaches can look to in the recent past that would make anyone nervous about this job and that is what happened in Miami after Nick Saban quit. The Dolphins had a disappointing season but faced a somewhat unexpected coaching search with a GM that was previously not the main decision maker in the franchise in Randy Mueller. They hired Cam Cameron, they went 1-15, ownership brought in Bill Parcells as a consultant, and everyone was fired. In fact, this era in Dolphins front office history is so very similar to this era in Bills front office history. When Saban quit, they did not have anyone in the building that they trusted to lead the organization. Dan Marino and Don Shula had team roles during the coaching search which included Mike Tomlin, Ron Rivera, and Pete Carroll. They interviewed 12 people. Wayne Huzienga, their team President, and the team CEO lead the search with input from Dan Marino(this is after his extremely short run as a FO exec) and Don Shula. They eventually blew it up and brought in a consultant. People from afar can see that happening here. Maybe it won't happen here. You don't know for sure. Maybe Whaley and Monos are really great at being team architects and find the right guy for the Bills. Maybe they've stumbled on a great find in Anthony Lynn. Maybe it all works out. I don't know, but that's a lot of maybes. Most likely though, we are here doing this again in a year or two with a new FO.

I think Rex goes to TV for 2-3 years and either becomes a huge hit and outgrows the need to go back to the NFL or has a renaissance as a premier DC in the league for a few years.

Mike Nolan makes alot of sense there

Defensive retooling. Long term Offensive rebuild. But we are not at expansion level as some here would think. Keep Kromer at OL coach and make him fixture regardless of who we bring in to run offense.

None of those things you mention really make me think that Swinney would transition better to the NFL than Shaw. I don't care about their "big game" record, or even that Clemson is in the title game again. I think Shaw's demeanor, coaching style, and NFL connections would make him a great NFL coach.

He's great in college because he is one of the best recruiters in the nation. I agree that he's a guy players could potentially rally behind but IMO his best asset as a coach would be nullified in the NFL. I think he would be over his head with regards to building a staff and game planning. If we are talking college coaches, I think there only a few guys that I'm really interested in and they aren't leaving: Jim Harbaugh Nick Saban David Shaw David Shaw would be a great NFL coach. Good motivator. Great Xs and Os offense. History of developing some good to great players. Access to both Harbaugh's coaching network, which is extensive. Access to ex-Ravens, ex-Eagles, ex-49ers personnel department. IMO, he'd be the next great guy to jump to the NFL and lead a whole organization, top to bottom.

I would not read too much into where the interviews are taking place.

Pepper Johnson played OLB in NFL. Coached OLBs/DEs in NE. Coached 43 D-Line here. All of the Jets D-Linemen are 300 lb-ers. Jets have talent on defense but their defensive roster is odd.

Both Pats coaches are being interviewed by every team except us it seems. Same with Shanahan.

No. More like: if you don't talk to me, I'll be forced to use what little info I have to go to build a story. It's always better to have open dialogue with the media. The problem here is that the teams have been bad for a while or made decisions which were rightly criticized in the media and the teams took their ball and went home. They didn't want to take responsibility for their failures in the press.

Was team president in Jacksonville

Gotta be a typo. He surely means offensive staff. Right?

This list is very underwhelming. Throw a !@#$ing dart.

They are being criticized because they are handling this situation very poorly and because there is a glaring lack of transparency regarding who makes decisions, organizational structure, and team vision. With regards to him talking to Wawrow: It was a week after they had fired Ryan, allowing them the time to craft their own story as to how everything went down. They are not getting ripped on a local level. They are being criticized nationally.

I agree. They are doing what should have been done when Marrone quit. People are mad for two reasons now: 1. The optics are terrible. Someone posted that all this would be fine if Pegula had simply discussed this the day of the firing or even the Wednesday before Anthony Lynn gave his PC. That is true. Maybe they don't care how it looks, but I think they owe it to the fan base to at least not LOOK like a dysfunctional mess. 2. We've had two more years of underwhelming Doug Whaley drafts and seemingly poor contract decisions to have any faith in his ability to find a good coach moving forward or set a plan for success in motion. Those are legitimate reasons to be pissed as Bills fans.

I had to laugh when Donald Jones said that GMs in this league really don't make big decisions and that they all are at the whim of ownership. I don't know how he say that and keep from laughing.

This should be tagged or something and we can keep adding to it. There are literally so many that you forget about little things like Mike Williams or going into the 2nd Marrone training camp with EJ, Thad Lewis, and Jeff Tuel at QB.

Not fair to evaluate Lynn on one game. But that's also why I don't like interim coaches getting the head job. Interim coach is more like a lifetime achievement award. They rarely ever are the best candidates for the job though.

He had a heart attack during a game 3 years ago. Missed a game due to health reasons this year. He's accomplished everything he's needed to in his career.