I pretty much totally agree... I do however think their talent has been more on the average side, especially the past couple years and the depth has pretty much failed most tests. I've said before it's a coaching, scheme, talent combo crap-sandwich on Defense...
The thing that was mentioned in this thread previously that really nails it was the Simms comments on how offenses have figured out exactly where to go against our Defensive zone, and most of the time it's with the primary option so that pass is out fast. So, on those plays we have zero chance to get to the QB. And teams have been mixing in a screen or two as well that just kill us. These factors have murdered us on 3rd down. And if anyone wants a heart attack just go look at team Defense 3rd down efficiency this year, and especially in the last 3 games... Holy hellfire it's bad. Defense on skates is a great way to describe our 3rd down D... It's brutal...
The good news is I really believe this years team is the best chance we have yet to score 40 points in 3 straight games in the Playoffs. And the D will turn it over a couple times to help. But otherwise I think we're cooked on that side of the ball... I've pretty much felt that way for a while now. Just don't want to be overtly negative all the time...